I'm a little the other way. Buckley has at least two attributes that set him apart. I'm not sure that Graham has.Sounds cruel but I'm not sold on Buckley just yet.
I am though sold on Graham, Cripps and even Giles.
Most of all I think the relationship between VFL form and AFL form can be tenuous at times. Hard to make calls with any level of confidence until they have a decent run in the 1's.