Captaincy: the importance

[flea29]

I'll give this a go!
R1: Pendles 120 (Cox 165) -45
R2: Goddard 102 (Pendles 162) -60 (-105)
R3: Goddard 112 (Bartel 159) -47 (-152)
R4: Pendles 132 (Buddy 146) -14 (-166)
R5: Montagna 119 (Pendles 130) -11 (-177)
R6: Cox 131
R7: Pav 122 (Cox 125) -3 (-180)
R8: Pav 109 (Thompson 136) -27 (-207)
R9: Pendles 124 (Montagna 151) -27 (-234)
R10endles 138 (Thompson 162) -24 (-258)
R11:Judd 83 (Cox 166) -83 (-341)
R12:Ablett 139 (Goddard 143) -4 (-345)
R13:Ablett 144
R14endles 114 (Pav 155) -41 (-386)
R15av 118 (Ablett 185) -67 (-453)
R16:Ablett 19 (Pendles 160) -141 (-594)
R17:Judd 122 (Lower 146) -24 (-618)
R18:Swan 115 (Judd 197) -82 (-700)
R19:Goddard 138 (Cox 213) -75 (-775)
R20endles 133 (Judd 163) -30 (-805)

R1-10: -258
R11-20: - 547

 

[Philzsay]

Since I was starting to get depressed looking at some of my poor captaincy choices, instead I decided to twist this to compare my choice against my lowest scoring captaincy option!

To qualify as an captaincy option they had to be my Captain or VC at least once this year which amazingly was 13 players: Pendles, Dal Santo, Ablett, Judd, Swan, Cox, Murphy, Selwood, Chapman, Goddard, Goodes, Sandi, Franklin.
So other potentials in keepers like as Pav, NRoo, Lids, Gibbs as well as all the plebs were not included.


1 Pendles 120 (Goodes 63) +57
2 Goddard 102 (Sandi 101) +1/58
3 Franklin 147 (Pendles 94) +53/111
4 Cox 87 (Judd 84) +3/114
5 Pendles 130 (Dal Santo 87) +43/157
6 Cox 131 (Goodes 47) +84/241
7 Chapman 85 (Chapman 85) -/241
8 Swan 98 (Chapman 70) +28/269
9 Swan 80 (Dal Santo 78) +2/271
10 Selwood 136 (Goddard 57) +79/350
11 Judd 83 (Judd 83) -/350
12 Judd 111 (Goodes 53) +58/408
13 Cox 105 (Goddard 84) +21/429
14 Ablett 121 (Judd 84) +37/466
15 Ablett 186 (Franklin 66) +119/585
16 Ablett 19 (Ablett 19) -/585
17 Pendles 145 (Chapman 94) +51/636
18 Swan 115 (Chapman 73) +42/678
19 Ablett 138 (Franklin 63) +75/753
20 Swan 136 (Cox 78) +58/811

Thus I’m 811 points better off than if I made the worst decision from realistic choices each week!