Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. goodie23

    Day vs Twilight vs Night Grand Final

    Day Granny by the length of the Flemington straight. Twilight games suck, even the spectacle of a Grand Final won't fix that.
  2. goodie23

    The gretest indigenous player to have played the game

    Nicky Winmar?
  3. goodie23

    Twilight games in general

    Rather than just looking at the Granny, might as well as the question about all twilight games.
  4. goodie23

    Russell Robertson vs Stephen Milne

    Not miles apart but Milne did it better for longer which is harder.
  5. goodie23

    Gunston vs Darling vs Stringer

    I rate the hell out of Stringer, he's the one that worries me most
  6. goodie23

    Which of these young small forwards is most likely to become a top 25 AFL player?

    How many small forwards have ever been considered top 25 players?
  7. goodie23

    Best #1

    Port should have the stand-out candidate, given their captain always wears the #1. Probably between Cassissi, McIntosh and Walker
  8. goodie23

    Is Cyril Rioli Overrated?

    Depends who you ask. By the commentators, probably. By Hawks fans, mostly but that's their prerogative. By opposition fans, given how many call him overrated, not really.
  9. goodie23

    Long term contracts

    St Kilda fans thought the same thing with Hamill... There are obvious benefits, but my point is sooner or later, and with the multitude of long-term signings the odds are shifting towards sooner, a team's going to get bit.
  10. goodie23

    Long term contracts

    With the impending threat of free-agency, more players are being signed to longer contracts. How do you feel about your club locking up a player on a four/five year deal? Does the security outweigh the risk of injury or loss of form?
  11. goodie23

    Which of these small forward pair would you choose to have at your club right now?

    More a case of Milne and Schneider spending more time in the midfield than a dislodgement.
  12. goodie23

    Best Tagger in the AFL?

    Sean Dempster overtook Jones last season
  13. goodie23

    How many draft picks will GWS trade?

    Thought this was an interesting question, how active do you think GWS will be in terms of trading away their many valuable draft picks? Not counting mini draft picks. EDIT: Can a mod add the poll? Options: None at all, they'll hoard, 1-3, 4-6, 6-10, 10+ fire sale
  14. goodie23

    Would you support a tiered comp?

    Would I support my team if the league adopted this concept? Probably. Do I support the idea of a tiered competition? Nope.
  15. goodie23

    Todd Goldstein Vs Ben McEvoy Vs Drew Petrie

    Think you overstate slightly, but I get your point. For me the key is the question. It asks for favourite ruckman, not best or most potential.
  16. goodie23

    Todd Goldstein Vs Ben McEvoy Vs Drew Petrie

    I'm curious how Big Ben got involved in this argument. He's come a long way this year but he's still got ground to make up on these two
  17. goodie23

    Gary Moorcroft Mark vs Andrew Walker Mark

    Overhead mark over chest mark every time
  18. goodie23

    Who would you take?

    I rate Pendlebury highest, but structurally would probably go with Kennedy
  19. goodie23

    Didak or Milne

    Exactly my thoughts, especially when you considering one of the tall forwards usually crashing through the air is Koschitzke
  20. goodie23

    Ben McEvoy, Tom Bellchambers or Zac Smith?

    I'm a fan of Big Ben and like where he's headed, but Smith by a fair margin
  21. goodie23

    Black vs Hayes

    I have as big a man-crush on Lenny as anyone, but still gotta admit Black. Does raise the question though how great they would've been if their clubs were reversed
  22. goodie23

    Daniel Kerr

    It's not much more of a farce than many of the AFL tribunal decisions
  23. goodie23

    Do you want a FINAL 10???

    Final 10 only means more teams making up the numbers. It'll still be between the top 2-6 at the absolute most
  24. goodie23

    What annoys you most about current football coverage?

    Then everyone would choose all of the above. Not allowing multiple options means you have to think about your response
  25. goodie23

    What annoys you most about current football coverage?

    Wondering what annoys people the most
  26. goodie23

    What do you think of the GWS guernseys?

    Western Sydney Jaffas? Not a fan.
  27. goodie23

    Rebecca Twigley Vs Lauren Phillips

    Lauren over Tiggers, but I was mighty impressed with Riewoldt's new girl.
  28. goodie23

    Jurrah vs Goddard - Mark of the Year

    It was 29, Tom Lynch (officially listed as 192cm), but Pattison was rubbing the back of his head immediately after so I'm pretty sure Goddard clipped him
  29. goodie23

    Harry O'Brien vs James Gwilt

    The longer Gwilt's hair gets, the better he is
  30. goodie23

    Who is St Kilda's top midfielder?

    Inspired by the discussion in the Swan vs. Montagna thread.
Back
Top