Remove this Banner Ad

Recent content by Smarch

  1. Smarch

    Rumour Ross Lyon to coach Carlton in 2022.

    A bit late with response sorry, but I don't think that counts considering Ratten almost had us in a Prelim the year prior, heaps of injuries stuffed us the year he got sacked and then Malthouse only made it because the Bombers were kicked out. Technically correct but we had recently been in...
  2. Smarch

    Rumour Ross Lyon to coach Carlton in 2022.

    Fair enough, good call, I did forget that, but yes, I concur on him being a bell end of sure
  3. Smarch

    Rumour Ross Lyon to coach Carlton in 2022.

    Don't get me wrong, I like our list, even Dow and Plowman that every one bags out, they did what they could in role they were given in the system. But how many teams that have changed coach, outside the 8, have then turned it around the following year and made the 8? Learning a new system and...
  4. Smarch

    Rumour Ross Lyon to coach Carlton in 2022.

    100% this, Sayers has made his decision and out priced everyone else by stating finals are expected, this is a purposeful act designed to limit the selection pool. He has already spoke to Lyon and now Clarko is out of the question there is almost no one else insane enough to put their hat in...
  5. Smarch

    Rumour Teague Gone

    Lloyd and Liddle are the bigger problem at the Club than Teague could ever be. Lloyd has been useless, list was set up by SoS then they pushed for Williams and Saad last year,happy with Saad at least, but nothing else to improve the club through culture shift or sourcing new assistants etc...
  6. Smarch

    Rumour Carlton to enter mini-rebuild. Teague to be sacked. Weitering to be captain.

    Thought McGovern's contract was up at the end of this year or next but it is actually 2023!?!?!? I personally think that if he, Harry and Charlie can get on the park together he would complement the other two, which would have been the plan, but I think they have all played only 3 or 4 games...
  7. Smarch

    Recommitted Tom Papley [wanted to return to Victoria, nominated Carlton - didn't get there]

    I would be more willing to give up Plowman than Marchbank, would prefer neither but I think Marchbank reads the play better and is a better user with the ball the Plowy. Weitering is a definite no chance, just got back to form this year and I think would be considered an untouchable by the...
  8. Smarch

    Rumour Best football related rumour you have heard from someone you trust

    Short answer is no, deteriorates the sample but unless you do multiple and commercial grade bleaching then the metabolites will still be detected. As stated, safer to just shave down for a few months, depending on what has been taken it can stay in your system for a while, which is why Coke and...
  9. Smarch

    Rumour Poor Ryhlee West

    Are you just going through every rumour thread and posting the exact same thing!?!? Have seen you in at least 3 so far today
  10. Smarch

    Traded 2018 Live Trade: Carlton trade #4 (2019) to Adelaide for #19 (2018) and #9 (2019)

    Look, you are probably 100% right on that, but what I have written is just my opinion, I have no idea if it is right or not, I'm sure they have their reasons for doing what they did, your option makes 100% sense though so I don't know what their final strategy is really. Maybe they have a trade...
  11. Smarch

    Traded 2018 Live Trade: Carlton trade #4 (2019) to Adelaide for #19 (2018) and #9 (2019)

    After all that has been said, we did the trade because we missed Shiel, we wanted a solid/classy mid to help out Murphy, Curnow, Cripps and the kids. Dow had a great season and Fisher stepped up more than expected, add Doc to rotate in a bit as well, Setterfield to get his body right along with...
  12. Smarch

    Traded Mitch McGovern [traded to Carlton in a three-way trade involving Sydney and McAdam]

    I don't know what will be a fair trade but 24 or 25 looks to be unders for me, coming from a Carlton supporter. He is not worth 1, or even a top 10 but maybe mid to high teens would be fair in my mind, especially in this draft, now how do we get that pick? That is the question, no idea, I don't...
See more

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom