Opinion Off-Season Fun - If you could have any player from another club....

[ShanDog]

Roughead.

Top bloke. Excellent forward. Mobile. Can play any position. Him and Casboult as the two main targets up forward would be awesome and Hendo could go down back, strengthening our defence too. The most important player we could get if we had a choice of anyone would be a key forward. It fixes so many issues!

 

[BlueBelle]

Roughead.

Top bloke. Excellent forward. Mobile. Can play any position. Him and Casboult as the two main targets up forward would be awesome and Hendo could go down back, strengthening our defence too. The most important player we could get if we had a choice of anyone would be a key forward. It fixes so many issues!

Yet, in a way, we just let one go... not as good as Roughy but still

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Which player from the past in their prime would you have ag Carlton right now ?

I'd have to say Leigh Matthews, he was so tough, consistently great and durable over a long period of time,didn't watch him play, but i defer to the opinions of old timers who say he was the greatest player in history.

 

[ODNBlue]

Which player from the past in their prime would you have ag Carlton right now ?

I'd have to say Leigh Matthews, he was so tough, consistently great and durable over a long period of time,didn't watch him play, but i defer to the opinions of old timers who say he was the greatest player in history.

Kernahan.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Someone with the qualities of a Fyfe, Judd, Dangefield all rolled into one....

 

[JamisonRun40]

Someone with the qualities of a Fyfe, Judd, Dangefield all rolled into one....

Cannot like this enough x1000

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Cannot like this enough x1000

Had an argument with some main board posters once upon a time as they never thought he should be referred to as a champion.

 

[Quazza]

Which player from the past in their prime would you have ag Carlton right now ?

I'd have to say Leigh Matthews, he was so tough, consistently great and durable over a long period of time,didn't watch him play, but i defer to the opinions of old timers who say he was the greatest player in history.

Carey

Just not invited to team BBQ's

 

[Bluesince62]

Mitch Thorpe so I could see the meltdown on BF

 

[SBYM]

Gazey from the Morning Glory team.

Good for morale.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Gazey from the Morning Glory team.

Good for morale.

Turn it up....

 

[Juddalenko]

Gary Jr. Hope he comes back from his shoulder injury just as good. He is absolutely amazing - zero weaknesses in his game.

 

[Sublime]

 

[Amers]

Roughead.

 

[Number17]

I'd like to see James Hird* come out of retirement and become our new captain-coach [ducks for cover].

 

[The Coach]

Fyfe

 

[Mister Carlton]

Aaron Joseph. Has unfinished business.

 

[Jabba73]

Which player from the past in their prime would you have ag Carlton right now ?

I'd have to say Leigh Matthews, he was so tough, consistently great and durable over a long period of time,didn't watch him play, but i defer to the opinions of old timers who say he was the greatest player in history.

SOS the ultimate swingman, equally good at full back or full forward.

Right now it would be a toss of a coin between the bloke with the most appropriate name in footy in Roughead or the bloke that should be the current brownlow medallist, Fyfe.

 

[jaymasha]

Luke Parker. Absolute jet, and b&f winner.

 

[BIGGUS 64]

I'd like to see James Hird* come out of retirement and become our new captain-coach [ducks for cover].

Hird the player?
Hell yes!!

As long as no one allows him to think he might coach some day....

 

[SE_Blue]

Jarrad Waite

 

[thylacine60]

Luke Parker. Absolute jet, and b&f winner.

GF hack.......

 

[james Dean]

Josh Bootsma or Fyfe I'm split 50/50

 

[ferrisb]

Jeffy Garlett from Melbourne.

Been one of the best small forwards in the league in recent years.....

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Jeffy Garlett from Melbourne.

Been one of the best small forwards in the league in recent years.....

Too soon