Best I can find (at 12am in the morning. Haha).
Will Ashcroft > Joe Daniher > Dustin Fletcher > Tim Watson > Ken Fletcher > Jack Clarke > Dick Reynolds > Garnet Campbell > Clyde Donaldson > Dave Smith > Jim Anderson
The only let down... Jack Clarke retired Rd. 2, 1967, and Ken Fletcher debuted...
Herb Matthews Sr > Phil Brooks > George Bennett > Ted Fletcher > Allan Woodley > David Parkin > Michael Tuck > Darren Jarman > Simon Goodwin > Jack Gunston > Calsher Dear
Dunno if better is possible
It has probably been done... but what is the furthest we can go back using six players from the modern day? This is what I've got. Any further?
Zach Merrett > Dustin Fletcher > Tim Watson > Ken Fletcher > Jack Clarke > Dick Reynolds
Present day back to 1933... although one small asterisk...
In all seriousness though... other replies tongue in cheek.
Why would you not trade him now if we can work out something fair for both parties? You're getting unders if he nominates Hawthorn next year. Serious question.
So you want a 4x All Australian, Norm Smith Medallist... and expect to get him for two picks in a weak draft? Righto.
We've said that a deal really needs to turn our head or we will hold him to his contract as Steven King is happy to have him back at the club.