No Oppo Supporters Re-signing Tex, Danger and Sloane *** Crows Only ***

[alex_is_on_fire]

That trade definitely favours Collingwood.

Out of interest - how and why?

 

[matty p]

That trade is weighted far too heavily in Collingwood's favour. They'd get Dangerfield for a completely unproven Scharenberg and a very minor downgrade in picks (we might actually have a higher pick than them by the end of the season). Can't see that happening.

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

That trade is weighted far too heavily in Collingwood's favour. They'd get Dangerfield for a completely unproven Scharenberg and a very minor downgrade in picks (we might actually have a higher pick than them by the end of the season). Can't see that happening.

No, we will win next 3 and play finals. They won't.

 

[Tex Support]

Collingwood get a top 5 elite player for Adam Oxley & Scharenburg and move a few spots back in the first round.

Collingwood wins by the length of the straight.

 

[Jarman3]

No need for a comma there.

Maybe change to Yoda-speak to remove any ambiguity around the necessity (or otherwise) of a comma?

"Trying too hard, you are now".

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Collingwood get a top 5 elite player for Adam Oxley & Scharenburg and move a few spots back in the first round.

Collingwood wins by the length of the straight.

Look, If PD leaves. I'm going to be happy if we end up with Aish, Schenberg and a top 5 pick and the look on Geelong face will be priceless.

 

[dylan123]

Not as if we'd be losing if he does want out.

 

[Heafy83]

That trade is weighted far too heavily in Collingwood's favour. They'd get Dangerfield for a completely unproven Scharenberg and a very minor downgrade in picks (we might actually have a higher pick than them by the end of the season). Can't see that happening.

Don't think you can look at like that. You need to look at it from the perspective of what we could get if Danger were just to leave via FA. In that case its a compo pick at 12+ roughly. When you look at it like that then its a great deal for us. You are never going to get fair value for him. You also have to think about the Aish ramifications. If we dealt directly with brissy for Aish its likely to cost us our first pick or an acquired pick between 12-20. If he is part of a deal like this then we get him for a second rounder bc they are getting a quality youngster in return. Of course this is all very hypothetical.

 

[Bacon8]

Collingwood get a top 5 elite player for Adam Oxley & Scharenburg and move a few spots back in the first round.

Collingwood wins by the length of the straight.

Of course, Collingwood could get a top 5 elite player for nothing, so giving up Oxley & Scharenburg on top is a loss for them (in some sense).

 

[Tex Support]

Look, If PD leaves. I'm going to be happy if we end up with Aish, Schenberg and a top 5 pick and the look on Geelong face will be priceless.

As would I, but I'd be praying to Lord Jesus/Ala/Buddha/whoever will listen that Aish & Scharenberg reach even half their potential in an AFC jumper, because we'd need them to if it meant losing a brownlow medal level game changer...

Doesnt matter, he's staying remember

 

[1990crow]

Had me worried there Alex, Collingwood get too much out of that deal

 

[headache1]

Just an idea. Trying to make something work as i'm bored today.

Haha, so it's a massive rumour that was conceived, and is currently going around in your head? Guess it's got as much weight as any other rumour going around.

 

[moogerfooger]

The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.

Watch Jon Ralph go ahead and write about it in the herald sun anyway.

 

[haydo]

Massive rumour going around.

Dangerfield to Collingwood
Scharenberg to crows
Aish to Crows
Oxley to Brisband

Crows get: Scharenberg, Aish & Collingwood first pick (approx 6 to 8)
Crows lose: Dangerfield, first round pick (to Collingwood), second round pick (to Brisbane)

Collingwood get: Dangerfield & Crows first pick (approx pick 10 to 12)
Collingwood lose: Oxley & first pick (approx 6 to 8)

Brisband get: Adam Oxley & crows second round pick (approx 26)
Lose: Aish

Ahh, I remember the old Playstation AFL trade weeks. Let's be honest, too many players involved. Don't think the brains trust of the AFL could handle something like that. They'd rather simple trades. It is the AFL after all

 

[alex_is_on_fire]

Haha, so it's a massive rumour that was conceived, and is currently going around in your head? Guess it's got as much weight as any other rumour going around.

Geelong are like an ex girlfriend we are trying to find a way of forgetting.

 

[headache1]

On the trade front. That policy allowing clubs to trade future draft picks. Is that coming in this year, or next?

 

[footy4ever]

Surely your sig should read 'You'll LEVER walker sloane'?

This should be immortalised somewhere! As clever as I've seen on BF.



….Nice fluke newbie!

 

[Heafy83]

On the trade front. That policy allowing clubs to trade future draft picks. Is that coming in this year, or next?

You would have to think next. Not enough time to allow clubs to prepare now for this year.

 

[Draft Bored]

On the trade front. That policy allowing clubs to trade future draft picks. Is that coming in this year, or next?

You would have to think next. Not enough time to allow clubs to prepare now for this year.

It's coming in this year. Already announced.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-commission-trading-future-draft-picks-20150728-gimgzk.html

 

[headache1]

You would have to think next. Not enough time to allow clubs to prepare now for this year.

I stopped being lazy and Googled it for myself. It's coming in this year apparently.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-commission-trading-future-draft-picks-20150728-gimgzk.html

 

[footy4ever]

Massive rumour going around.

Dangerfield to Collingwood
Scharenberg to crows
Aish to Crows
Oxley to Brisband

Crows get: Scharenberg, Aish & Collingwood first pick (approx 6 to 8)
Crows lose: Dangerfield, first round pick (to Collingwood), second round pick (to Brisbane)

Collingwood get: Dangerfield & Crows first pick (approx pick 10 to 12)
Collingwood lose: Oxley & first pick (approx 6 to 8)

Brisband get: Adam Oxley & crows second round pick (approx 26)
Lose: Aish

I'd rather give Danger away for free and keep our first and second round picks. No emoticon needed. I'm serious.

 

[FyfeToAdelaide]

This should be immortalised somewhere! As clever as I've seen on BF.



….Nice fluke newbie!

Been said many times

Was Yol(men) Lever Walker Sloane

 

[Pugsley]

You would have to think next. Not enough time to allow clubs to prepare now for this year.

4 week trade period. 2 weeks required to crunch numbers

 

[Pdub]

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/showdown-xxxix.1104484/page-40#post-39710032

 

[WhiskeyTangoFoxtrot]

Out of interest - how and why?

They basically downgrade half a dozen picks in the first round and lose 2 unproven players for a top 10 midfielder who is a proven contested ball winner that also has outside speed and can play forward.