Recent content by cbrendan

  1. C

    Position 2024 Rookies

    Why does sweet have to come in for Livingstone? Though the magic of DPP you can bring sweet in for anyone, shift Livingstone forward for a few weeks, then cash out Sweet in a month and shift Livingstone back.
  2. C

    Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Didn't notice Guldens BE was so high. Leaning towards Dunkley the more I think about it. Lots of mouths to feed in the Sydney midfield and Gulden plays a wing/ outside role. Gulden might have the ceiling, but Dunkley seems to have the higher floor.
  3. C

    Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Gulden vs Dunkley vs Serong Can get to Gulden or Dunkley trading Carroll & Clarke. To get Serong I'd have to let go of McKerch instead of one of those two (who I'm thinking of holding and backing in to restart his cash gen). Mids are currently - Merrett, Green, Butters, Steele, Miller, Rozee
  4. C

    Trades 2024 Round 6 Trades

    Why is there so much talk about Walsh? Huge score this week, but isn't the interupted preseason a huge red flag? Scores to date are irrelevant when trading in, but do people think he can maintain a 120+ level and be a top 8 mid from this point forward?
  5. C

    Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Fisher will score ~70-80, Powell ~90-100. Trade is likely to get you 20-30 extra points. Whitfield will likely score 60-70 points more than whoever he is replacing at D6.
  6. C

    Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

    If not for the early byes it would be Touk by a mile. Even with the byes I'd still take Touk over Steele. (I have both)
  7. C

    Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Stewart & Serong vs Ryan or Houston & Dawson
  8. C

    Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Missing Mckenna, and have enough cash to turn any of my lower performing rookies to him via DPP. Who would you turn into mckenna from: Cowan, Baker, Constable, Greene/ skip mckenna and just hold.
  9. C

    Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

    Touk & Cunnington vs Cripps & Gulden
  10. C

    2019 Player X v Y v Z

    bont vs yeo? Stewart vs finlayson? edit - went Bont + Stewart
  11. C

    Round 9 Trades

    Hoping for some help fellas. Pretty happy with my team. Options for this week include: a) Upgrade the def line. $21k left in kitty. b) Go a week early on Lloyd and bring in the number one def, and a likely top 3-5 mid. $1k left in kitty. c) Huge mid line upgrade. 81k remaining...
  12. C

    Round 7 Discussion (dedicated to Andrew Birch)

    Which of these glorious spuds should I field this week? D Joyce or J Lockhart? Joyce scored 67 in his first game, but I'm worried he'll get a lockdown role on Cameron and give away a thousand frees and end up on 20. Whereas Lockhart seems like a 35-45. Neither option is amazing. Thoughts?
  13. C

    Round 6 Trades

    I'm thinking of going Clarke - Lockhart & Goldy - Baker (via Bines DPP). Would leave with with team below and ~600k in the kitty. Starting with Goldy instead of Grundy was a gamble that hasn't really paid off, and ROB looks decent enough to cover for a few weeks until he can be upgraded to...
  14. C

    Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

    I'd be hesitant about bringing Sheed or Rocky in without seeing them with Gaff/ Wines back along side.
Back
Top