Poll - Who would you rate as the weakest premiership side in the AFL era?

[Strapping Young Lad]

Average 12 posts a day for 12 years... wow... you don’t have much else going on do you?

And you’re trying even harder than the other guy!

 

[frggr]

Did you win the flag in 1995? When we beat you in finals we win the flag, you’re our lucky charm.

Luckily you very rarely make finals then

 

[frggr]

And you’re trying even harder than the other guy! s:

I'm sure they'd post more if their team was relevant at any stage in the past 40 years

 

[dean33]

I'm sure they'd post more if their team was relevant at any stage in the past 40 years

Awwwww hawks and cats fans teaming up against big bad tiger fans... how sweet.

 

[Grin]

Awwwww hawks and cats fans teaming up against big bad tiger fans... how sweet.

Poor Abasi & frggr
Can't be much of a life for either of them

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Poor Abasi & frggr
Can't be much of a life for either of them

Says the guy who keeps tagging me with nothing else to add.

 

[Grin]

Says the guy who keeps tagging me with nothing else to add.

'Cause you're a winner

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

'Cause you're a winner

I like that you're offended.

 

[frggr]

Awwwww hawks and cats fans teaming up against big bad tiger fans... how sweet.

There, there - I'm sure paying 5 guys 40% of your cap will bring harmony to Punt Road

 

[Grin]

I like that you're offended.

You are truely master of your domain
I kneel, vanquished

 

[Sterge]

Everyone who voted Richmond looking stupider by the day.

 

[thecatattack]

Everyone who voted Richmond looking stupider by the day.

You're a mod bumping a thread that hasn't been posted in, in a year?

Pull your head out and go celebrate your ******* flag.

 

[Boston tiger]

I was looking for this thread. Hilarious

 

[Sterge]

You're a mod bumping a thread that hasn't been posted in, in a year?

Pull your head out and go celebrate your ******* flag.

Found someone who voted for Richmond

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

How anyone can not vote for the crows 97/98 is amazing to me. Literally only won coz the rules of finals were BS, they came 5th lost and got a second chance. Would not have been premiers in 2019. Never top four in home and away

 

[HODGEYROAD]

My apologies to Richmond 2017 I was clearly wrong as lots of people were, still don't think these Tigers teams are up with the upper echelon as the comp is pretty weak at the top end now with equalisation but they clearly aren't the weakest as many voted.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Bulldogs easily

 

[Craze]

Need to change the poll to 'Richmond 2017-19'.

But yeh, 508 people who know f*** all about football.

 

[Sterge]

My apologies to Richmond 2017 I was clearly wrong as lots of people were, still don't think these Tigers teams are up with the upper echelon as the comp is pretty weak at the top end now with equalisation but they clearly aren't the weakest as many voted.

If the upper teams are 'weaker' because the comp is more equal then that makes winning flags more impressive not less

 

[HODGEYROAD]

If the upper teams are 'weaker' because the comp is more equal then that makes winning flags more impressive not less

Depends what way you look at it I suppose.

 

[Sterge]

Depends what way you look at it I suppose.

The correct way

Sure a super team in a weak comp will be better on paper

But a good team in an even comp is a better achievement.

 

[Ancient Tiger]

There are no weak premiers. You beat who is dished up to you. Bulldogs were amazing in 2016.

This is such a ridiculous thread.

 

[sprockets]

My apologies to Richmond 2017 I was clearly wrong as lots of people were, still don't think these Tigers teams are up with the upper echelon as the comp is pretty weak at the top end now with equalisation but they clearly aren't the weakest as many voted.

Using that argument the 'bottom' teams are now stronger, so it's harder to win against them, yes?

 

[Ron The Bear]

There, there - I'm sure paying 5 guys 40% of your cap will bring harmony to Punt Road

We are the club of love.

 

[Art Corvelay]

Richmond get 19 games in a row at the G, beat an inexperienced Brisbane, a Scott led Geelong team who couldn’t beat witches hats in finals, and then beat up on an inexperienced GWS, and somehow think this proves they are a great team? lol