spudmaster
Brownlow Medallist
Updated the lists.
My ranks:
(1) Sydney:
Kennedy, Jack, McVeigh, Hannebery, Parker, McGlynn, Bird
(8) Hawthorn:
Mitchell 9 NS votes, Hodge 10 NS votes, Burgoyne, Smith, Lewis 9 NS votes, Sewell, Hill
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Updated the lists.
My ranks:
(1) Sydney:
Kennedy, Jack, McVeigh, Hannebery, Parker, McGlynn, Bird
(8) Hawthorn:
Mitchell 9 NS votes, Hodge 10 NS votes, Burgoyne, Smith, Lewis 9 NS votes, Sewell, Hill
hahhahahhahahahhahaClaye will be the Nathan Ablett of the Beams family unless he requests a trade to Collingwood so we can unleash is potential. I think Dayne enjoys playing with A graders in Swan and Pendlebury so i dont see why he would request a trade to Brisbane to play alongside Tom"my touches dont damage, at all"Rockliff and the rest of the C graders over at Brisbane.
It was all abit of banterhahhahahhahahahhaha
Claye will be the Nathan Ablett of the Beams family unless he requests a trade to Collingwood so we can unleash is potential. I think Dayne enjoys playing with A graders in Swan and Pendlebury so i dont see why he would request a trade to Brisbane to play alongside Tom"my touches dont damage, at all"Rockliff and the rest of the C graders over at Brisbane.
Sidebottom is pretty handyFair to say Collingwood now have one of the worst midfields in decades.
Pendlebury, Adams, Greenwood, Varcoe... really struggling to name anyone.
Geelong aren't too flash eitherFair to say Collingwood now have one of the worst midfields in decades.
Pendlebury, Adams, Greenwood, Varcoe... really struggling to name anyone.
Port 3rd best?1. Hawthorn
2. Brisbane
3. Port
4. Gold Coast
5. Sydney
6. Freo
7. North
8. Essendon
9. Richmond
10. Geelong
11. Adelaide
12. West Coast
13. GWS
14. Carlton
15. Collingwood
16. Bulldogs
17. Melbourne
18. St Kilda
you go for adelaide, therefore your opinion on port is invalidPort 3rd best?
yeah, nah
Yet you rank Gold Coast (Brisbane's rival) 4th on your flawed list.you go for adelaide, therefore your opinion on port is invalid
brisbane - gold coast rivalry is pretty much non existent. port and adelaide hate eachothers guts though, everyone knows thatYet you rank Gold Coast (Brisbane's rival) 4th on your flawed list.
ahhh hypocrisy..
Anyways, how is ports midfield the 3rd best in the comp. I need a laugh.
Fair enough.brisbane - gold coast rivalry is pretty much non existent. port and adelaide hate eachothers guts though, everyone knows that
any midfield with the likes of Boak and Gray in it is going to be elite, then you chuck in Wines, Hartlett, Cornes, Ebert, Polec & Wingard and you got an incredibly strong midfield
brisbane - gold coast rivalry is pretty much non existent. port and adelaide hate eachothers guts though, everyone knows that
any midfield with the likes of Dangerfield and Sloane in it is going to be elite, then you chuck in B. Crouch, Douglas, S. Thompson, M. Crouch, Smith & Lyons and you got an incredibly strong midfield
Gray>DangerFair enough.
Each to their own I guess. I personally don't think it is THAT good.
you could argue:
Although, I agree it isn't as well rounded, crows top end talent is better IMO
unfortunately this is probably trueChuck in Aish next year and it can only get better
lol, ok.Gray>Danger
Boak>Sloane
Wines>B.Crouch
Hartlett=Douglas
Cornes<Thompson
Ebert>M.Crouch
Polec>Lyons
Smith isn't even a midfielder
Port's is comfortably better
port/brisbane comparison would be a lot closer
Gray>D.Beams
Boak=Rockliff
Wines<Hanley
Hartlett=Rich
Cornes=Redden
Ebert=Christensen
Polec<Zorko
Gray was ablett-like at times this year, absolute gunDude overestimating Gray by miles.
Turning 27. 1 good year in his entire career.
Beams and Danger are both 24 and already better than Gray.
I thought that was the general consensus around here.
Although he was very good this year you have to take into account things like his age, consistency.Gray was ablett-like at times this year, absolute gun
I'd take beams and danger over gray to have at my club because of gray's age and injury history... but that doesn't change the fact that Gray's the better playerAlthough he was very good this year you have to take into account things like his age, consistency.
Bottom line is Beams and Danger are younger, and have arguably shown a greater degree of ability and done so over a longer period of time.