TurboBreuster
Cancelled
Maybe Wines and Docherty?
Round 3 trades
- Thread starter stevebbb
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
option 2.
love gray, but fyfe gives you capt option
i had to give nvb a miss too :-(
I hear ya, but Fyfe could come in as early as round 6 and more likely round 8.
Assume:
Fyfe = 130
Gray = 110
NVB = 85
Heeney = 65
Option 1 Gray + NVB: If Gray goes 110 and Fyfe 130 over 3-5 rounds, that's 60-100 points foregone (excepting captain choice) in order to get NVB. But I would play NVB over Heeney for 3-5 rounds (net gain 60-100 points) so they cancel out. I expect NVB to make about $175k over the time I have him, and McGrath about $145k, so I would be up $30k. Fyfe would cost me $40-45k more in 3-5 rounds though.
Points benefit: nil
Cost: $10-15k
Option 2 Fyfe + McGrath: I expect NVB to make about $175k over the time I have him, and McGrath about $145k. So that's $30k foregone in order to get Fyfe now (but Fyfe would have gone up $40-45k by round 6-8 anyway, so lets say I'm $10-15k up on the deal). However I would have to play Heeney on field instead of NVB, so cost of 60-100 points over 3-5 rounds - this is offset by taking Fyfe over Gray.
Points benefit: nil
Cash benefit: $10-15k
Option 3 Fyfe + NVB: Get Fyfe and NVB now and cop the Bont donut. Extra 60-100 points of Fyfe over Gray, plus extra 60-100 points of NVB over Heeney, makes a net gain of 120-200 points over 3-5 rounds. Take out Bont's donut (100) and it's 20-100 points up over 3-5 rounds and 30k up by taking NVB over McGrath (plus the $30k more Fyfe would have cost me in round 6-8, so call it $60k up).
Points benefit: 20-100
Cash benefit: $60k
Plus Bontempelli may yet play.
I'm warming to the idea of option 3
karaoke
Norm Smith Medallist
- Mar 26, 2013
- 6,812
- 14,570
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Gray & NVB - better combo & Gray's DPP is handy & is legitimate Captain/VC option as well
Cheers krk004, what are your thoughts on Fyfe + NVB and the risk of a Bont donut? Might be worth it in the long run?
Jiska
Moderator
- Moderator
- #2,231
Wait until Bonts is out. Pendles (107) wasn't playing all week either.I hear ya, but Fyfe could come in as early as round 6 and more likely round 8.
Assume:
Fyfe = 130
Gray = 110
NVB = 85
Heeney = 65
Option 1 Gray + NVB: If Gray goes 110 and Fyfe 130 over 3-5 rounds, that's 60-100 points foregone (excepting captain choice) in order to get NVB. But I would play NVB over Heeney for 3-5 rounds (net gain 60-100 points) so they cancel out. I expect NVB to make about $175k over the time I have him, and McGrath about $145k, so I would be up $30k. Fyfe would cost me $40-45k more in 3-5 rounds though.
Points benefit: nil
Cost: $10-15k
Option 2 Fyfe + McGrath: I expect NVB to make about $175k over the time I have him, and McGrath about $145k. So that's $30k foregone in order to get Fyfe now (but Fyfe would have gone up $40-45k by round 6-8 anyway, so lets say I'm $10-15k up on the deal). However I would have to play Heeney on field instead of NVB, so cost of 60-100 points over 3-5 rounds - this is offset by taking Fyfe over Gray.
Points benefit: nil
Cash benefit: $10-15k
Option 3 Fyfe + NVB: Get Fyfe and NVB now and cop the Bont donut. Extra 60-100 points of Fyfe over Gray, plus extra 60-100 points of NVB over Heeney, makes a net gain of 120-200 points over 3-5 rounds. Take out Bont's donut (100) and it's 20-100 points up over 3-5 rounds and 30k up by taking NVB over McGrath (plus the $30k more Fyfe would have cost me in round 6-8, so call it $60k up).
Points benefit: 20-100
Cash benefit: $60k
Plus Bontempelli may yet play.
I'm warming to the idea of option 3
I can't wait for final team Jiska, Dogs play Sunday whereas NVB, Gray, McGrath play today.
Taylor Adams wasn't playing all week either ...
Thats a pickle Crows play first game today and the puppies play on Sunday.
Jiska
Moderator
- Moderator
- #2,234
Haven't seen you team posted anywhere, but may have missed it?
Generically speaking, you shouldn't make rash moves and compromise the makeup of your team just to avoid a donut in one week.
Last week I switched Goodes to the bench when I heard he was sub and didn't even think to move the E from Goodes to Oxley nor did I think I needed to. Twenty minutes after the Dogs game started, Gibson was announced as a late out and I copped Goodes' 10 points.
Disappointing, but there was no way in the world I even considered trading out Gibson to avoid Goodes' ten points.
Anyone care to predict what they think Wines & Sloane will average this year?
SimplySublime
Debutant
All this chatter about the Bont scares me.
I had Gaz > Bont pencilled in as an easy choice, now what? What do I do? contemplating just taking no risk and going Gaz to Sloane.
This is hard.
there's no one who i can trade in really if I want to wait until tomorrow either, unless I take the likes of Mundy or Barlow, with Neale & Fyfe in my midfield already, that isn't much of an option.
Prestia/Bennell are the other options, then switch Bennell FWD later...
Thoughts?
I had Gaz > Bont pencilled in as an easy choice, now what? What do I do? contemplating just taking no risk and going Gaz to Sloane.
This is hard.
there's no one who i can trade in really if I want to wait until tomorrow either, unless I take the likes of Mundy or Barlow, with Neale & Fyfe in my midfield already, that isn't much of an option.
Prestia/Bennell are the other options, then switch Bennell FWD later...
Thoughts?
Is getting Sloane instead of Wines worth an extra trade then?
Hehe all my rookies and bench players are the top ones for their positions. Not in too 10 but happy where I'm at ATM No Ablett or rocky. Selwood the player that's going to lose me money while all the rest go up (besides newnes smh gone next week) figure selwood gunna go down at least 100k and I always use two trades before week 3 concludes..brought in oxley but still got one trade left lol. Know I'm being ridiculous tho
No. Options are as follows:
1. GAJ > Sloane this week, Next week, Goodes > Byrne, Pearce > Smith.
2. GAJ > Wines, Pearce > Smith (both this week) - if Smith doesn't play I'll get Oxley's 98.
The other benefit of Option 2 is I'm not rushed to trade Goodes > Byrne, can wait until he's on the bubble.
Asho81
Club Legend
- Apr 6, 2015
- 1,485
- 665
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Keep Wines... surely theres another way to get Sloane?
Who are your trading options?
Asho81
Club Legend
- Apr 6, 2015
- 1,485
- 665
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
How much cash does Gaz to Sloane leave you? Who else would you consider trading out?
After Gaz > Sloane I'm left with 160k. Pearce & Goodes the only players I'd trade out, rest is solid. Has to be a defender as I don't have DPP link.
Yeah but you're talking there about the rashness of trading out a premium simply to avoid a one-week donut. I'm not making any moves I wouldn't have made anyway. Ablett was coming out for Fyfe all week, and I've been weighing up Goodes to NVB v Goodes to McGrath in my mind. NVB won out in the end, and it's only now Bont is a rumoured out that I'm considering whether NVB is the must have I decided he was.
As it turns out I can play CEY instead of Heeney, so any points benefit of NVB over Heeney is moot. Fyfe + McGrath looking like the best option (provided McGrath keeps getting games).
Asho81
Club Legend
- Apr 6, 2015
- 1,485
- 665
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yeah, not a smart idea. Don't ever trade a Keeper (not sure about you, but Selwood IMO is a keeper) for a Keeper..... you upgrade non-keepers to keepers.
- Status
