Moved Thread Bailey Smith vs Sam Walsh

Who's better


  • Total voters
    182
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Walsh is an All Australian and his numbers are dipping because the Carlton midfield has gone from a one man show to an even spread unit. Baz is having a better season but Walsh is not worse than him

Walsh has been huge the past 4-5 weeks. Took a minute to adjust.

He's overtaken Smith this year, is beating him in every stat and imo is impacting games more.

 
Did you even look at the stats? He's beating him in handballs and efficiency 😅

disposals, marks, DE, contested/uncontested possies, supercoach.

actually you're right upon a closer look it's pretty tight, but given Walsh had a (by his standards) poor first 3-4 weeks and he's made up this much ground in such a short period, he will end up having the better season.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Baz is great. But he is so undisciplined around the contest its so fustrating. He will often give up goal side to his opponent. Get sucked into a contest leaving huge room behind him. He will learn in time but it's so fustrating to watch.
 
FU7jh23aUAA2IGj

Ill take Walsh thanks
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Back
Top