Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. jim boy

    Opinion Revisiting An Old Subject - "Substandard Club Songs"

    It is a fairly quaint tradition in Australian sport to go out to combat, give your all, battle hard and finish up by gathering in a circle and singing a jolly little song. Easy to mock - but it goes in hand with the extraordinary level of loyalty players have to clubs compared to athletes in...
  2. jim boy

    News Clubs operating league-sanctioned drug testing program - Harley Balic’s Dad Speaks

    LoL - we're talking illicit drugs, not performance enhancing. If you are not playing, then you cant exactly be accused of cheating. I mean if I were to go out at night, have a few bevvies, decide I'll drive home but first check my alcohol levels on one of those machines, so decide to taxi home...
  3. jim boy

    News Clubs operating league-sanctioned drug testing program - Harley Balic’s Dad Speaks

    Guilty of what exactly? - if you don't play then you cant be guilty of a match day crime. FWIW, any coach would be absolutely ropeable with any player who makes themselves unavailable in this way - one step closer to the exit door. The real story here is that drug culture at Melbourne seems so...
  4. jim boy

    News Clubs operating league-sanctioned drug testing program - Harley Balic’s Dad Speaks

    The next step is to remove speedometers from players cars so players cant "test" whether they are ILLEGALLY speeding and thus avoid the punishment by slowing down.
  5. jim boy

    Which club is Mick Malthouse most associated with?

    Obviously you think of malthouse as a coach, he had three very significant spells at three clubs plus Carlton. Each of those clubs could lay claim to this question. However I visualised him being in club colours, and only one team stood out, so Richmond it is.
  6. jim boy

    Opinion Bringing Back The “Night Time Premiership"

    Dont know what match you were going to but the season that year didnt even start until March and the match you referenced was in May, well into the regular season. And that was a major issue, teams couldn't play that much so they started putting in "under 19s" teams. They were trying to emulate...
  7. jim boy

    Autopsy The Stats Don’t Lie: VicBIAS By The Numbers - An Empirical Analysis

    I love stats. Throw me any team* and I will prove to you with stats that the AFL is being controlled by a cabal of shadowy parties determined to make said team win/lose/relocate *Dont
  8. jim boy

    Geelong sending players for surgery early and impacting GWS finals chances

    I think you are looking for something that isn't there. Questioning the integrity is about whether a team is trying to manipulate the results, or more specifically a loss, which was the alleged behaviour of West Coast. Sure - Geelong will be playing a weakened team - but we are going for a team...
  9. jim boy

    It’s time to abolish restricted free agency compensation

    Even so - I'd rather see compensation in the form of the losing club getting a bump in their salary cap. That way they can offer over-the-odds to a player from another team without condemning some poor kid to join a s**t-show of a team.
  10. jim boy

    Ineligible for F/S but fathers played AFL.

    I believe the Cornes brothers were eligible to be selected under F/S - to Adelaide. And I also think James Hird was also tied to Essendon under the archaic rules of the time.
  11. jim boy

    News Damien Hardwick agrees to become the coach of The Gold Coast Suns

    This should be the story - if Dimma is a dead cert to GC, why are the AFL funding a jolly for Mark Evans to get a sun tan on the Riviera? I can only imagine the most awkward of meetings as Dimma goes running against the bulls only to have poor little Mark Evans chasing him with a contract and a...
  12. jim boy

    Can Fyfe win the Coleman?

    No - just a lazy 58 off Curnow and wont kick any more this year. Should have put money on it. But even putting injuries aside, Cotchin has so far kicked an average of .41 goals a game this season, compared to the .33 goals per game that Fyfe managed. It is genuine shame to see what happened...
  13. jim boy

    Who won the Judd/Kennedy trade?

    Who is to say that West Coast wouldn't have won three flags if Judd had stayed?
  14. jim boy

    Expansion Surely Wellington or another NZ based team is the next port of call for an new AFL Team/Franchise

    Nah - should go the other way and have more teams. Ideally another six teams, but four would do. Then break the into two divisions. Come September you still have the finals, but you also have relegation/promotion matches. Everybody plays each other twice in their same div + finals. If...
  15. jim boy

    Expansion Surely Wellington or another NZ based team is the next port of call for an new AFL Team/Franchise

    Why would Channel 7 give the AFL any more money for a market they cant broadcast to and wouldn't even if they could? Will be 100 years before there is a NZ team
  16. jim boy

    Does Geelong need to implement a youth policy?

    Joking yeah? - Hawkins is on SFA, veterans are like that - Reiwoldt is another who is on next-to-nothing.
  17. jim boy

    News ‘Would be unreal’: AFL to consult clubs over addition of ‘wildcard round’ to finals

    That's not quite true - apparently CBA rules stipulate that you have to have two byes, so they have to factor in some sort of bye. Regardless though I dont mind it. 10 straight games is one thing, but finals are another step up. Winning 5 finals in a row is just massive. You'd know from last...
  18. jim boy

    Gawn and Grundy - a failure?

    absolute rubbish - plenty of teams do well with only so-so rucks, Port and Collingwood for example. WCE won 2018 with NicNat sitting on the pine. Brown in a way, is an ideal sceond string. Really not good enough to be a first-teamer but fine for the ocasional chop-out for Gawn. If all Grundy is...
  19. jim boy

    Where’s the love for GWS?

    TBF - they did lose to WCE. Good team though, may win in first week of finals
  20. jim boy

    Scott Pendlebury - Standing in the game?

    So pendles has been a consistently high performer, but hasn't had the blistering good years of a Judd or Martin. The latter two who spent probably half their career worse then pendles and the other half better. Its really just a personal judgment, how well do you judge 'best' - consistently...
  21. jim boy

    The Suns have set on Dew

    Its even stupider when you remember that Carrara was originally set up for the Brisbane Bears
  22. jim boy

    The Suns have set on Dew

    gone - according to SEN
  23. jim boy

    AFL grand final Draw - Full Replay or Extra Time

    And if they had played extra time in 2011 and the pies had won, then they would all be saying extra time is best.
  24. jim boy

    West Coast - where are they going?

    If Port of 2011 were playing WCE, Port would win by 12 goals. WCE are at whole another level of awfulness. Port at least managed to salvage 3 wins for the year. Sure they had a couple of massive losses, but they were against the top teams, not the bottom six teams. Its remarkable that WCE have...
  25. jim boy

    AFLs love affair with Gambling. Is the game compromised?

    I have one - it is that umpires are human and can have bad nights for any number of reasons, not all of them involving sinister underworld figures, could be as simple as a lack of sleep due to a young child that leads to judgement impairment.
  26. jim boy

    AFLs love affair with Gambling. Is the game compromised?

    Umpires decision doesn't go my way -> Game is rigged and I'll start a conspiracy theory to prove. Umpires decision goes my way -> Nothing to see, move along
  27. jim boy

    Luke Sayers - PWC Scandal

    Certainly the guy on the ATO board was a bad apple, but that isn't why Luke should be in trouble. The issue is that the information obtained was used by more than 50 other PWC consultant projects. One or two you might just say ok, well they made mistakes, but 50! These are multimillion dollar...
Back
Top