Halorad
The GOAT
I think you would find most people would rate voss ahead of Hird and Buckley but they are all extremely close. Ablett is the greatest mid in history.
As far as that debate gores I think Hird has the X factor that Buckley and voss don't have.
Sometime you could watch a quarter of James hird and think that nobody else could ever be that good. It might have only happened 10 times across his career but you just remember them as though you were still in the stands. The only current players I have seen that with are Judd, buddy and Ablett.
I can't really say that with voss, not saying he wasn't as good, just that his best wasn't as memorable