Search results for query: *

My point is exactly that there is a rule against doing just that for good reason. You guys don't want everyone he just quoted to drop by your board and call him a flog. I don't want to summon him to the Hawthorn board so he can reply there, either.

Am I allowed to tell a flog that he is a flog in his own forum if he has quoted a post of mine from the main board?

Well, let's be honest, North are not in the 8, and not that many people think they will make finals. There was room to have one wild-card on Sunday, as there will be one first week final on a Sunday. Would it be fair to Sydney, who are currently in the 8, to give North the preferable fixture...

$800k over three years is nly slightly above average for an AFL player. This isn't about chasing dollars it's about Gibson wanting to be at a club that really needs him, rather than a club who don't really see him as being in their best 22 moving forward. Interesting the Buckley is mentioned...

I probably agree than he is worth more than pick 25, but less than pick 9, maybe somewhere in the range of pick 14 to pick 18. Depending on the specific young talent that Scott has in mind, pick 25 + a player might get it done.

See, now this - you admit that you didn't read Crypt's post, but you are abusing him for it all the same. Also, I read the rules of this forum before I started posting here, as I want to be respectful of this forum and the posters here. Absuing other posters is against the rules, and so is...

Emphasis mine. Look, I know it's your forum and all, but I really think you're being very hypocritical. I know I've been very respectful of your club and your board in here, and so have the bulk of the other Hawthorn posts I've seen. I think this is the key. I understand the emotion from the...

It's one thing for you to say this, but take the emotion out of the equation, and you have to believe that North, if faced with a choice of pick 25 or nothing, will take pick 25. As supporters, you have the luxury of being emotional about it. The club doesn't. I can't honestly see them rejecting...

No chance of this. None whatsoever.

Pick 9 and Dowler for Gibson and a box of Shapes? Unless I'm missing the meaning behind the box of shapes, then I don't see how this is a response to the question of whether you'd be happy to lose him and get nothing in return into the PSD. You guys are acting as though we have something to...

I would probably take this. It's "Thorp", though. It doesn't work that way. To get someone in the PSD, you have to offer what they're asking for. I can't see North giving Gibson a substantial pay rise as a reward for walking out on them. I think that Melbourne have an abundance of young key...

I can't imagine us offering you pick 9, given that Gibson is uncontracted, and has stated that he wants to come to Hawthorn. Even if you do toss him into the PSD, I get the impression that part of the reason he wants to move is that Hawthorn have offered him more money than the Roos can afford...

Well done on a fantastic win. I don't think anyone could genuinely take much away from North tonight, definitely deserved to win. It's described as an upset, because, rightly or wrongly, Collingwood were favorites to win, $1.40 I think. I don't think you should see it as insulting that it's...