Position 2021 Rookies

[Hack_Watts]

Do you have to take one this week?

Yes. Unless I leave Danger whos price will go through the roof. Could abandon Danger but don't like the idea of not having him through SC finals. Who would you pick?

 

[MacStradbroke]

Yes. Unless I leave Danger whos price will go through the roof. Could abandon Danger but don't like the idea of not having him through SC finals. Who would you pick?

View attachment 1174389
View attachment 1174390

Same here. Got a little bit extra coin so might just go Brockman, thought he looked alright early in the season.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Yes. Unless I leave Danger whos price will go through the roof. Could abandon Danger but don't like the idea of not having him through SC finals. Who would you pick?

View attachment 1174389
View attachment 1174390

Not much choice to be honest. Can you do something with Jones and get a more appealing def or mid in? Ginnivan sounds close if it must be a forward.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Same here. Got a little bit extra coin so might just go Brockman, thought he looked alright early in the season.

Fair call. I got 144k i think.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Not much choice to be honest. Can you do something with Jones and get a more appealing def or mid in? Ginnivan sounds close if it must be a forward.

Trading Jones would have been the play but too late for that. Danger might go up 50k this week...

 

[Northernsoul74]

Trading Jones would have been the play but too late for that. Danger might go up 50k this week...

ah yes Port already played. I’d post in the trades thread and see if you can get some advice. I’ve not really looked at rookies recently due to my situation.

 

[Hack_Watts]

ah yes Port already played.

I think Kelly is marginally the better call on the basis that Collingwood is lighter on KPP to medium sized talent?

 

[MacStradbroke]

Fair call. I got 144k i think.

I asked exactly your question earlier this week of pies fans and Obese Arachnid tipped me towards ginnivan over Kelly but just. If they aren’t required this week he still might be the go, sounds pretty close to selection.

 

[Hack_Watts]

I asked exactly your question earlier this week of pies fans and Obese Arachnid tipped me towards ginnivan over Kelly but just. If they aren’t required this week he still might be the go, sounds pretty close to selection.

I guess with Ginnivan the have McCreery back in a couple of weeks?

 

[Jiska]

Should be playing this week apart from dumb selection, kicked 4 goals in the vfl last week and our team can’t kick a goal to save themselves

Might take him instead of Sharp. Should get a good go once he gets a game. Pies have backed wookies once they’re in the side.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Might take him instead of Sharp. Should get a good go once he gets a game. Pies have backed wookies once they’re in the side.

Hopefully gets a good run after this week, got some mongrel in him too. Gave the bird after his 4th goal last week

 

[Hack_Watts]

Might take him instead of Sharp. Should get a good go once he gets a game. Pies have backed wookies once they’re in the side.

If all the rookies look bad at least saving 20-40k and getting a DPP is wise?

 

[Jiska]

If all the rookies look bad at least saving 20-40k and getting a DPP is wise?

I like Sharp, he looks good. But the extra 40k and no DPP is a bit of a concern. I’ve got Bianco to switch down there if required. Probably not that much diff to Sharp.

 

[Hack_Watts]

I like Sharp, he looks good. But the extra 40k and no DPP is a bit of a concern. I’ve got Bianco to switch down there if required. Probably not that much diff to Sharp.

Who would you take out of Ginivan and Kelly Jiska?

 

[Jiska]

Who would you take out of Ginivan and Kelly Jiska?

As in Will Kelly? What happened in his first game? Was he medical sub?

Reckon at this stage versatility key. DPP helpful. Problem is that Ginnivan may not play. Should but no certainty.

 

[Hack_Watts]

As in Will Kelly? What happened in his first game? Was he medical sub?

Reckon at this stage versatility key. DPP helpful. Problem is that Ginnivan may not play. Should but no certainty.

Yep will Kelly. Sadly I didn't take Jeka and I need a forward rookie by 2:30pm to bring in Danger...

 

[Jiska]

Yep will Kelly. Sadly I didn't take Jeka and I need a forward rookie by 2:30pm to bring in Danger...

4:30 you mean.

Not sure depends on your team. Does a DPP forward help? And do you have decent cover at F7 already?

 

[Hack_Watts]

4:30 you mean.

Not sure depends on your team. Does a DPP forward help? And do you have decent cover at F7 already?

Poor cover sadly. The DPP may help later to swing with Finn Macrae. May eventually be able to upgrade Bramble and Jones 1 up 1 down for cover though which makes me lean towards the cheaper Ginnivan:



5 trades and 88k. Thanks mate

 

[Jiska]

Poor cover sadly. The DPP may help later to swing with Finn Macrae. May eventually be able to upgrade Bramble and Jones 1 up 1 down for cover though which makes me lean towards the cheaper Ginnivan:

View attachment 1174493
View attachment 1174494
5 trades and 88k. Thanks mate

You can’t trade Sharp in anyway?

Risky having no cover at F7 or F8

 

[Hack_Watts]

You can’t trade Sharp in anyway?

Risky having no cover at F7 or F8

Went with Kelly. Will no doubt be the wrong call! Thanks for your input mate really appreciate it

 

[Jiska]

Went with Kelly. Will no doubt be the wrong call! Thanks for your input mate really appreciate it

Good luck mate!

 

[Andrew Birch]

1/4 time in the VFL
Ginnivan 3 goals

 

[stevebbb]

1/4 time in the VFL
Ginnivan 3 goals

Finished with 4 goals 2 behinds

I'd be shocked if he doesn't debut next week

 

[Faz 2000]

This Minivan fellows sounds like the ticket. I need one of these ultra budget MFers to play so I can finish my on-field team.

Collingwood looks like the source... Fin Macrae? Minivan? Is the North RF Edwards gonna get a go?

Even 20-30 points a week would be acceptable as pure cover, but who is gonna play?

 

[rocker_oz33]

This Minivan fellows sounds like the ticket. I need one of these ultra budget MFers to play so I can finish my on-field team.

Collingwood looks like the source... Fin Macrae? Minivan? Is the North RF Edwards gonna get a go?

Even 20-30 points a week would be acceptable as pure cover, but who is gonna play?

North Edwards won't play this year.
He's at play school..