That trade values dusty as pick 22. Tigers would need to pay a significant portion of his rumoured $1.5m salary to make that happen. Picks are only worth points in the first 4 rounds - 81 and 99 are worth 0 points.
Also need to factor in clubs can only take an amount of picks in to the draft as...
Would be more interested in staying in the top 7 this year.
Trade your f1 for gc’s pick 5 and some other picks. Send 5 and 19 to us for 4. That’s what it would take if Curtin is still on the board at 4.
Easiest point of reference is last year -
GWS gave - 3, 12, collingwood f2 (~37)
GWS got - 1, 53, 57
What I suggested is in line with last years trade, and pretty much every other pick swap in history.
Doubt eagles get a better offer than a top 3 pick and 2 top 20 picks, definitely won’t...
Your suggested trade wasn’t too far off, but would need later picks coming back to the dees to even it up.
Hawks in/ dees out - 4, 23
Hawks out/ dees in - 3, 50
~350 points benefit to the hawks
WCE in/ dees out - 3, 15, f1
WCE out/ dees in - 1, 36, 38
~500 points benefit to WCE
WCE get the...
A long way ahead of where Cam Rayner is… Cameron Rayner and Christian Petracca AFL Stats Comparison
SuperCoach points isn’t a great metric but he averaged 44 points more in his fifth season than Rayner is right now…
If he’s interested in moving to Melbourne and Pickett nominates port could see a trade of Georgiades for Pickett and a pick swap in Melbourne’s favour happening.
Take it with a grain of salt, but a friend who’s a Melbourne based recruiter for an interstate club has said he will be at Melbourne next year.
Waiting on the Jackson trade to go through for it to happen. Likely to be futures for Hunter and a later pick this year.
Your maths is off - based on this years ladder pick 5(Rankine) + p22(gwsf2) + p26(gcf2) is worth 3,452 points.
P11(wbf1) + p13(blf1) + p30(wbf1) + p32(blf2) is worth 3,754 points.
The difference in points is the equivalent of pick 48.
He used to be ‘in the know’ with mfc, but believe his sources left the club a year or two ago.
Edit - speculating his sources left the club - has been a few years since he dropped something on the money about the mfc
Article by Jay Clark in the herald sun today said Freo are looking to trade their first this year up to Port Adelaide’s pick 8, which would be sent on with next years future first for Jackson.
GC get pick 5 for Rankine and 43 - values Rankine as pick 9 on points.
WCE trade 2 and 20 for GC’s 5,7 and 25 - values splitting pick 2 as worth pick 22.
WCE trade 7 and Darling for Jackson and 32 - values Jackson as Darling + pick 17
WCE
In - Jackson, 5, 25, 32
Out - Darling, 2, 20
MFC
In -...
Probably worth a mid-20s pick to us.
The issue is we have no ruck depth and Lobb is not a full time ruck, so we would have to bring in another back up ruck as well.
Probably cheaper both picks and salary wise to bring in Grundy.
Based on media speculation Grundy would be a late teen - early...
Yes.
That said, if you bring in Lobb, which of your forwards are relegated to the VFL? Bruce? If so, what would it take to move him on? Late 30’s - early 40’s pick?
Three team trade?
Fremantle
In - Jackson
Out - Lobb, 13
Melbourne
In - Ugle-Hagan, 37
Out - Jackson
Western Bulldogs
In - Lobb, 13
Out - Ugle-Hagan, 37
The rising star is a pretty good indicator of a good, long career.
The average games played of the 17 retired rising star winners is 240 - the only retired rising star winners to play under 200 games are Rhys Palmer (123), Jared Rivers (194) and Nick Holland (179).
IMO, between 1993-2019...
Would much prefer Jackson stay than go.
Historically out of contract players go for less than they are worth/ than they would if contracted.
Using the trades I mentioned as a baseline, you could probably estimate his trade worth as an out of contract player being the equivalent of a pick 3-5...
An out of contract Jeremy Cameron and 2x future 2nds (2021 picks 32 and 35) went for picks 13,15,20 (ended up as 15,18 and 25 after bids) and a future 4th (2021 pick 60). Trade was equivalent to pick 5 after bids were considered.
An out of contract Jake Lever, pick 35 (37 after bids) and future...
Would probably be worth an early to mid second rounder, somewhere in the 25-30 range.
His off field contributions make him worth a lot more to Melbourne than what we’d get in a trade though - in the leadership group, his parents foster a large number of non-Melbourne draftees (Jackson, Pickett...
You’re right, will probably be 9-10, but at this stage who knows, Brisbane and Essendon might play funny buggers over Danihers contract, same with saints and Adelaide. Either could be band 1 compo, or band 2. JUH and Campbell the likely top 10 father son/ academy picks, but there are 5-6 in the...
He could also become the best player in the comp, win the brownlow and go up in price.
It’s all hypothetical at this time because talk of Oliver leaving is based off a Sam McClure rumour.
IMO there’s next to no chance of this happening this year - Oliver is too good and too young to trade away.
That said, the Lachy Neale tradie would be the benchmark for this one:
Pre-draft - Neale and p30 for p6, p19 and p55 (on points value it was Neale for 2,279 points (~p3)).
After NGA and...
What is Wingards value relative to Hogan? Are they rated even or would one club have to send steak knives the other way if we were to on trade what freo offer for Hogan?
The two most recent comparable deals (young quality key forwards being traded to a nominated club) were:
Charlie Dixon and picks 19 and 49 for picks 10 and 31 (2015) + 26 and 32 (2016)
Tom Boyd for Ryan Griffin and pick 6 (2014)
Dixon was 25 y.o. with 65 games and 94 goals when he was traded...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.