Trades 2024 Round 2 Trades

[54Dogs]

OK, so after preaching conservative, sensible trades, I'm looking for advice on how to do the exact opposite.

I'm pretty committed to trading Fisher to Heeney and want help to find the $95K or so I need (as I only have $11K in the bank).

This is the team...

View attachment 1935465
View attachment 1935466

Options:
Option 1: Amon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney ($266K ITB to upgrade Gibcus to Mass next week and fix other rookies) - I actually like the Amon pick - he averaged 107 when moved to the backline at the end of last year and scored 89 week 1 with very little kick in opportunities due to Essendon's accuracy. But he will probably only average 95-100 (so not a MUST have) and I suspect there will be a number of backline premiums available to us throughout the year.
Option 2: Bontempelli to Serong/Green, Fisher to Heeney - OK, so I know this sounds crazy/sideways/point chasing. I know Bont will remain a good pick and you don't waste trades doing sideways moves of premium players that are not injured. But, as I was saying preseason, Bont has averaged 116-120 every other year besides last season and premium prices converge down as rookies increase in value so I am certain he will be available for $100K cheaper later. Confident the likes of Green can match him for 100K less, allowing me to get in Heeney and I can roughie Bont back in later for less.
Option 3: Jordon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney - In some ways, this feels more comfortable but Jordon is averaging in the 80's for less than $280K and obviously has some money to make. I'm paying 480K for Amon for example, who also scored in the 80's. However, Footywire also suggests that he will only make about $50-$60K over the next 3 weeks but I'm not sure if they are basing that on continuing to score 80's or something less? If only $60 odd thousand to be made (and not a keeper), that is justifiable to me.

(Had hoped to do Z.Williams to Hore instead but am about $1K short)

So, which option do you like best (or can you see another way to find $90K ish)??

Thanks all.

A single Amon > Heeney looks the obvious play. Sort out the backs next week. Fisher is not an urgent concern, plenty would like to hold him this week if Heeney wasn't on the bubble

 

[JT_the_Man]

Screw it, if they burn me they burn me.

Fisher to Berry
Martin to Heeney

A nice bank for next week.

 

[SC fish]

Screw it, if they burn me they burn me.

Fisher to Berry
Martin to Heeney

A nice bank for next week.

Yep 40 trades = enough for a few roughies here are there, right Judd_Magic ?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

OK, so after preaching conservative, sensible trades, I'm looking for advice on how to do the exact opposite.

I'm pretty committed to trading Fisher to Heeney and want help to find the $95K or so I need (as I only have $11K in the bank).

This is the team...

View attachment 1935465
View attachment 1935466

Options:
Option 1: Amon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney ($266K ITB to upgrade Gibcus to Mass next week and fix other rookies) - I actually like the Amon pick - he averaged 107 when moved to the backline at the end of last year and scored 89 week 1 with very little kick in opportunities due to Essendon's accuracy. But he will probably only average 95-100 (so not a MUST have) and I suspect there will be a number of backline premiums available to us throughout the year.
Option 2: Bontempelli to Serong/Green, Fisher to Heeney - OK, so I know this sounds crazy/sideways/point chasing. I know Bont will remain a good pick and you don't waste trades doing sideways moves of premium players that are not injured. But, as I was saying preseason, Bont has averaged 116-120 every other year besides last season and premium prices converge down as rookies increase in value so I am certain he will be available for $100K cheaper later. Confident the likes of Green can match him for 100K less, allowing me to get in Heeney and I can roughie Bont back in later for less.
Option 3: Jordon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney - In some ways, this feels more comfortable but Jordon is averaging in the 80's for less than $280K and obviously has some money to make. I'm paying 480K for Amon for example, who also scored in the 80's. However, Footywire also suggests that he will only make about $50-$60K over the next 3 weeks but I'm not sure if they are basing that on continuing to score 80's or something less? If only $60 odd thousand to be made (and not a keeper), that is justifiable to me.

(Had hoped to do Z.Williams to Hore instead but am about $1K short)

So, which option do you like best (or can you see another way to find $90K ish)??

Thanks all.

Amon to McKercher

 

[JoeGab]

Gibcus + Lazzaro to Hore + Berry. I could boost williams to massimo but I dont see the point wasting a boost and a trade on someone who might not even crack top 18 and wont change price till after next round.

 

[iDon]

Fisher/Lazarro > T Berry

Then a debate. Just hold Gibcus/Reid and miss out on Heeney, or go early on Mass and boot Martin… Obviously holding could open me up to massive carnage next week.

I'm holding Martin. Happy with decision

 

[Ollie1981]

Hi Legends
Thought on the below trades.
Gibcus -> Hore
Clark -> Thomas Berry

16

Thomas Berry

Age

23

Ht

185cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.8

2star

K

3.2

1star

HB

4.6

3star

M

2.0

2star

T

2.2

4star

G

0.0

1star

D

7.8

2star

K

3.2

1star

HB

4.6

3star

M

2.0

2star

T

2.2

3star

G

0.0

1star

D

7.8

2star

K

3.2

2star

HB

4.6

4star

M

2.0

3star

T

2.2

4star

G

0.0

1star

(Move Laz Mid)

Or

Gibcus -> Hore
Lazzaro -> Billings

Yes i know i would be going a week early on Hore.
Any suggestions?

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Hi Legends
Thought on the below trades.
Gibcus -> Hore
Clark -> Terry (Move Laz Mid)

Or

Gibcus -> Hore
Lazzaro -> Billings

Yes i know i would be going a week early on Hore.
Any suggestions?
View attachment 1935723

If you trade Gibcus to Hore then the week Melbourne have their bye, you will be one short in your Defenders (unless you have someone to replace Reid with) and one short in your Rucks. Leaves you with 20 on field...

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Hi Legends
Thought on the below trades.
Gibcus -> Hore
Clark -> Terry (Move Laz Mid)

Or

Gibcus -> Hore
Lazzaro -> Billings

Yes i know i would be going a week early on Hore.
Any suggestions?
View attachment 1935723

This is good
Gibcus -> Hore
Lazzaro -> Billings

Have you thought about buffing up your DEF a bit more ....by considering

Gibcus to Massimo
Lazzaro to Sam Berry ($226K) ....via Wilson to FWD's

Assume the latter trade would have to be done next week, as Wilson as already played

 

[stevebbb]

This is good
Gibcus -> Hore
Lazzaro -> Billings

Have you thought about buffing up your DEF a bit more ....by considering

Gibcus to Massimo
Lazzaro to Sam Berry ($226K) ....via Wilson to FWD's

Assume the latter trade would have to be done next week, as Wilson as already played

Sam Berry? Last week's performance was trash, hardly any midfield time. If it wasn't for that late goal, he would have scored 60ish.

He's on the chopping block to be traded OUT next week, unless his performance (not score) improves.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Sam Berry? Last week's performance was trash, hardly any midfield time. If it wasn't for that late goal, he would have scored 60ish.

He's on the chopping block to be traded OUT next week, unless his performance (not score) improves.

30% approx CBA's ...any $226K player scoring an 80 of a trash performance .....off-setting that goal, Sam Berry didn't get his customary high # of tackles ...his #1 wood is tackling

 

[Judd_Magic]

Yep 40 trades = enough for a few roughies here are there, right Judd_Magic ?

 

[Ollie1981]

If you trade Gibcus to Hore then the week Melbourne have their bye, you will be one short in your Defenders (unless you have someone to replace Reid with) and one short in your Rucks. Leaves you with 20 on field...

Round 6 is when Melbourne have the bye. Yes i would be 1 short on DEF unless i trade Reid. for my Rucks i will move Jackson in the ruck and Livingstone in the FWD bench.

 

[St Steady]

30% approx CBA's ...any $226K player scoring an 80 of a trash performance .....off-setting that goal, Sam Berry didn't get his customary high # of tackles ...his #1 wood is tackling

View attachment 1935785

alot of slow thinking sanfl players probably inflates your statistical evidence and dillusional observance a touch ?

 

[Rioli magic]

alot of slow thinking sanfl players probably inflates your statistical evidence and dillusional observance a touch ?

He averages 6.6 tackles a game in the AFL across his career, averaged 9.5 tackles a game in 2022 across 18 games.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Trades Done

 

[toxic]

OK, so after preaching conservative, sensible trades, I'm looking for advice on how to do the exact opposite.

I'm pretty committed to trading Fisher to Heeney and want help to find the $95K or so I need (as I only have $11K in the bank).

This is the team...

View attachment 1935465
View attachment 1935466

Options:
Option 1: Amon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney ($266K ITB to upgrade Gibcus to Mass next week and fix other rookies) - I actually like the Amon pick - he averaged 107 when moved to the backline at the end of last year and scored 89 week 1 with very little kick in opportunities due to Essendon's accuracy. But he will probably only average 95-100 (so not a MUST have) and I suspect there will be a number of backline premiums available to us throughout the year.
Option 2: Bontempelli to Serong/Green, Fisher to Heeney - OK, so I know this sounds crazy/sideways/point chasing. I know Bont will remain a good pick and you don't waste trades doing sideways moves of premium players that are not injured. But, as I was saying preseason, Bont has averaged 116-120 every other year besides last season and premium prices converge down as rookies increase in value so I am certain he will be available for $100K cheaper later. Confident the likes of Green can match him for 100K less, allowing me to get in Heeney and I can roughie Bont back in later for less.
Option 3: Jordon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney - In some ways, this feels more comfortable but Jordon is averaging in the 80's for less than $280K and obviously has some money to make. I'm paying 480K for Amon for example, who also scored in the 80's. However, Footywire also suggests that he will only make about $50-$60K over the next 3 weeks but I'm not sure if they are basing that on continuing to score 80's or something less? If only $60 odd thousand to be made (and not a keeper), that is justifiable to me.

(Had hoped to do Z.Williams to Hore instead but am about $1K short)

So, which option do you like best (or can you see another way to find $90K ish)??

Thanks all.

Dawson to Max Holmes
Fish to blonde
Gibcus to massimo

 

[WaynesWorld19]

alot of slow thinking sanfl players probably inflates your statistical evidence and dillusional observance a touch ?

Fair comment ...however those tackling numbers were repeated in his 2022 AFL Stats

 

[54Dogs]

Don't care if JHF is out, don't care if it's a decimated Tigers, don't care if it's a boost I never want to see Wines in my team again.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Don't care if JHF is out, don't care if it's a decimated Tigers, don't care if it's a boost I never want to see Wines in my team again.

View attachment 1935961

That's fine, but no bitching after Wollie goes 130 vs Richmond.

 

[Jack Lindon]

OK, so after preaching conservative, sensible trades, I'm looking for advice on how to do the exact opposite.

I'm pretty committed to trading Fisher to Heeney and want help to find the $95K or so I need (as I only have $11K in the bank).

This is the team...

View attachment 1935465
View attachment 1935466

Options:
Option 1: Amon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney ($266K ITB to upgrade Gibcus to Mass next week and fix other rookies) - I actually like the Amon pick - he averaged 107 when moved to the backline at the end of last year and scored 89 week 1 with very little kick in opportunities due to Essendon's accuracy. But he will probably only average 95-100 (so not a MUST have) and I suspect there will be a number of backline premiums available to us throughout the year.
Option 2: Bontempelli to Serong/Green, Fisher to Heeney - OK, so I know this sounds crazy/sideways/point chasing. I know Bont will remain a good pick and you don't waste trades doing sideways moves of premium players that are not injured. But, as I was saying preseason, Bont has averaged 116-120 every other year besides last season and premium prices converge down as rookies increase in value so I am certain he will be available for $100K cheaper later. Confident the likes of Green can match him for 100K less, allowing me to get in Heeney and I can roughie Bont back in later for less.
Option 3: Jordon to T.Berry, Fisher to Heeney - In some ways, this feels more comfortable but Jordon is averaging in the 80's for less than $280K and obviously has some money to make. I'm paying 480K for Amon for example, who also scored in the 80's. However, Footywire also suggests that he will only make about $50-$60K over the next 3 weeks but I'm not sure if they are basing that on continuing to score 80's or something less? If only $60 odd thousand to be made (and not a keeper), that is justifiable to me.

(Had hoped to do Z.Williams to Hore instead but am about $1K short)

So, which option do you like best (or can you see another way to find $90K ish)??

Thanks all.

You got just a bit greedy in the Mids with a 480k M6. Easy fix.
Gibcus > Mass
Amon > Kirch
Fisher > Heeney
Spare $$ for next week

 

[THE_GUN]

Trades Done

View attachment 1935915

Welcome the Hulk Hogan train Brada

 

[King Max]

Fisher to Billings?
Either can spud it up, but extra $135k thrown into SC bank.
Billing’s BE is lower and will raise in price. another 90-100 and boom!
Fisher BE is higher and needs a 90-100 to restart the cash generation.
Just convinced myself to trade.

 

[jdwood]

This game has genuinely jumped the shark.

Trading a $463k player (Wines) after a score in the 90s.

And talking about trading a $230k player (Berry) after a score in the 80s.

It’s now just roulette for people with short attention spans.

 

[BuckleysBrigade]

Welcome the Hulk Hogan train Brada