Comparsion!

[RichosGuns]

Geelong Fowards
NAblett: 195cm 95kg
SJohnson: 189cm 89kg
Hawkins: 197cm 105kg
Ottens: 202cm 108kg
Mooney: 194cm 99kg
Varcoe: 179cm 78kg

Average: 192.7cm 97kg

Geelong Backs
Scarlett: 192cm 95kg
Playfair: 198cm 100kg
Milburn: 189cm 92kg
Mackie: 192cm 84kg

Average: 193cm 93kgs

Richmond Fowards
Richo: 196cm 105kgs
Meyer: 183cm 70kgs
Hyde: 184cm 81kgs
Pettifer: 184cm 84kgs
Huges: 192cm 84kgs
Jackson: 188cm 90kgs
JON: 188cm 75kgs

Average: 188cm 84.1kgs

Richmond Backs
JBowden: 188cm 91kgs
Newman: 183cm 84kgs
McGuane: 191cm 76kgs
Raines: 182cm 79kgs
Moore: 190cm 86kgs
Polak: 194cm 92kgs

Average 188cm 84.7kga

Thought this would serve as a very good comparison of the foward lines which played last night. At one stage it shows that when McGuane was playing on Ottens he was giving away 11cm and 32kgs!

 

[RichosGuns]

Also shows our backman were some 13 kilos lighter then theres on average!

 

[tigerT]

replace Hyde with Schulz in our forwards. That would be a more realistic setup. and who are geelongs "small" defenders? you only have 4 in there.... I also would think that the man mountain Playfair wouldnt get a gig there too often?

 

[RichosGuns]

replace Hyde with Schulz in our forwards. That would be a more realistic setup

This was going on last nights game, Schultz played about the first 2 minutes

 

[tigerT]

yeah true, but thats due to injury and unforeseen circumstances. We usually play 3 talls standard with a 4th for cameos. So the discrepancy might not be as bad as the stats show

 

[RichosGuns]

yeah true, but thats due to injury and unforeseen circumstances. We usually play 3 talls standard with a 4th for cameos. So the discrepancy might not be as bad as the stats show

Makes no real difference mate. Height average goes up .5m and weight average goes up a kilo. The real issue here isn't the fowards. Its the backs. Even if you were to include Thursty in that it would increase the hieght or weight averages that much.

Also i think Meyer weighing only 70kgs is a real concern. Has had 2 full pre-seasons and 2 and half years on the list. No excuse

 

[tigerT]

theres no doubt they need some mass. But they are still young so youd expect them to fill out. Well you'd hope... Dunno whats happening with Meyer..

 

[krustyman]

meyer look like a 15 year old kid, what happened to him? he is supposed to be a mid fielder like just about 80% of the youth.

 

[RichosGuns]

meyer look like a 15 year old kid, what happened to him? he is supposed to be a mid fielder like just about 80% of the youth.

Listening to Browny on SEN last night and he said the bloke had great skills and will be a start but also lacks alot of discipline and can sometimes be lazy and that he should grow out of it.

For a teammate to be saying that about him in the media it really shows that he must have some dicipline or laziness issues

 

[krustyman]

Listening to Browny on SEN last night and he said the bloke had great skills and will be a start but also lacks alot of discipline and can sometimes be lazy and that he should grow out of it.

For a teammate to be saying that about him in the media it really shows that he must have some dicipline or laziness issues

Oh dear me....I think the tigers need to assign mentor to the kids so that they improve their skills, fitness and attitude especially since there is so much at stake.

 

[Sttew]

Geelong Fowards
NAblett: 195cm 95kg
SJohnson: 189cm 89kg
Hawkins: 197cm 105kg
Ottens: 202cm 108kg
Mooney: 194cm 99kg
Varcoe: 179cm 78kg

Average: 192.7cm 97kg

Geelong Backs
Scarlett: 192cm 95kg
Playfair: 198cm 100kg
Milburn: 189cm 92kg
Mackie: 192cm 84kg

Average: 193cm 93kgs

Richmond Fowards
Richo: 196cm 105kgs
Meyer: 183cm 70kgs
Hyde: 184cm 81kgs
Pettifer: 184cm 84kgs
Huges: 192cm 84kgs
Jackson: 188cm 90kgs
JON: 188cm 75kgs

Average: 188cm 84.1kgs

Richmond Backs
JBowden: 188cm 91kgs
Newman: 183cm 84kgs
McGuane: 191cm 76kgs
Raines: 182cm 79kgs
Moore: 190cm 86kgs
Polak: 194cm 92kgs

Average 188cm 84.7kga

Thought this would serve as a very good comparison of the foward lines which played last night. At one stage it shows that when McGuane was playing on Ottens he was giving away 11cm and 32kgs!

Playfair didn't play - you can have him. Perhaps you mean Egan?