Search results for query: *

Salem straight swap :drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk::drunk:

Glad we traded him early enough so we could actually get something :)

Think people are a bit harsh on Melk, undeniably he does have a head you just want to punch but I'd like to see him play a few games under Goodwin before passing judgement

In respects to Hibberd, Goodwin loves players that make quick decisions with elite skills. Our attacking style is heavily based on our speed of ball movement, I have no doubt he would fill that role off HB far better then anyone else at our club.

Agree to disagree, I'm just suggesting that the length of a players career doesn't necessarily indicate the importance it had for the club.

Adams isn't needed in GWS's midfield depth and Shaw isn't needed in Collingwood's rebuild so its a clear win-win because both teams would be worse off with their initial players. Your argument of who won it more is founded on whether having a player that allows you compete for a flag is more or...

Not saying that at all, I think both clubs won. They equality achieved their motivations, GWS wanted experience and to compete for the flag and Collingwood wanted to build for the future. Both clubs have achieved their goal.

Shaw is going to help guide GWS to premiership success this year or the years to come, no doubt Adams is a gun and has a lot of years ahead of him but to say you win the trade when Shaw could be a key component to a flag is wrong imo

Salem will not be a straight swap. Bloke is a star, been concussed and had a thyroid problem all year. Going to need your 3rd rounder in addition to Hibberd at bare minimum.

We'll add in a ripe Dean Terlich if push comes to shove!

I second that, need some good ball-use out of the back by foot and some experience to assist our current back-line leader in Tommy Mac

Easy straight swap, DimWitt for Lewis 'Car Scratcher' Taylor

I was thinking about this just the other day. The only people that clubs want from GC are their genuine stars, their o'mearas, prestias, bennells ect while other clubs hound GWS's fringe players. When clubs want a young player to fill a role they go to GWS. With Cam McCarthy, Adam Tomlinson...

Love watching this bloke play football the exact type of player we have lacked for a very long time