Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by Karnivool

  1. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    They made the only logical case: they argued that Umpire Foot simply misheard a standard football query, and they backed their captain’s character to the hilt. The "doubling down" wasn't a lie; it was Butters’ genuine recollection of the only meaningful thing he said. The Tribunal used Ollie...
  2. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    Thinking that a few timeline inconsistencies proves Zak is a liar is the ultimate low-IQ take. If Zak and Ollie had told the exact same story word for word, it would’ve been a rehearsed script. Real human memory under 180 bpm adrenaline is messy, Zak forgetting he had a second throwaway chirp...
  3. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    You’re literally arguing that Zak’s credibility is shot because he plays a physical sport physically, which has zero relevance to whether he used a specific set of words. Stick to the traffic court analogies, because your understanding of procedural fairness is as clear as the audio the AFL...
  4. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    Dirtiest player in history? Get a grip, mate. If you think a few fines for being hard at the ball makes someone a serial liar, you’ve swallowed the AFL’s propaganda hook, line, and sinker.
  5. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    The fact that the betting agency connection wasn't mentioned in the judgment doesn't make it irrelevant; it makes the judgment a protected PR exercise. The Tribunal deliberately narrowed the implication of the comment to avoid acknowledging the massive elephant in the room: that a Sportsbet...
  6. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    The Tribunal's logic is basically a "guilty until proven innocent" stitch up. They claim it’s "impossible" for an umpire to mishear something, which is a joke considering they’re in a loud stadium with 30,000 fans screaming. They also completely cherry-picked Ollie Wines' testimony; they used...
  7. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    They actually had the nerve to write that Zak has committed "well over a dozen reportable offences over the last eight seasons." What the actual hell does that have to do with whether he said something to an umpire on Sunday?! This is supposed to be a hearing about one specific moment where...
  8. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    This whole Zak Butters case is becoming a pretty stark example of how not to run a serious disciplinary process. We’ve got: Missing audio of the alleged comment. A finding of guilt based purely on conflicting recollections. And now, during the most critical phase of the hearing, a panelist...
  9. Karnivool

    Umpiring Nick Foot reporting Zak Butters for abusive language

    It’s not really about defending Butters, it’s more the principle, it just doesn’t sit well with a lot of people that an incident with no clear evidence still results in a guilty finding.
  10. Karnivool

    Trades 2026 Round 5 Fantasy Trades

    Steele, Callaghan or Washcroft?
  11. Karnivool

    Trades 2026 Round 2 Fantasy Trades

    Are these two defenders trade in options for Blakiston: Bo Allen (WCE) $267k – scored 50 Josh Gibcus (RCH) $254k – scored 52 Or is it just worth keeping Blakiston against Port?
  12. Karnivool

    Trades 2026 Round 2 Fantasy Trades

    Its cathartic and lets me feel better about my shit team
  13. Karnivool

    Trades 2026 Round 2 Fantasy Trades

    Is Gibcus an option? Trading out Blakiston for Gibcus nets $150k
  14. Karnivool

    Mega Thread Nick Daicos - Can he be the GTWEB? Part 2

    Going off this player rating system for the season, Daicos isn't top 10 this season. Not sure it is the best system.
  15. Karnivool

    NO TROLLS Rankine handed a 4 match suspension by the AFL integrity unit for a homophobic slur against opponent

    What happened with Quaynor being booed was already a terrible look for Adelaide supporters, but Matthew Nicks’ response “It’s not one for me to comment on” is just as concerning in its own way. A coach doesn’t need to deliver a fiery speech, but the bare minimum is to show leadership and make...
See more

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom