Who's the better player? Garry Sheffield or Bobby Abreu?

[Bronx Bomber]

Recent quote from Garry Sheffield reguarding his impending trade from the New York Yankees -

"He (Abreu) is a good player, but you can draw it up any way you want and he ain't me," Sheffield said. "I understood them having to make this move for the remainder of the season, but to sit here and I'm leaving because of Abreu? I was always told you need to leave because someone is better than you and that's not the case here"

Seems like a case of sour grapes. But I thought I'd get a view of who the BigFooty members see as the better overall player.

 

[DaSawx]

I like Sheffield for his power, he can put up some damn fine numbers when he's healthy

 

[Renegade]

Yup, Sheff healthy is huge.

 

[Borgsta]

But is he ever really healthy?

 

[DaSawx]

But is he ever really healthy?

was the first year in 15 he didn't play 130 games and the first in 4 he didn't play 150, he's not doing too badly

 

[Derek Zoolander]

Bobby's numbers after coming across are massive though. Very hard to ignore.

 

[Peninsula Boy]

Bobby's clean.

End of story.