Search results for query: *

I mean the fact that it's ungraded is a piss take

I would question how accurate the sideline reporting of it is anyway. How long do you think a concussion test takes? Usually you've completed half of it by the time the players off the field. I do understand that the AFL level assessment would be more thorough given the presence of a Dr at the...

Can answer this. Work as a trainer in local football in Perth. The AFL approved concussion recognition tool only requires one visible sign for a player to be removed from play. Following that, it only takes one positive symptom to be ruled out. I doubt Simpkin would have got past the first...

Might as well just ban pinning arms in tackles full stop.

100%. This is the problem. By giving leeway you create this mess.

Imagine he may be doing it again this week. Had a go at Neale tonight.

You mean if you are on the other side of the fence.

Even if he did hit him in the chest, he probably would've broken a rib given what he managed to do to his face.

At 3 quarter time he said 'that's footy'. Showing great character this club.

Clearly deserves a suspension. But just curious, everyone is saying high contact? Haven't followed the way they grade dangerous tackles but high contact because his head hit the floor? Seems a little odd to me. I reckon 2-3 weeks is what is deserved.

It's pretty clear now. Tackle someone and cause a concussion, it's at least a game off. Don't agree with it, but when it comes to tackling, the suspensions seem pretty clear. All about the outcome. In saying that, Naitanui has done this 3 times this year. Very reminiscent of the tackling...

Mate even the AFL don't think that.

Lol

I'd say biting somebody is pretty disgusting.

Um no. Rischitelli had to come off for the blood rule but wasn't concussed. Neither was Lewis when he struck him.

Who has Fyfe actually injured?

Wrong thread buddy. Fyfe will probably get a game or two for that. Missed the second post of the thread did we?

For all those saying it was nothing, Fyfe spent a few minutes off the field and came on after half time with compression around the leg Mitchell kneed. It wasn't an accident, Mitchell's done it 3 times this year now.

How in the world is that careless?

Sam Mitchell bumped him, was a head clash. He'll get off.

Varcoe got off, so should Fyfe.

Marc Murphy.

300... At a pinch.

Nichols???!!!!! Well at least it's not Luke Farmer.

Except he barracks for any team playing Freo. He was complaining about Hills goal to seal the game. Selwood will get off, no media coverage/no whining = no report. Foxtel had a camera on Selwood and Crowley the whole game in round 14, they were expecting to pick up dodgy stuff Crowley did, they...

Should have just marked it. Problem solved.

Is Chris Scott the new Sir Alex Ferguson, he has just retired and needs a replacement, i think we have found him.

Poll speaks the truth