What is your ex-GWS player success ratio?

[FurTheWin]

Yeah, good call. Leon Cameron would be an upgrade on Chris.

Uh huh
Leon "Mr September" Cameron

 

[Hawk Dork]

Leon should never been given the keys to the Ferrari .....going backwards is not the way its supposed to go

 

[HairyO]

We seem to be 75% good, 25% bad with the plastic frachise club discards.

Scrimshaw looks to be an absolute gun. O'Rourke simply couldnt play at AFL level without getting injured.

 

[BloodRet]

Shaun Edwards was a great coup

 

[Saveloy Rockstar]

To be taken seriously you would have to add/subtract your GCS players. Otherwise it’s like leaving University out

 

[Mofra]

To be taken seriously you would have to add/subtract your GCS players. Otherwise it’s like leaving University out

Done.

Gold Coast Suns to Bulldogs: Zero to date.

100% confirmed

 

[September Action]

I'll start: Bulldogs - 100% (Tom Boyd)

Likely just a usual Mofra troll rather than anything serious

Mofra self guzzle more like it.

(Nb Collingwood 100%)

 

[Mofra]

(Nb Collingwood 100%)

Will Hoskin-Elliot - 0 premierships
Taylor Adams - 0 premierships
Adam Treloar - 0 premierships

You still have time but it's not looking good at the minute.

 

[Mofra]

Look, I'll be even kinder - Essendon fans can count any winning finals game.

 

[Santoz]

Look, I'll be even kinder - Essendon fans can count any winning finals game.

No Devon Smith & Dylan Shiel in your Best 22?

 

[Mofra]

No Devon Smith & Dylan Shiel in your Best 22?

It wasn't my best 22, and it was from a couple of years ago. They'd be in it. Not sure we'll see them win in finals for a couple of years though.

 

[Santoz]

It wasn't my best 22, and it was from a couple of years ago. They'd be in it. Not sure we'll see them win in finals for a couple of years though.

Is Shiel injured?

 

[About Blank]

Premiership hero Jacob Townsend should be on the field.

Boydy and Towna would carry that side. Proven winners.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Will be 100% when Cameron makes his move to the Cats next year

Not sure SCAblett would want a decent forward to crowd him out.

 

[FurTheWin]

Not sure SCAblett would want a decent forward to crowd him out.

Yeah, because those two would be competing for the same spot

Ah man, Tomahawk, Big Sav, Cameron + Miers, Gaz, Rohan, Narkle + the middies kicking a few
I can't see Geelong averaging less than 120 a game next year

 

[AFDogs]

FB: Sam Frost (Melb) 5, Lachie Plowman (Carl) 6, Jack Hombsch (PA) 6
HB: Kristian Jaksch (Carl) 1, Caleb Marchbank (Carl) 5, Tom Bugg (Melb) 3
C: Jack Steele (STK) 7, Taylor Adams (Coll) 8, Anthony Miles (Rich) 3
HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott (Coll) 6, Tom Boyd (WB) 4, Jono O’Rourke (Haw) 3
FF: Liam Sumner (Carl) who?, Josh Bruce (STK) 7, Cam McCarthy (Fre) 2
Foll: Andrew Phillips (Carl) who?, Adam Treloar (Coll) 8, Dom Tyson (Melb) 3
I/C: Jacob Townsend (Rich) 5, Jonathan Giles (WCE) 2, Jarrod Pickett (Carl) 2, Curtly Hampton (Adel) 2

I've given each a rating /10.

Collingwood have done the best out of the GWS pickups, but no flag. #SoDogsWinLol

 

[AvantGardener]

Probably, but he is Leeton’s favourite son.
It makes me wonder, whose playing career would you prefer? Lids, who won’t ever play in a flag side, or Towno?

I thought Leetons favourite son was a 3 way tie between O'Garey, Hodge and Matt Smith? Jonty Rowe did have them covered until a few years ago.

Hopper will be soon though

 

[AvantGardener]

FB: Sam Frost (Melb) 5, Lachie Plowman (Carl) 6, Jack Hombsch (PA) 6
HB: Kristian Jaksch (Carl) 1, Caleb Marchbank (Carl) 5, Tom Bugg (Melb) 3
C: Jack Steele (STK) 7, Taylor Adams (Coll) 8, Anthony Miles (Rich) 3
HF: Will Hoskin-Elliott (Coll) 6, Tom Boyd (WB) 4, Jono O’Rourke (Haw) 3
FF: Liam Sumner (Carl) who?, Josh Bruce (STK) 7, Cam McCarthy (Fre) 2
Foll: Andrew Phillips (Carl) who?, Adam Treloar (Coll) 8, Dom Tyson (Melb) 3
I/C: Jacob Townsend (Rich) 5, Jonathan Giles (WCE) 2, Jarrod Pickett (Carl) 2, Curtly Hampton (Adel) 2

I've given each a rating /10.

Collingwood have done the best out of the GWS pickups, but no flag. #SoDogsWinLol

Lol Marchbank is better than Plowman you flogsticle. Good ratings flogtard plus Andrew Phillips is the guy who got a career high hitouts against your mob last season!

 

[Mofra]

Is Shiel injured?

No, but he plays for Essendon so no chance for a finals win.

 

[Mofra]

Lol Marchbank is better than Plowman you flogsticle. Good ratings flogtard plus Andrew Phillips is the guy who got a career high hitouts against your mob last season!

How many flags have they won?

Swapping zero for zero still gives you zero.

 

[Santoz]

How many flags have they won?

Swapping zero for zero still gives you zero.

I like Essendon's success ratio with the Dogs though

Stewart Crameri for the Dogs pick #26 = Zach Merrett

 

[Mofra]

I like Essendon's success ratio with the Dogs though

Stewart Crameri for the Dogs pick #26 = Zach Merrett

Zach Merret - zero flags. Zero finals wins.

Terrible attempt at deflection. Try to stay on topic. I've told you 104 times.

 

[Santoz]

Zach Merret - zero flags. Zero finals wins.

Terrible attempt at deflection. Try to stay on topic. I've told you 104 times.

This thread has 2 pages in 5 days. Any contribution I make either on topic or not seems desperately needed

 

[Mofra]

This thread has 2 pages in 5 days. Any contribution I make either on topic or not seems desperately needed

Quality > quantity. That's actually the point, otherwise Carlton would be leading any success measure of ex-GWS players.

 

[Santoz]

Quality > quantity. That's actually the point, otherwise Carlton would be leading any success measure of ex-GWS players.

Is that the Dogs measure for premierships?