Search results for query: *

Looks at net free kick ladder over the past 15 years. collingwood near the top. Cats near the bottom. Looks at where geelong has played all its home games against collingwood the past 15 years. Every single game at collingwoods home ground and city. can i have some of what you are taking?

I think it was in. Not out.

It looks like Cameron probably marked it in the play. Look where the boundary line is in the pic. Its not conclusive. But calling it obviously out is ridiculous. Commentators were just being biased to appease pies supporters. And like usual, most neutrals fall for what the commentators and crowd...

What a ridiculous comment. You home ground is where all your fans are and near where your players live. you also happen to play 14 games a season there. You havent played at punt road in fifty years.

Mega celebrity cats supporters including darryl summers, aaron baddeley, felicity kennett and portia di rossi have written letters to the tribunal about what a great bloke stewart is. Changes everything. case being reopened.

Can we rectify the flaw where we play our so called home game against you at your home city and stadium in front of 60 thousand of your fans? or do you only occur about flaws that disadvantages your side.

Stewart got 4 for concussing an opponent cos he didnt have waleed aly in his corner to tell the tribunal what a great bloke he was. richmond supporters all silent on that one. houli great bloke. Stewarts a monster.

Jonas connected with an elbow. Not a bump.

Your player wasnt unconscious either.

for consistency sakes. So you want to make up new harsh rules now just for geelong and ignore precedent.

Not correct. There is no requirememt for fear. Simply unwanted touching is all it takes to be an assault charge. And if you simply touch an old person you can go to court and face a jury for a serious assault charge. The law is insane.

which is a 3-4 week crime. not a 6 week crime. Name a single player who got 6 weeks for running past the ball, bumping a player in the head and giving them concussion? the answer is zero. Its zero. All players who have been done for those sort of weeks had elbows raised, swung hail marys or...

Ok now you are arguing something different. We were just discussing if there was an elbow. he was far too late and he connected with the head. no one is disagreeing with that. Thats what the 4 weeks are for. He didnt lead with an elbow. He didnt punch him. If he did it will be 6 weeks. and 8...

A different era? A different era was the 1990s. It was 4 years ago. Houli punched a player in the head. Concussed him. Put him out of the game. It was worse then stewarts. you are just being a hypocrit. houli was given 2 weeks.

His tucked in elbow as per standard bumps. The elbow comes out after the bump has already happeend as per all perfectly executed bumps. Its where the elbow is on contact that matters. Is it tucked in or is it pointed at the oppenents head.

A magical elbow from his third invisible arm.

Greg williams got 9 for touching an umpire. umpires are different. Given they arent playing you could argue touching an umpire is assault.

He wasnt unconscious. There was no elbow raised. 4 weeks seems exactly right. Could of even been only 3.

Um cos jonas went with the elbow. Stewart didnt.

Lynch intent and action was worse in some of those incidents. he just had bad aim that didnt connect.

Richmond could of stopped the play by calling for a stretcher. You didnt. Maybe ask the question of why your club didnt do this.

Which aint a link. scott played at brisbane and coached north. Never been at geelong.

which would still be a hell of a lot shorter then those four players. All of them werent just concussed. They were physically disfigured too. drinking out of straws for weeks.

See the last sentence. Well stewart didnt do what those 4 did. Not even close. All 4 of them put players out of the game for half a season or more with broken faces.

you literallg had an ex richmond player on the tribunal for twenty years. Brad scott has never had any links to geelong.

And if you are knocked out you arent up at all. He watched the game on the side lines. You guys didnt even call a stretcher. He wasnt sent immediately to hospital. steve johnson got cleaned up in a similar incident where a player ran past the ball about 8 years ago and hit him flush in the head...

there are worse incidences. Jeremy cameron on andrews a few years ago was worse. Cameron got 5 weeks. And then there was gaffs punch which was a lot worse. It got 8 weeks. 3-4 weeks. But the media is baying for blood because well richmond.

6-8 weeks would be completely inconsistent with all other incidences.

Cameron had a raised elbow. Andrews went to Hospital with bleeding on the brain. timing is one of many factors.

He wasnt knocked out. He was concussed.