Mod. Notice Bigfooty Womens Board POTY: Round 5

[The_Wookie]

Vote for your 1,2,3

I swear Ill do a leaderboard soon

 

[fanackapan]

Carlton vs Bulldogs
3. Blackburn (WB)
2. Davey (Carl)
1. Vescio (Carl)

Fremantle vs Collingwood
3. Eva (Coll)
2. Hooker (Fre)
1. Stevens (Coll)

Adelaide vs Brisbane
3. Bates (BL)
2. Marinoff (Adel)
1. Frederick-Traub (BL)

 

[Jivlain]

GWS vs Melbourne
3. Dal Pos (GWS)
2. Paxman (Mel)
1. Swanson (GWS)

Carlton vs Bulldogs
3. Vescio (Car)
2. Blackburn (Wbd)
1. Lucas-Rodd (Car)

Fremantle vs Collingwood
3. Kuys (Col)
2. Filocarno (Fre)
1. Hope (Col)

Adelaide vs Brisbane
3. Frederick-Traub (Brl)
2. Marinoff (Ade)
1. Bates (Brl)

 

[Teen Wolf]

GWS Giants vs Melbourne
3: Jess Dal Pos (GWS)
2: Karen Paxman (Melb)
1: Emma Swanson (GWS)

Carlton vs Western Bulldogs
3: Ellie Blackburn (WB)
2: Darcy Vescio (Carl)
1: Tilly Lucas-Rodd (Carl)

Fremantle vs Collingwood
3: Jessica Cameron (Coll)
2: Lara Filocamo (Frem)
1: Alicia Eva (Coll)

Adelaide vs Brisbane Lions
3: Emily Bates (BL)
2: Erin Phillips (Adel)
1: Kate McCarthy (BL)

Also, by my count, this is the tally of all the votes given so far:

If we're to abide by that simple (albeit imperfect) system, the leaderboard would look like this:

 

[Teen Wolf]

spooner21 Gigantor Toucan Soup ilovemeatpies Canary threenewpadlocks or anybody else following along, interested to get your thoughts if you saw some of the action on the weekend?

 

[Canary]

spooner21 Gigantor Toucan Soup ilovemeatpies Canary threenewpadlocks or anybody else following along, interested to get your thoughts if you saw some of the action on the weekend?

I've only had time to watch the Melbourne games over the past couple of weeks. From our game vs. GWS

3. E. Swanson
2. D. Pearce
1. J. Dal Pos

 

[Teen Wolf]

I've only had time to watch the Melbourne games over the past couple of weeks. From our game vs. GWS

3. E. Swanson
2. D. Pearce
1. J. Dal Pos

As they say, every vote counts! (and dilutes the influence of my own input, which can't be a bad thing)

 

[spooner21]

spooner21 Gigantor Toucan Soup ilovemeatpies Canary threenewpadlocks or anybody else following along, interested to get your thoughts if you saw some of the action on the weekend?

GWS vs Melbourne
3. J. Dal Pos
2. E. Swanson
1. K. Paxman

Carlton vs Bulldogs
3. E. Blackburn
2. J. Lambert
1. T. Lucas-Rodd

Fremantle vs Collingwood
3. A. Eva
2. D, Hooker
1. L. Filocamo

Adelaide vs Brisbane
3. E. Bates
2. C. Randall
1. L. Kaslar

 

[Toucan Soup]

Adelaide V Brisbane

3. E Bates
2. S Frederick-Traub
1. Kate Lutkins

Teen Wolf : As is quite self-evident, my voting is certainly biased (although if more votes were cast, then that impact would be negated). With the new league, it sometimes feel that players with a stronger media profile are afforded extra votes - but I guess that is the case everywhere.

Let's get topical: at this stage, I'm just hoping that Brisbane can do enough to claim top spot & host the final at the Gabba.

 

[Canary]

Also re; the leaderboard, given the small voting numbers it might make more sense to have 3 'total' votes rather than ties counting as 'one vote,' sort of the the way it works at the Olympics if two people tie for Gold there is no Silver awarded - only a Bronze.

The way this would work for, say, the BL v. Collingwood game in round three is this:

3 (10) - S. Frederick-Traub
3 (10) - E. Zielke
1 (6) - S. D'Arcy

McCarthy would receive no votes.

This would hopefully concentrate the votes a bit better.

 

[Teen Wolf]

As is quite self-evident, my voting is certainly biased (although if more votes were cast, then that impact would be negated). With the new league, it sometimes feel that players with a stronger media profile are afforded extra votes - but I guess that is the case everywhere.

Hey, we're all biased in one way or another. I know for me personally I usually value attacking play over defence, and AFL umpires award Brownlow votes to ball-winners more often than not, etc.

Also re; the leaderboard, given the small voting numbers it might make more sense to have 3 'total' votes rather than ties counting as 'one vote,' sort of the the way it works at the Olympics if two people tie for Gold there is no Silver awarded - only a Bronze.

That's a good solution for the example you used, I'm just not sure how it gets implemented for some of the more heavily deadlocked ties (such as Round 3 GWS vs Freo)? The_Wookie might have already decided how he wants it to work, but I think basically any route is going to be mostly okay.

 

[The_Wookie]

happy for you to do it your way teenie

 

[Teen Wolf]

Great! So with two rounds left, here's how things are looking:

Verrry tight at the top.