Search results for query: *

How good for Doggies and Blues supporters that we even get to have discussions around players like Bont vs. Cripps and Walsh vs. Smith. I'll leave the weekly pissing contests to all the reactive imbeciles and just enjoy watching guns and gun youngsters. Like I've said before, I doubt Carlton or...

Impossible to dispute this...

This is a fair bust up... Absolutely idiots on both sides of this ridiculous 'weekly bump' wank fest. Both looking like extremely good AFL players going forward. Both clubs happy with what they got and would do it the same again if given the opportunity.

That's a fair point. I probably should have allowed for the SA clubs having the number 1 pick as I think they (especially Adelaide) may have selected Lukosius. I have doubts that the Doggies would have overlooked Walsh for the 3 standout talls had they had 1, but it's unlikely we could ever...

You're very delusional if you think any club, including the Dogs, wouldn't have selected Walsh if they had pick 1. He was about as consensus number 1 as there has ever been and backed it up with the statistical best first year of a player ever. Carlton would pick him again and so would I (if it...

This is one of those funny threads that is unavoidable on BigFooty that will receive constant, reactionary bumps when either player has a good or bad game. The truth in between all of the hyperbole and huff and puff is that both clubs look to have exemplary talents and future guns. Carlton...

For Carlton: Hurley - Watts - Naitanui Starting a team from scratch: Hurley - Naitanui - Watts Not saying I don't rate Watts. So tough to split them at this early stage, but based on what I've seen of them in the AFL that's how I would do it. All 3 should have long and good careers. Reckon...

Pretty tough call. Both in the very early stages of their career, so really predictions at this stage should be taken with a grain of salt. Having said that, I reckon I'd take Shuey.... just.

I agree with you regarding the best player-captaincy thing. Rischa has showed plenty of leadership though I've felt, particularly in a team that isn't short of great leaders (Brown, Black etc.) He probably isn't the most vocal bloke, but that can happen in a team not short on dominant...

No love for Rischitelli here? I would of thought it would have been out of him and GAJ. This would be my preferred structure if I was calling the shots. Captain (Ablett/Rischitelli) - Vice-Captain (Brown) Vice-Captain (Ablett/Rischitelli) - Leadership Group Player #1 (Fraser) Leadership Group...

I think the people predicted them to beat Carlton are more so showing their dislike of Carlton and hoping that they beat us rather then actually thinking that they can and will. Not saying it is impossible, but I think it highly unlikely, whether you think I'm biased or not. I think if our...

My view on the vast majority of these rule change issues is quite simple. Leave the game alone!

I agree minus the :rolleyes: This is the crappiest argument leveled at pro-athletes bar none. Everyone would take a pay-rise to do their same job, yet Juddy is some sort of evil man for doing so? Also add the fact that he was at a workplace in reasonable turmoil, away from his home and family...

Get your head around the fact that I cannot show this 'evidence'. Any research done on the topic now is superfluous as there is certain injuctions in place prohibiting any discussion/reporting of any kind. Of course discussion which excludes Hodge from such incidents is readily available, it's...

It's obviously easy for you to argue your case because my hands are tied in terms of what I can say. Bit like a boxing match where one bloke has his hands hog tied. Dermott Brereton certainly wasn't allowed to comment wholly when discussing Hodge recently, regardless of how high you regard his...

We can't discuss it so obviously I have to let this slide. But it's a little naive to say he isn't/wasn't involved. No more on the issue from me.

If I barracked for Hawthorn I would 100% prefer Hodge. What he offers them I doubt Judd could equal. As a Carlton man, Judd all the way. No explanation needed. Our own coach calls him 'the man'. Enough said. Starting a team from scratch would be touch and go. Not trolling but I think Hodgies...