Search results for query: *

Also arguably a reasonable example of confirmation bias.

That well known finals performer Bryce Gibbs?

What's your rationale for that? A limited form of free agency where Melbourne could just sign an undrafted ruckman would be more appropriate IMO. Having said that, I'm against it all, part of the challenges of list management.

I'm also intrigued by the logic that Scharenberg shouldn't play AFL because he needs highly skilled players around him to play well. Jack Watts notwithstanding, the players in the AFL tend to be as highly skilled as you can get.

I realise he's a few years off, but Chris25 do you know anything of Kieran Aigus from North? Seems ridiculously dominant?

He's not an awful shortish second ruck and in a good team can make a handy third tall. He just makes an atrocious third tall in a poor team.

Best case scenario is a poor man's Tom Hawkins or Leigh Brown. So basically only if a premiership contender was in the market for a relatively versatile 2nd ruck and was already very short. Kept thinking Carlton wouldn't be the worst place in the world for him but for the fact with...

Think we all suspected the Swans had something up their sleeve when the Johnston deal seemed so unders. Good get.

From that list isn't Stevens the only one who really "walked" though? I suppose in a manner of speaking Rawlings did.

Adam Morgan;)

Just quietly, every time the words James Hird or Chris Grant are mentioned here I'm mentally comparing the w***er Essendon and Bulldog's supporters to this other w***er: Yo, Yo other 14 clubs, I respect you, and I'm going to let you finish and that but James Hird and Chris Grant were the...

...to an extent vindicated this year with the "They know we're coming" marketing campaign which traded off the premise of a very talented list that has achieved **** all in living memory. The extent to which draft picks affect the business of a club should not be underestimated in this day and age.

Well according to the Crows they were going to take Tippett until Sellar unexpectedly slipped, I know who I'd believe;) Also agree there should be a statute of limitations, say 5 - 7 years on discussing whether a draft pick constitutes a "steal."

His family moved over to Adelaide to live with him. I call Bullshit!

...really count any of the pre-1991 drafting as real though. How players were drafted without nominating is total Victorian BS. Jarman did however **** the Crows over pretty bad in 1991 through agreeing to sign, the Crows then reserved him one of their safe 10 spots and then Hawthorn offering...

http://bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=483948 Here it is in all it's glory:rolleyes:

I'm fairly certain you told us he was traded to Fremantle last year? I call bullshit.

Fair enough, what I was trying to say, is that if you were picking a tall to play this week from the 2006 draft, it would probably be Tippett.

Funny remembering how highly some of the bigs were rated coming into the 2006 draft such as Gumbleton, Hansen, Reid, Riedwvolt, Sellar, Thorpe and the Browns that Tippett has arguably outstretched them all. Also interesting to note how they're almost doing well in the reverse of their draft...

Will be interesting to see what if any effect the new elite U18s competition has on the standard. My two to watch would be Panos and Evans.

Tyler Brimacombe

In the Adelaide Sunday Paper South Australian U18 coach named his likely draftees from South Australia, in no particular order (Ok the order they were in the paper) they were: Tyler Brimacombe (Sturt) Mathew Broadbent (WWT) Paul Cahill (Sturt) Phil Davis (North Adelaide) Chris...

SA Results: Vertical Jump Tyler Brimacombe (Sturt) 77cm Alex Kinal (Sturt) 75 cm Peter Rolfe (South) 74 cm Agility Peter Rolfe (South) 8.22 secs Charlie Sharples (Sturt) 8.25 secs Scott Blessing (West) 8.36 secs 20m Sprint Glen Dawson (Eagles) 2.75 secs Tyler Brimacombe...

Tyler Brimacombe from Sturt, although more likely on a rookie list

The only things I'd consider from Melbourne are Rivers and Mclean.

Is there any reason it needs to last for a whole 4 days though? Could it be done over a weekend or perhaps even a 3 day weekend to minimise it's disruption to schooling?

You do have yours, and I have mine. But I don't hold that against you. Nope, it's SANFL League, Reserves and Under 19s Grand Final week. The only league that's not affected is the Under 17s, which this will be the first time in years someone will actually be drafted from. And Leather Magnet...

It's a slap in the face of the SANFL, still the second best competition of Australian Rules Football. It's a direct implication that the TAC Cup, the WAFL, the QAFL, the TFL etc. etc. etc. are all more important than the SANFL. If this problem affected one Victorian player (let alone two)...

Just quietly, you may not have noticed, but 21 years ago the VFL became the AFL:rolleyes: If the Victorian leagues had their grand final this weekend how much do you want to bet that the AFL would put it back a week. Typical Prictorian imperialism.