Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. M

    Opinion Teams you actively avoid watching?

    Related point, I hate watching games in WA. I don't mind the clubs, but the commentary is atrocious. Biased commentary and the constant reminders of any visiting players links to WA ( "Fred Blog's 2nd cousin lives in Albany, and when Joe Smith visited as a 3 year old kid, he saw a football in...
  2. M

    Fixture Gather Round - SA announced as host for next 3 years 2024-2026

    The 3 gather rounds would be 2*6 matches, 1*7 matches. ( 3 gather 'rounds' = 2 games + a bye for each team, so 19 games) Hold them all in Tas (and it would surely only be a 6 match round) and you have an attendance for the round lucky to get much over 125K. The AFL loves it's money/PR too much...
  3. M

    Opinion Unpopular opinion about your own club

    Are you sure you haven't got cause and effect backwards?
  4. M

    Expansion Tasmania Officially Granted 19th Licence

    License officially granted, or granted provisionally on the bid meeting certain criteria (stadium, etc)?
  5. M

    Roast Has Opening Round been totally botched?

    They all get the bye. Just for 10 clubs it's not particularly meaningful.
  6. M

    Roast Has Opening Round been totally botched?

    Technically 3...(post rnd 23/pre-finals)
  7. M

    Roast Has Opening Round been totally botched?

    and both off a short (5/6 day) break.
  8. M

    Roast Has Opening Round been totally botched?

    So, your argument is your tinfoil hat?
  9. M

    Roast Has Opening Round been totally botched?

    On what basis do you say that?
  10. M

    Who are the biggest busts in VFL/AFL history?

    Sure. BTW. I've got a bridge to sell you. Prime position, right on Sydney Harbor.
  11. M

    Who are the biggest busts in VFL/AFL history?

    Drafting is often a probability equation. In the Buddy draft...Buddy was a wildcard. Everyone knew he could be something special, but there was also a significant chance he'd flame out....so he dropped to 5. Deledio on the other hand was a 'sure thing' (95%+) to be a good (top 10 in the club)...
  12. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    Tigers bottom 4
  13. M

    Who are the biggest busts in VFL/AFL history?

    Richard Lounder. Pick 1 in 1987 (2nd draft ever). 203cm 116Kg FF from SA, kicked 4 goals on debut, but then other clubs worked him out and he ended up playing a total of 4 games and kicked 5 goals. What did they work out about him? Well, he was described as being "built like a brick...
  14. M

    Who are the biggest busts in VFL/AFL history?

    Thorp also puts the Tambling over Buddy 'disaster' in perspective. If Buddy (and Roughhead) were such obvious champions from the get go, why did Hawthorn spend their first pick 2 years later on a key forward? Clearly even after 2 years Hawthorn had doubts about how things were going to play...
  15. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    Or that the game style McRae introduced to Collingwood is a lot like what Hardwick brought in at Richmond?
  16. M

    News Tarryn Thomas - 18 matches and sacked from North Melbourne

    Because the justice system is seriously messed up. Currently looks like it'll be 9 months between when charges were laid and facing court. That's why we have to treat people as innocent until proven guilty...punishing them while they wait for the court system to get to them is unfair. It's...
  17. M

    News Tarryn Thomas - 18 matches and sacked from North Melbourne

    St Kilda had to pay a (secret but apparently substantial) sum to Lovett as settlement for his unfair dismissal case. I imagine North are trying to avoid that.
  18. M

    News Tarryn Thomas - 18 matches and sacked from North Melbourne

    Not my problem. I'm not saying it'll work, but giving him an avenue to return can't hurt.
  19. M

    News Tarryn Thomas - 18 matches and sacked from North Melbourne

    Tas is supposed to get a VFL team next year. He can join that and if he keeps his nose clean, can be one of their inaugural AFL players.
  20. M

    News Tarryn Thomas - 18 matches and sacked from North Melbourne

    It's not fair, but people on high incomes like Thomas have a lot more access to lawyers. Also payouts for unfair dismissal tend to be far higher. It's understandable that North (presumably with the AFL's support) wanted to make sure all the i's were dotted and the t's crossed before taking...
  21. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    They'll win them by so much they'll be given 5 points for each win.
  22. M

    Demons Drug Crisis - Why not the same scrutiny as West Coast?

    With west coast, the problems grew behind the scenes until nobody (club/media/AFL) could deny it any more. Partly due to that, there is a lot more monitoring these days (AFL drug code), so the Melbourne problem is still probably a year or two less developed than where WCE was at when their case...
  23. M

    Analysis Traditional Melbourne clubs' territory

    The other relevant factor for the 'early days' is where the VFA teams were, particularly the bigger ones, and where the train/tram lines went. The VFL might have taken most of the bigger teams, but a lot of people would have still supported their local (VFA) side, not least because they could...
  24. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    I'll defer to your obvious experience there.
  25. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    I'm assuming he knows others who have similar views, and that they might be considered 'good'.
  26. M

    Analysis Traditional Melbourne clubs' territory

    I'd also say this map is a bit generous to North.
  27. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    I can.
  28. M

    Sydney… the biggest club in the land??

    Not Collingwood specifically, but I dare say the media rights go for more because the AFL agrees to fixture with one of their goals being to maximise viewers. (presumably there is an agreement to 'consult' the broadcaster on such things, and some KPIs involved). I'd also add that the AFL (not...
  29. M

    2024 Ladder Predictions

    After their win in the match simulation, Richmond are clearly premiership contenders. Melbourne on the other hand are going to struggle this year.
Back
Top