Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by philthy05

  1. philthy05

    Player Watch Dougie Cochrane APPROVED to be in Port's NGA, signs for Port Magpies for 2026

    I’m not confusing it with Tom. It was a direct quote from someone at port in an article , they said he’s done 3 hamstrings then a knee. I read it twice to double check.
  2. philthy05

    Player Watch Dougie Cochrane APPROVED to be in Port's NGA, signs for Port Magpies for 2026

    It was a direct quote from port Adelaide in an article. May have been Chris Davies I believe. I’m just pointing out that we’re not playing around or playing games to try to get him to drop , he legit has had a very bad injury run. And there’s genuine reason to be concerned about his ability...
  3. philthy05

    Player Watch Dougie Cochrane APPROVED to be in Port's NGA, signs for Port Magpies for 2026

    I think we still have to pick Dougie , we just can’t pass on him, but yeah, there’s so much risk there with the cost and injury history As I pointed out before , the talk about him going so early after knee surgery and 3 hamstrings is wild. There was a mock draft that highlighted the...
  4. philthy05

    Player Watch Dougie Cochrane APPROVED to be in Port's NGA, signs for Port Magpies for 2026

    Being super cautious? He’s had 3 hamstrings and knee surgery. We’re not being cautious , he’s incredibly injury prone and it’s an absolute red flag right now. There’s talent galore , just like Bowen Lockwood. At this stage he can’t stay on the park, his brother hasn’t been able to stay on the...
  5. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 AFL Draft, November 19 and 20 (Picks after Round 12: 3, 21, 23, 39, 50, 57)

    Where did I say anything about trading late picks? Why would we need to trade late picks if we’re trading the first down to get more points ?
  6. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 AFL Draft, November 19 and 20 (Picks after Round 12: 3, 21, 23, 39, 50, 57)

    Yes we can only match with two bids. If we trade our first down we can get more points. That’s how it has always always worked If we trade our seconds up we lose points. That’s how it always always works. So why would we take the option that’s worse for us? Why do’s everyone have such a...
  7. philthy05

    List Mgmt. List Management 2026-27

    Steven’s is a bit of a position less plodder tho isn’t he? Not sure I would bother I’m not sure what this boards obsession is with Roger’s. He’s a 9.8d 0.6 goal 172cm forward who wants to be a mid. If he was on our list we would call him a bust and I think most of this board would want his...
  8. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 AFL Draft, November 19 and 20 (Picks after Round 12: 3, 21, 23, 39, 50, 57)

    Why is everyone so wrapped up in trading picks up when there’s the obvious and more beneficial option to trade down? To trade up we probably have to give overs , of someone wants to trade up to our pick they pay overs, and teams will be , as always , very interested in a very early draft pick...
  9. philthy05

    List Mgmt. List Management 2026-27

    Has been floated here. I’ve long been a fan but his injury , lack of form and age counts against him. He will be 28 next season (from memory) so really not in the right age window, having said that we need players. I would be happy for port to float a 3rd or 4th rounder to take his contract...
  10. philthy05

    List Mgmt. List Management 2026-27

    Has been floated here. I’ve long been a fan but his injury , lack of form and age counts against him. He will be 28 next season (from memory) so really not in the right age window, having said that we need players. I would be happy for port to float a 3rd or 4th rounder to take his contract...
  11. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 Mid Season Draft

    We have a strong need for a medium forward / marking winger .. plus he’s young , possible upside I just doubt he lasts to us.
  12. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 AFL Draft, November 19 and 20 (Picks after Round 12: 3, 21, 23, 39, 50, 57)

    We cannot afford to do that. That means not cutting any of the deadwood , signing them to new contracts. Or maybe just making the bare minimum cuts. And it would mean no new mids to try to develop.
  13. philthy05

    List Mgmt. List Management 2026-27

    Sure You can tell me how poor you think Drew is all day long. What do you think about Watkins playing his spot next year ? I’m not against moving him, but we’ve got to be realistic at what that is gonna look like. If we lose butters drew and wines is finished , we’re looking at possibly...
  14. philthy05

    List Mgmt. List Management 2026-27

    Sure swap Drew for a mid in the draft , are we getting a high enough draft pick ? And is that mid ready straight away ? Are we bringing him into a midfield of rozee / jhf / Watkins / mead assuming no injuries ? Cause Jesus that’s not a great environment to blood a kid in. We likely have the...
  15. philthy05

    List Mgmt. 2026 Mid Season Draft

    That sounds like a great way to end up with another decade of lycett / sweet type rucks. That would be disappointing Visentini , like he’s done most of the year and will likely do for the rest of the year. (11ish games yeah?)
See more

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom