There is a lot more to that story than meets the eye - there were plenty of good judges that "queried" this purchase at the time including Dr Turf. Put simply the horse was not worth $5M on type - it was all hype for BC3 and as we now know "The Edge". Laminitis is an insidious disease - and there is no known cure just a management plan - BUT there have been a big swing in claims were Laminitis is listed as the cause of death.
Can of worms just got bigger.
My understanding is that his near fore was on sideways and the X-ray of his near fore knee was ordinary, so yes on type he was not worth 5M, from memory most good judges thought the Fastnet Colt that the Hawkes camp ended up with was clearly the best horse on type.
I do remember Turfy on radio as the news broke of his illness saying that the sale of Jimmy was very suspect as there were no serious biders and in fact the underbidders looked as though they were going to have heart attack when they thought they would end up with him, it seemed very scripted.
The entire situation stinks, I find it extremely hard to believe that Jimmy's illness is just one big coincidence!