DaSawx
Brownlow Medallist
Way too up and down
Retired #19: David Hille - Three games short of 200.
- Thread starter DaSawx
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Way too up and down
Re: 19. David Hille
Great game from him. Actually looked like a proper tap ruckman.
Great game from him. Actually looked like a proper tap ruckman.
monty1104
Premium Platinum
Re: 19. David Hille
Needs to find consistency.
Needs to find consistency.
David Hille
Pitiful last night and copped a brox cheer for it from our own fans just like Justin Murphy copped in round 20' 05 and it turned out to be his last game for the club.
Has Hille played his last game for the club?
Is he on the table come trade week?
Pitiful last night and copped a brox cheer for it from our own fans just like Justin Murphy copped in round 20' 05 and it turned out to be his last game for the club.
Has Hille played his last game for the club?
Is he on the table come trade week?
monty1104
Premium Platinum
Re: David Hille
We should look far a trade IMO, but we ned to be sure that Ryder is ready to play 30-40% of the game in the ruck, otherwise Hille is still needed, unless we trade for a ruckman anyway.
We should look far a trade IMO, but we ned to be sure that Ryder is ready to play 30-40% of the game in the ruck, otherwise Hille is still needed, unless we trade for a ruckman anyway.
Re: David Hille
I am sick to death of his mistakes. He has absoloutely no footy smarts. How was the time in the last quarter when he stood 1 metre away from the ruck contest and decided to spectate as Tuck sharked it and goaled across his body ? Laycock has clearly taken over from him as our number one ruck, and Laycock himself has plenty of flaws but at least he tries his guts out and does plenty each week to show that he is going to get better and better. Hille just does nothing.
I am sick to death of his mistakes. He has absoloutely no footy smarts. How was the time in the last quarter when he stood 1 metre away from the ruck contest and decided to spectate as Tuck sharked it and goaled across his body ? Laycock has clearly taken over from him as our number one ruck, and Laycock himself has plenty of flaws but at least he tries his guts out and does plenty each week to show that he is going to get better and better. Hille just does nothing.
Re: David Hille
Hille isnt a bad footballer. He didn't play well yesterday but that doens't take away from the fact that he can be a good ruckman, not great but good. Trading him is a risk, as it means Ryder will have to ruck and he may be mroe useful elsewhere. However, Laycock looks 5 times better when he is allowed to ruck the majority of a game and Hille obviously doens't like being the number two ruckman. If we can get a great deal, which is possible as a 24 year old ruckman who has shown a bit and has more improvement in him is a rare trade commodity, then we should maybe look at a trade.
Hille isnt a bad footballer. He didn't play well yesterday but that doens't take away from the fact that he can be a good ruckman, not great but good. Trading him is a risk, as it means Ryder will have to ruck and he may be mroe useful elsewhere. However, Laycock looks 5 times better when he is allowed to ruck the majority of a game and Hille obviously doens't like being the number two ruckman. If we can get a great deal, which is possible as a 24 year old ruckman who has shown a bit and has more improvement in him is a rare trade commodity, then we should maybe look at a trade.
monty1104
Premium Platinum
Re: David Hille
He is good around the grounds, when he can go body on body. But in the centre bounce, he is useless. He mistimes his jump and doesnt try and hit the other player, which he should try and do seeing as though he would be one of the heaviest ruckmen going around.
Bomber Stu
Rookie
Re: David Hille
Seems to be low on confidence more than anything, new coach might change things around.
Can't see him being trade bait.
Will Ryder move into the ruck on a permanet basis? I thought he was the next CHB
Seems to be low on confidence more than anything, new coach might change things around.
Can't see him being trade bait.
Will Ryder move into the ruck on a permanet basis? I thought he was the next CHB
Re: David Hille
What about developing him more as a Jonathon Brown type CHF. He's the same body type and I've seen him kick some huge goals from the 50. Pity, I thought last year was the making of him, but he's definately gone backwards this year
What about developing him more as a Jonathon Brown type CHF. He's the same body type and I've seen him kick some huge goals from the 50. Pity, I thought last year was the making of him, but he's definately gone backwards this year
monty1104
Premium Platinum
Re: David Hille
Yeah, because we are really lacking in CHF's
Yeah, because we are really lacking in CHF's
Re: David Hille
Simply put, he can be a good player, but he should not be crucified for last night's shithouse effort. And he was s**t.
Simply put, he can be a good player, but he should not be crucified for last night's shithouse effort. And he was s**t.
Re: David Hille
Maybe if Scotty Lucas could manage to kick the ball on to the guys chest not 5 metres in front of him it would help....
Maybe if Scotty Lucas could manage to kick the ball on to the guys chest not 5 metres in front of him it would help....
Stants_24_Legend
Cancelled
- Banned
- #22
Re: David Hille
I remember saying something like this about 12 weeks ago....
HE IS A DUD bad thing is...he has become so s**t we wont get anything for him..
I remember saying something like this about 12 weeks ago....
HE IS A DUD bad thing is...he has become so s**t we wont get anything for him..
Re: David Hille
I guess none of you bagging him remember that goal he kicked from 55 that went through half way up or the one he got in the goal square... Yeah what a dud.. Did more then a lot of other players yesterday
I guess none of you bagging him remember that goal he kicked from 55 that went through half way up or the one he got in the goal square... Yeah what a dud.. Did more then a lot of other players yesterday
monty1104
Premium Platinum
Re: David Hille
Yeah, but that was after the worst marking attempt in the history of the game. He went for it one handed, and turned his head. He broke the 2 basic rules of marking: two hands and keep your eyes on the ball. It was embarrasing as far as im concerned.
Stants_24_Legend
Cancelled
- Banned
- #25
Re: David Hille
yeah he did do more...more turnovers than anyone else...look i wouldnt mind if he did play at CHF great kick for goal...but he continuly is rucking...he is too worried about the man coming at him....use his 110kg body and no one will stop him... BUT FFS DONT RUCK HIM!!!
Similar threads
