VOTES (Go Ray!)

[KarmaGeddon]

3) Simon Black
2) Luke Power
1) Ray Chamberlain

When are we going to put forth a complaint to the AFL for this guys trigger whistle's against us. Three games that we've lost this year he has given away multiple fifties against us. Not only that but he definately has a TRIGGER WHISTLE. WE SHOULD examine the guy and bring evidence of biased umpiring before the AFL.

p.s well played Brisbane.

 

[BlueDevil]

can we appeal about the air pressure in the ball as well? it always seemed to bounce brisbanes way.

my way of saying we cant do anything about things out of our control. we all know ray and his ways. he likes to be the centre of attention we cant control that.

 

[KarmaGeddon]

can we appeal about the air pressure in the ball as well? it always seemed to bounce brisbanes way.

my way of saying we cant do anything about things out of our control. we all know ray and his ways. he likes to be the centre of attention we cant control that.

Sure we can. No media hoohaa. No whinging to the media. Just decisive action with the AFL.

It would be a positive move that keeps any biased umpiring off our backs, because let's face it the mentality of the AFL at the moment is that we have to earn our wins. It's called strategic, smart, psychological pressure.

 

[[ToTTi]]

A freekick Brown got towards the City End in Q3 I believe was probably the softest freekick I've ever seen. Even in touch footy it wouldn't have been paid.

Loved the cheer squad getting stuck into Ray in Q3 as well.

 

[HBF]

Some pretty soft free kicks paid tonight, that's for sure. The Fisher spoil in the 3rd quarter, then 50, then a goal IIRC, was nearly the worst one of the night I thought. As Totti said, the Brown free kick was terrible. Vey very SOFT indeed.

 

[HBK619]

3) Simon Black
2) Luke Power
1) Ray Chamberlain

When are we going to put forth a complaint to the AFL for this guys trigger whistle's against us. Three games that we've lost this year he has given away multiple fifties against us. Not only that but he definately has a TRIGGER WHISTLE. WE SHOULD examine the guy and bring evidence of biased umpiring before the AFL.

p.s well played Brisbane.

Just thought I would say.

Carlton Free Kicks for - 16, Brisbane Free Kicks for - 18.

Brisbane goals from Free Kicks - 3(including 1 from 50m penalty), Carlton goals from Free Kicks - 4.

 

[Blue Skies Ahead]

umpires had a shocker tonight, with the bulk of contentious decisions coming from ray chamberlain... does this guy have a vendetta against the club or what? at one stage he was just watching brown and o'hailpin for a solid 3 minutes to see ifhe could pin him for a free in the 3rd quarter.. and the 50m penalty against fisher for an accidental graze of the head to merret was a joke... i dont like blaming umpires but the AFL does need to have a strong hard look at some of the decisions tonight, for both teams

 

[berisha]

Carlton votes::
3. Scotland
2. Wiggins
1. Bower

 

[XXX KINGS]

Just thought I would say.

Carlton Free Kicks for - 16, Brisbane Free Kicks for - 18.

Brisbane goals from Free Kicks - 3(including 1 from 50m penalty), Carlton goals from Free Kicks - 4.

Those stats are totally awesome besides the fact that they don't tell you what the frees were paid for.

I saw some of the softest decisions ever paid tonight, just disgraceful umpiring.

 

[KarmaGeddon]

Those stats are totally awesome besides the fact that they don't tell you what the frees were paid for.

I saw some of the softest decisions ever paid tonight, just disgraceful umpiring.

Exactly, stats are meaningless without observing the context.

 

[thylacine60]

Carlton votes::
3. Scotland
2. Wiggins
1. Bower

Bloody hell, I thought everything he touched turned pretty much to mud.

 

[HBK619]

Those stats are totally awesome besides the fact that they don't tell you what the frees were paid for.

I saw some of the softest decisions ever paid tonight, just disgraceful umpiring.

Is that why Carlton were down by 7 goals at Half Time, because of poor umpiring.

As soft as the free kicks might have been, Carlton got their fair share too.

 

[koutamarto]

3. Murphy
2.Scotland
1.Wiggins

 

[XXX KINGS]

Is that why Carlton were down by 7 goals at Half Time, because of poor umpiring.

As soft as the free kicks might have been, Carlton got their fair share too.

Carlton deserved to lose by more than we did you tool, we were oviously our own worst enemy. I don't think I ever blamed them for the loss???

That doen't mean I dont have to right to criticise a sub-standard effort of umpiring that were paying decisions not within the spirit of the game, soft free kicks are ruining this sport.