Rd 8 St Kilda v Collingwood - Player Votes

[Kildonan]

Please feel welcome to vote

We're using a flexible system of voting where 15 pts are allocated to vote with. You can give a maximum vote of 5 pts and a minimum of 1 pt for any one player.

Typical Vote: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 4, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 5, L Hayes 5, L Ball 2, S Milne 2, J Geary 1
Acceptable: N Riewoldt 3, L Hayes 3, L Ball 3, S Milne 2, J Geary 1, J Koschitzke 1, L Montagna 1, D Armitage 1

Please be aware that there are two Fishers, Clarkes, and Gardiners so please use initials to clarify.

This thread will be stickied until next Friday and the totals will be tabulated.

 

[TassieSaint]

5 Luke Ball (Deserves a medal for that effort, did the club proud)
3 Nick Dal Santo
2 Lenny Hayes
2 Sam Fisher
1 Robert Harvey
1 Max Hudghton
1 Leigh Montagna

Blake and Birss did great jobs but did verrrry little else.

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

5 L Ball
4 R Harvey
3 N Dal Santo
2 L Hayes
1 M Hudghton

 

[Mick_15]

5 L Ball
4 N Dal Santo
3 L Hayes
2 M Hudgton
1 M Gardiner

 

[foxy_dal]

5. Ball
4. Dal Santo
3. Hayes
2. Harvey
1.S . Fisher

 

[35Harvs]

5 - Ball
4- Hayes
3- dal
2- Max
1 - S Fisher

 

[Look2Me4Guidance]

5 - L Ball

4 - L Hayes

3 - M Gardiner

2 - M Hudghton

1 - J Blake

 

[makemytime]

4 - L Ball
3- S Fisher
3 - M Hudghton
3 - L Montagna
2 - L Hayes

 

[Squizz]

2 Ball (needs to take the shot when inside 50)
2 Sam F
2 Dal
2 Harvs (what a second half)
1 Lenny (could have got more but for missed shots)
1 Monty
1 BJ
1 Gram
1 Max (stiffed by the umps)
1 Gardi (great night. tried to win the game for us, but don't think we used him enough).
1 Blakey (smashed Cloke but didn't get much of his own ball).

 

[Sir Robert]

5 - Ball
4- Hayes
3- dal
2- Max
1 - L Fisher

Do you mean S Fisher? Leigh was bloody hopeless. Refer passengers thread. Couldn't get a kick in an a$s kicking contest. This bloke needs to be dropped for us to win games. Simple as that. Poor disposal, poor decision making... Basically poor.

My votes:

5 - Ball
4 - Hayes
3 - M Gardiner
2 - Dal Santo
1 - Max

 

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Dal Santo
4 - Ball
3 - Harvey
2 - Hayes
1 - S Fisher
1 - Blake

 

[bluejay]

5. Ball
4. Hayes
3. Dal Santo
2. Harvey
1. S. Fisher

 

[The Punter]

5 Ball
4 Harvey
3 Hayes
2 Montagna
1 S Fisher

 

[35Harvs]

Do you mean S Fisher? Leigh was bloody hopeless. Refer passengers thread. Couldn't get a kick in an a$s kicking contest. This bloke needs to be dropped for us to win games. Simple as that. Poor disposal, poor decision making... Basically poor.

lol - oops !! thanks have changed

 

[Fox7]

5 Ball
4 Dal
3 Lenny
3 Big Fish

 

[Nothingman11]

5 Bally
3 Hayes
3 Dal
2 Harvs
1 Armo
1 BJ

 

[Danger Mouse]

5 Harvey
5 Ball
3 Hayes
2 M Gardiner

 

[Kildonan]

oops - I forgot to put mine down

4 Luke Ball
3 Nick Dal Santo
3 Sam Fisher
2 Lenny Hayes
2 Robert Harvey
1 Shane Birss