our best 22 come the start of 2014?

[Spitter9]

​

Mullett Thompson Atley​

Hansen Grima McDonald​

MacMillan Ziebell Wells​

Harvey Tarrant Black​

Thomas Petrie Adams​

Rucks: Goldstein Cunnington Bastinac​

bench: Mckenzie Hine Garner Gibson​

Swallow the obvious one out with injury.​

​

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

B:Macmillan Thompson Grima
HB:McDonald Hansen Atley
C:Mullet Bastinac ?????
HF: Ziebell Black Thomas
F:Harper Petrie Tarrant

R:Goldstein Cunnington Wells

I:Gibson Harvey Mckenzie Adams

We need another winger. Will this be someone already on the list? New draftee? Free agent?

 

[Jay-Z]

B:Macmillan Thompson Grima
HB:McDonald Hansen Atley
C:Mullet Bastinac ?????
HF: Ziebell Black Thomas
F:Harper Petrie Tarrant

R:Goldstein Cunnington Wells

I:Gibson Harvey Mckenzie Adams

We need another winger. Will this be someone already on the list? New draftee? Free agent?

Gibson and Harvey are both starting 18 IMO which means Gibson, Bastinac or MacMillan will likely be on the other wing

 

[The Nostradamus]

B: Mullett Thompson Hansen
HB: Atley Grima McDonald
C: Bastinac Ziebell Mckenzie
HF: Harvey Tarrant Garner
F: Thomas Petrie Black
R:Goldstein Wells Cunnington
I: Greenwood Macmillan Adams
S: Jacobs

Hope Swallow is ready for round 1 but left him out to be safe

 

[Reginald0]

Surprised at the low key reception for Garner
Looks exactly wot we need someone who can Tackle
and likes doing it
Take note Basti BMac Sirra
I think Wright is looking fringe if this bloke comes good

No doubt he will be in Rnd 1 team

 

[Ahern2Boof]

FB: Hansen - Thompson - MacMillan
HB: Mullett - Grima - McDonald
C: Bastinac - Cunnington - Atley
HF: Harvey - Black - Adams
FF: Thomas - Petrie - Tarrant
R: Goldstein - Ziebell - Wells
I/C: McKenzie - Garner - Gibson - Harper
EMG: Wright - Currie - Hine

Things get interesting when Swallow returns and if we pick up some players in the FA period.

 

[Winter]

First of many to come:

Mcmahon Thompson Hansen
Atley Grima Mullett
Gibson Ziebell Bastinac
Harvey Tarrant Harper
Black Petrie Thomas
Goldstein Cunnington Wells
IC: Macmillan McKenzie McDonald
Sub: Garner

Out: Swallow (Inj)

 

[Black2Blue]

B: Hansen Grima Mullett
HB: McMillan Thompson McDonald
C: Wells Cunnington Atley
HF: Harvey Black D.Thomas
F: Tarrant Petrie L.Thomas
R: Goldstein Ziebell Bastinac
Inter: Gibson Garner Adams McKenzie
Emerg: Garlett Wood Harper

Might make last minute change in late Feb.

 

[jclei]

B: Hansen Thompson McMahon
HB: Mullett Grima McDonald
C: Wells Cunnington Atley
HF: Harvey Tarrant Adams
F: Thomas Petrie Black
R: Goldstein Ziebell Bastinac

Int: Gibson Macmillan McKenzie Harper
EMG: Garner Daw Jacobs

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

B: C.Delaney - Thompson - McDonald
HB: Atley - Hansen - Mullet
C: McKenzie - Cunnington - Dal Santo
HF: Harvey - Petrie - Wells
F: Wood - Black - L.Thomas
R: Goldstein - Ziebell - Bastinac
Inter: Swallow - Greenwood - Garner - Harper

Emerg: Garlett Currie Firitto
Daw. MacMillan Wright
Gibson Hine Jacobs

 

[Roo-Boy]

Only Brad Scott knows the best 22 by round 1 2014. That's his job not us supporters.

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Yeah, I've been thinking about it, and it might pay to experiment over the off-season with players that have obvious talents which should be utilized but just haven't found form/their niche:

B: Macmillan Thompson Grima
HB: Macdonald Hansen Harper
C: McKenzie Bastinac Mullet
HF: Ziebell Black Thomas
F: Harvey Petrie Tarrant

R: Goldstein Cunnington Wells

I: Atley Wright Gibson Adams

 

[trooroo4life]

B: Hansen - Thompson - C.Delaney
HB: Mullet - Grima - McDonald
C: Atley - Cunnington - Bastinac
HF: Harvey - Black - Garner
F: Thomas - Petrie - Tarrant
R: Goldstein - Ziebell - Wells

I: Harper - MacMillan - Gibson - Adams
Emg: Jacobs - Wright - McKenzie

Getting harder and harder to pick a best 22, which is a good sign of depth i suppose.

 

[Daz]

C.Delaney Thompson Mullett​

Atley Grima Hansen​

Bastinac Cunnington Wells​

Harvey Tarrant Adams​

Thomas Petrie Black​

Goldstein Swallow Ziebell​

McDonald MacMillan Gibson McKenzie​

​

​

- I'm choosing to believe that Swallow's 25 years of church going will result in special healing powers.​

​

- Hansen to play loose, hence the tall looking backline. Spare Keys in a battle with Spud for the 3rd tall role.​

​

- McDonald to play a mixture of defence and wing. A bit like Vlastuin this year and Ellis the year before. But, you know, better.​

​

- JMac to become a permanent winger.​

 

[Rod Stroker]

McDonald best 22 for round 1 already?

I'll get hounded for this but I wouldn't have JMac as best 22. I reckon others will go past him in the pecking order.
I'd probably even have Wright ahead of JMac, Wright offers more when "on"

 

[Rockstar6]

B: Hansen Thompson Mullett
HB: Atley Grima MacMillan
C: Bastinac Wells Gibson
HF: Harvey Tarrant Adams
F: Thomas Petrie Black
Ruck: Goldstein Cunnington Ziebell
Interchange: McKenzie, McDonald, Firrito
Sub: Harper

Like everyone else, Swallow is out with the Achilles injury

 

[Daz]

McDonald will be our most ready to go first rounder since Ziebell.

 

[Only Forwards]

McDonald will be our most ready to go first rounder since Ziebell.

He will step straight in.

Whats more I reckon he will step straight in and lead.

 

[5 GB USB]

B: Jmac Thompson Hansen
HB: McDonald Grima Mullett
C: Dal Santo Cunnington Atley
HF: Harvey Tarrant Adams
FF: Black Petrie Thomas
Ruck: Goldy Wells Ziebell
I:Bastinac McKenzie Gibson Sub: Jacobs

Atley to move to the middle after a big preseason with the midfielders. McDonald then takes Atley spot.
Dal Santo a welcome introduction on the wing.
*Swallow (injured)

 

[Page8383]

McDonald will be our most ready to go first rounder since Ziebell.

Yes. (Assuming he goes first round that is - Tell me im dreaming)

A year in the VFL, a pre season, it's like a 10-15 game head start,

 

[B4Bear]

McDonald best 22 for round 1 already?

I'll get hounded for this but I wouldn't have JMac as best 22. I reckon others will go past him in the pecking order.
I'd probably even have Wright ahead of JMac, Wright offers more when "on"

Totally agree.

Are we Melbourne, looking for the next big thing in the draft?

 

[Shermanator]

B: Jmac Thompson Hansen
HB: McDonald Grima Mullett
C: Dal Santo Cunnington Atley
HF: Harvey Tarrant Adams
FF: Black Petrie Thomas
Ruck: Goldy Wells Ziebell
I:Bastinac McKenzie Gibson Sub: Jacobs

Atley to move to the middle after a big preseason with the midfielders. McDonald then takes Atley spot.
Dal Santo a welcome introduction on the wing.
*Swallow (injured)

Nice squad

 

[Mailman]

no love for Hine? i think we picked up a good player there

Also, i think that Daw will be very close to the mark for best 22 next season. Tarrant might need to get prepared for the back line..... I won't be able to deal with another year of Goldy playing as the lone ruckman. Daw offers more versatility than Currie (but happy for either)

 

[tales129]

Minimal love for harper, its going to be tight from here onwards, with potentially best 22 players in the vfl! Good depth

 

[Mailman]

B: MacMillan, Thompson, Mullet
HB: McDonald, Hansen, McKenzie
Mids: Goldstein, Ziebell, Swallow; Wells, Cunnington, Atley
HF: Harvey, Black, Bastinac
F: Thomas, Petrie, Tarrant

Bench: Daw/Currie, Hine, Gibson, Harper