Which side?

[ripitup27]

I was inspired by the thread "Can you make two teams that could beat Richmond" and decided to mix our teams up. Personally I think our VFL side could beat Richmond, but anyway, which side is better?

Kardinia Kings
B: J.Hunt H.Taylor A.Donohue
HB: D.Milburn T.Harley M.Rooke
C: C.Enright J.Bartel L.Bedford
HF: P.Chapman N.Ablett R.Gamble
F: S.Byrnes T.Hawkins T.Varcoe
R: B.Ottens J.Corey J.Selwood
Int: D.Simpson B.Moles S.Hogan S.Simpson

Skilled Saints
B: D.Wojcinski M.Scarlett D.Johnson
HB: A.Mackie M.Egan N.Djerrkura
C: K.Tenace C.Ling J.Davenport
HF: J.Kelly C.Mooney D.McKenna
F: S.Johnson T.Lonergan M.Stokes
R: M.Blake B.Prismall G.Ablett
Int: T.West J.Laidler C.Kangars S.Mumford

I'd probably pick the second side, just, because of a more solid backline and more goalkicking options. The first side has the superior midfield.

Waddayarekon?

 

[BigBadCam]

Yeh, I reckon we could just about have fielded three teams that would've beaten Richmond at stages of 07.

 

[bingle]

How demoralizing if your a tigers fan taking this stuff seriously.
I'd probably give the nod to your Skilled side. Better forward line plus scarlo down back. Both teams would account for Tigers IMO

 

[Pivo]

I'm going with the Skilled Saints as well, the combination of Scarlett at FB and Egan at CHB gets them over the line.

Mooney is also present for the Skilled Saints and he is the most dangerous of GFC's tall forwards (at the moment) as well as having Sevie J and Ablett.

But sadly, if you're a Tigers supporter, it looks like it'll be another long year.