Analysis Evaluate our first rounders

[George Kramer]

Pick a first rounder and state their trade value. This will give an indication of our drafting with top end picks.I’ll start it off:

McAsey: 60-70

 

[pjcrows]

Pick a first rounder and state their trade value. This will give an indication of our drafting with top end picks.I’ll start it off:

McAsey: 60-70

Lawrence Angwin: 4th rounder

 

[dogs105]

Lance Picioane. We got pick 79.

 

[Stephen2]

Assumption: pick 80 is "no value"

Player	Picked at	Current worth/worth at best	Differential
Josh Rachele	6	1	+5
Riley Thilthorpe	2	5	-3
Luke Pedlar	11	25	-14
Brayden Cook	25	25	0
Fischer McAsey	6	80	-74
Chayce Jones	9	40	-31
Ned McHenry	16	60	-44
Darcy Fogarty	12	50	-38
Jordan Gallucci	15	80	-65
Wayne Milera	11	40	-29
Tom Doedee	17	10	+7
Jake Lever	14	10	+4
Brodie Smith	14	5	+9

Sum total: -273
Avg for 13 picks: -21

So give us pick 1, and we can make it worth pick 22 for ya! We're very talented.

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Assumption: pick 80 is "no value"

Player	Picked at	Current worth/worth at best	Differential
Josh Rachele	6	1	+5
Riley Thilthorpe	2	5	-3
Luke Pedlar	11	25	-14
Brayden Cook	25	25	0
Fischer McAsey	6	80	-74
Chayce Jones	9	40	-31
Ned McHenry	16	60	-44
Darcy Fogarty	12	50	-38
Jordan Gallucci	15	40	-25
Wayne Milera	11	40	-29
Tom Doedee	17	10	+7
Jake Lever	14	10	+4
Brodie Smith	14	5	+9

Sum total: -233
Avg for 13 picks: -18

So give us pick 1, and we can make it worth pick 19 for ya! We're very talented.

Gallucci? He wasn't worth a packet of Nobby's Nuts.

 

[Stephen2]

Gallucci? He wasn't worth a packet of Nobby's Nuts.

● 3rd among rising stars in Inside 50s Per Game in 2018

● 5th among rising stars in Metres Gained Per Game in 2018

end 2018 he looked... alright. Someone might have given us those nuts.

 

[George Kramer]

● 3rd among rising stars in Inside 50s Per Game in 2018

● 5th among rising stars in Metres Gained Per Game in 2018

end 2018 he looked... alright. Someone might have given us those nuts.

He was delisted, that’s his ranking

 

[Stephen2]

He was delisted, that’s his ranking

Fair call. adjusted. We're now even worse!

 

[Scorpus]

Only doing players we haven't traded

High First Round Pick
Rachele
Thilthorpe

Late First Round Pick
Nil

Second Round Pick
Cook
Pedlar
Doedee

Third Round Pick
Jones
McHenry
Milera
Fogarty

Fourth Round Pick
McAsey

Fifth Round Pick
Gallucci (at the time of his delisting)

Doedee a tough one. I think he's worth a late first to us but when was the last time a medium defender was traded for a first rounder?

 

[CrowToon]

Third Round Pick
Jones
McHenry
Milera
Fogarty

Fourth Round Pick
McAsey

Couldn't see another club actually paying anything as high as that for that crop of players. Just a bit of clever accounting if they did.

 

[Wazzy36]

I forgot that Milera was a pick 11... sheesh. It doesn't make for good viewing does it.

 

[Grenville]

Only doing players we haven't traded

High First Round Pick
Rachele
Thilthorpe

Late First Round Pick
Nil

Second Round Pick
Cook
Pedlar
Doedee

Third Round Pick
Jones
McHenry
Milera
Fogarty

Fourth Round Pick
McAsey

Fifth Round Pick
Gallucci (at the time of his delisting)

Doedee a tough one. I think he's worth a late first to us but when was the last time a medium defender was traded for a first rounder?

Pretty close i think

 

[Pugsley]

Plenty of misses and two hits.

 

[GreyCrow]

Lawrence Angwin: 4th rounder

That would be a steal

 

[Rags_118]

Only doing players we haven't traded

High First Round Pick
Rachele
Thilthorpe

Late First Round Pick
Nil

Second Round Pick
Cook
Pedlar
Doedee

Third Round Pick
Jones
McHenry
Milera
Fogarty

Fourth Round Pick
McAsey

Fifth Round Pick
Gallucci (at the time of his delisting)

Doedee a tough one. I think he's worth a late first to us but when was the last time a medium defender was traded for a first rounder?

Jordan Dawson?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Jordan Dawson?

Not a first rounder.

 

[Rags_118]

If the GWS game was anything to go by, few if any recruiters would pick Rachelle ahead of Callaghan.

 

[lincsPJ]

Lawrence Angwin: 4th rounder

Time to release the Meese. Let’s see what he can do.

 

[skam85]

Doedee a tough one. I think he's worth a late first to us but when was the last time a medium defender was traded for a first rounder?

Lever?

 

[DJ75]

Only doing players we haven't traded

High First Round Pick
Rachele
Thilthorpe

Late First Round Pick
Nil

Second Round Pick
Cook
Pedlar
Doedee

Third Round Pick
Jones
McHenry
Milera
Fogarty

Fourth Round Pick
McAsey

Fifth Round Pick
Gallucci (at the time of his delisting)

Doedee a tough one. I think he's worth a late first to us but when was the last time a medium defender was traded for a first rounder?

On the open market, Doedee is top 15. As is Cook. Cook has shown that he can play at the level AND that he has enormous potential still. That translates in to a strong pick.

 

[GROTTO]

Lawrence Angwin: 4th rounder

Dont give up on him just yet, we still have hope.

Angwin eyes return to AFL

Angwin eyes return to AFL

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[relapse]

Here are my brutually honest assessments of our first round picks.

Rachele = blue chip talent, potential Top 50 player.
Thilthorpe = looking promising, but still has a lot of development ahead of him.
Pedlar = too early to call, but has been somewhat disappointing thus far.
McAsey = MASSIVE BUST
Jones = BUST
McHenry = BUST
Fog = BUST

 

[GROTTO]

Here are my brutually honest assessments of our first round picks.

Rachele = blue chip talent, potential Top 50 player.
Thilthorpe = looking promising, but still has a lot of development ahead of him.
Pedlar = too early to call, but has been somewhat disappointing thus far.
McAsey = MASSIVE BUST
Jones = BUST
McHenry = BUST
Fog = BUST

When you look at our busts, you can see why Carlton has taken over 20 years to rebuild.

 

[George Kramer]

Here are my brutually honest assessments of our first round picks.

Rachele = blue chip talent, potential Top 50 player.
Thilthorpe = looking promising, but still has a lot of development ahead of him.
Pedlar = too early to call, but has been somewhat disappointing thus far.
McAsey = MASSIVE BUST
Jones = BUST
McHenry = BUST
Fog = BUST

Throw in Gallucci and its disasterous reading. How Hamish is not facing a massive amount of scrutiny is beyond me.

Look at where Ginnivan was drafted and what he is producing compared to McHenry.

Jones, top 10 pick is playing back pocket and the pass mark for a good game is when he doesn't * up.

As for McAsey, FMD.

I had high hopes for Pedlar, still think he can make it but hell, he'd want to be showing a lot more in the SANFL and on a consistent basis.

 

[rocket18]

Throw in Gallucci and its disasterous reading. How Hamish is not facing a massive amount of scrutiny is beyond me.

Look at where Ginnivan was drafted and what he is producing compared to McHenry.

Jones, top 10 pick is playing back pocket and the pass mark for a good game is when he doesn't fu** up.

As for McAsey, FMD.

I had high hopes for Pedlar, still think he can make it but hell, he'd want to be showing a lot more in the SANFL and on a consistent basis.

That horrendous reading and very hard to argue, seems like the better picks we've had the worse we've become at selecting talent.