-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 12
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 11 Winner: denisp
Tippett Multi Club Trade
- Thread starter Glenelgcrow
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
PykeDream
Only the Betts
- Sep 2, 2011
- 4,700
- 1,902
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
If West Coast were involved would you agree to:
Lycett + Pick 8
If West Coast were involved would you agree to:
Lycett + Pick 8
Put in other thread but how would we view:
Tippett + Douglas for Redden + Polec?
OR
Tippett + 24 for Redden + 8?
The only reason i add another of our players in the mix is Brisbane would be loathe to give both players without a decent mid in return. For mine, Douglas is a poor mans Redden so makes up for the mid shortfall but also our shortfall in giving away the most valuable of the 4 players listed above.
Not sure which of the 2 options above I'd prefer...probably the first one as i really think we could do with Polec's outside run and skill, though his defensive side may worry Sando.
Tippett + Douglas for Redden + Polec?
OR
Tippett + 24 for Redden + 8?
The only reason i add another of our players in the mix is Brisbane would be loathe to give both players without a decent mid in return. For mine, Douglas is a poor mans Redden so makes up for the mid shortfall but also our shortfall in giving away the most valuable of the 4 players listed above.
Not sure which of the 2 options above I'd prefer...probably the first one as i really think we could do with Polec's outside run and skill, though his defensive side may worry Sando.
His opinion on what they will feel like when Adelaide pips them at the post for Brad Ebert?!
If we are talking about using the infamous pick 24 here, I'd prefer Howard if possible.
I'd probably be in the minority but i wouldn't bother getting Ebert...just a quicker, younger Symes.
A Port official knows the finer details of the Tippett trade, good to see the break has done you good
birdmanptr
Norm Smith Medallist
His opinion on what they will feel like when Adelaide pips them at the post for Brad Ebert?!
WCE want Ports pick 28 or 2 pick in the 30s. They have one in the 30s and are trying to get the 2nd one.
birdmanptr
Norm Smith Medallist
It's not like deals being talked about are top secret.
Bullshit, otherwise you would have clubs out maneuvering each other left right and centre
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
Excellent point...and I'm not sure that McKernan will ever be up to that level. If he had a half of Tippett's intensity then maybe but he just seems so docile.
Excellent point...and I'm not sure that McKernan will ever be up to that level. If he had a half of Tippett's intensity then maybe but he just seems so docile.
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
Am i missing something with Ebert?
I'd only rate him as blunt steak knives at best.
Lycett and Redden would have to spark interest though, as you would hope one of Lycett or McKernan would end up being a reasonable replacement for Tippett.
Am i missing something with Ebert?
I'd only rate him as blunt steak knives at best.
Lycett and Redden would have to spark interest though, as you would hope one of Lycett or McKernan would end up being a reasonable replacement for Tippett.
birdmanptr
Norm Smith Medallist
Language. Any hoo I don't care just passing on what I heard.
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
Redden, 8 and Lycett would not happen, maybe Lycett, 8 and Koby Stevens (OR Rischitelli Compo Pick-Either West Coast would get the Compo for Stevens or we get the compo) for Tippett and pick 35 (To the lions)
Redden, 8 and Lycett would not happen, maybe Lycett, 8 and Koby Stevens (OR Rischitelli Compo Pick-Either West Coast would get the Compo for Stevens or we get the compo) for Tippett and pick 35 (To the lions)
Haven't you got 8 more days?
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
We wouldn't get Lycett, Redden and a mid-round pick IMO
Lycett and Redden we might get though. Ebert was just the steak knives to balance it.
We wouldn't get Lycett, Redden and a mid-round pick IMO
Lycett and Redden we might get though. Ebert was just the steak knives to balance it.
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
Tippett for 8 and polec offer from lions would make me sit down with tips with a contract extension. He signs, he stays. He declines, pull the trigger.
Tippett for 8 and polec offer from lions would make me sit down with tips with a contract extension. He signs, he stays. He declines, pull the trigger.
- Banned
- #518
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
Completely agree.
If Brisbane dont offer something exceptional deal wont happen.
Brisb are probably prepared to offer 2 first rounders and an average player.
we probably want more...
Its a matter of how far brisbane are prepared to go to get Tippet?
They are desperate for someone like him but cant see them trading Redden or even Polec.
Completely agree.
If Brisbane dont offer something exceptional deal wont happen.
Brisb are probably prepared to offer 2 first rounders and an average player.
we probably want more...
Its a matter of how far brisbane are prepared to go to get Tippet?
They are desperate for someone like him but cant see them trading Redden or even Polec.
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
This seems very logical and would be the approach I would take
This seems very logical and would be the approach I would take
The Tippett trade is not going to happen.
- Moderator
- #522
Re: Brad Crouch and Luke Brown...
This I agree with
If Brisbane come to us with pick 8 + Redden or Polec for Tippett, I'd sit down with Tipp and find out what he wants to do and put an extension before him if he doesnt want to sign it then pull the trigger on the trade. I honestly wouldnt be surprised if Crazy Vossy were to offer us that type of deal late on Monday.
This I agree with
If Brisbane come to us with pick 8 + Redden or Polec for Tippett, I'd sit down with Tipp and find out what he wants to do and put an extension before him if he doesnt want to sign it then pull the trigger on the trade. I honestly wouldnt be surprised if Crazy Vossy were to offer us that type of deal late on Monday.
Hollow Knight
Imperfect vessel
- May 3, 2005
- 96,577
- 106,995
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Other Teams
- Scuderia Ferrari, Dallas Cowboys
- Feb 3, 2004
- 17,999
- 24,204
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- panthers, ukraine & broncos
Anyone else get the impression that Brisbane kept asking at the start of trade week and our simple "no", as reported, was being ignored? So in order to stop the asking, we turned around and gave a scenario where we might consider the trade, knowing that what we were asking was very, very high and was pretty much a hypothetical?
Brisbane have gotten to save face with their fans, as they say they tried but Adelaide were unreasonable.
Brisbane have gotten to save face with their fans, as they say they tried but Adelaide were unreasonable.
Yep!
That is exactly how I read it! Its like having this nagging kid bugging at you to go to the park for kick an a catch on a day when its pissing down. Then you tell them if they clean their room, eat all their veggies, brush their teeth and read a book for an hour you would do it! Except its too high a price for them to pay so they just find something else to entertain themselves with.
- Status
