Fogarty thus far in his whole junior career has played mostly up forward and some defence, the occasions he's played on the ball he has been mostly underwhelming. A dominant forward is far more valuable than a midfielder unless they are absolute superstars of the Martin, Dangerfield or Ablett Jr ilk. I just don't get why people are hell bent on going down the midfielder road with Fogarty when the nature of the AFL beast clearly shows more quality midfielders are far more readily available than quality key position players. From what I'm hearing from Darcy himself the club would appear to be going down the KPF path as almost every time he's interviewed he mentions he's learning leading patterns etc.
Who says he was underwhelming? I saw some really good passages from him for the Bays last year in the midfield.