Really?
Looks quite small in that pic.
Toast Matt Rosa - Welcome back as assistant coach!
- Thread starter Suma Magic
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Looks quite small in that pic.
Aish was not expected to fall to our original pick iirc.
Having said that, Sheed is the better player anyway and Aish has so far not proved to be someone I would have wanted our club to take with a very high pick.
Cut down by some bad injuries in his peak. Was a really important link man during 2011-2013. Not sure he can be too ropeable about being sub in the finals given he was coming back from injury. Thanks for the service Matty, hope you can get your body right and do well at GC.
there are 2 strong arguments for motive , 1 . the longer contract at a weaker club . so its just a business decision near the end of his career . 2. His nose out of joint for being the substitute in the Gf and Pf
Would take Sheed over Aish and Scharenberg at this stage of their careers based on what they've shown.
Sheed's only 20. Big effort to be in the best 22 of a Grand Final team as an inside mid. Very underrated IMO.
aussiechris
Debutant
- Jan 17, 2015
- 67
- 95
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I remember aish was supposed to have gone earlier than 7 but aish probably would have asked for a trade and been a wasted pic to us.happy with the drop to 11 and wa boy in sheed.
I wish rosa the best at the suns next year
I wish rosa the best at the suns next year
How often do they get our player names wrong!
they should have got this right atleast, considering each player selected are/have been elite players.
They got the team wrong too. Dumbarses.
Can't blame the reporter for not being obsessed like us. It's not like Gaff has got his name written on his hat or anything like that.
its their job to get it right.
Further off topic, Gaff in that IRS training get-up just confirms him as surely one of the least intimidating looking AFL players of all time. He just looks like your m8
Rosa still has a few years left in him.
If he was fringe player this season, he would have certainly struggled more next season.
So changing clubs, is a good move for him.
For West Coast, we lose an experienced player, that was versatile, and well liked.
So I'm sad to see him go. I hope he has a fruitful few years at Gold Coast, because he deserves it.
If he was fringe player this season, he would have certainly struggled more next season.
So changing clubs, is a good move for him.
For West Coast, we lose an experienced player, that was versatile, and well liked.
So I'm sad to see him go. I hope he has a fruitful few years at Gold Coast, because he deserves it.
There's pretty limited chat about Rosa on the Gold Coast board, which surprises me
I think they're underplaying the acquisition - he will be quite good for them
I think they're underplaying the acquisition - he will be quite good for them
I agree, I think his experience will be massive for them and he'll bring a running capacity no one at that club has shown. He might only have three years but they'll be a consistent three years where he racks up possessions from day 1.
Yeah it really depends on whether they want to allow a player to take up a spot til retirement when they could otherwise give it to a developing player who will be part of a flag push.
If they were closer to a flag i'd be excited, but they're still a while off so I can understand the muted enthus
- Feb 12, 2008
- 10,448
- 20,173
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I know Rosa is tall(ish) but he looks like a 7 footer in that pic.
because prestia is a midget.
- Feb 12, 2008
- 10,448
- 20,173
- AFL Club
- West Coast
175cm looks like its generous.
Damn good footballer though.
Makes me want Lovell even more.
iLikeIt
All Australian
- Oct 23, 2015
- 997
- 1,323
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Although seeing Yeo and Redden (looking short at 190cm) running along Giles gives some perspective.
Similar threads
- Poll
