Round 3 trades

[Kadog]

Gaj>Sloane is LOCKED. First trade of the year.

I've got 151k banked.
My midfield is now Pendles Fyfe Jelwood Sloane Griffen alongside Heeney CEY Vandenberg Jed Cripps Touk as my cas cows.

Do I pull a second trade of Touk Miller>NvB(m6) costing me 100k... or do I have sufficient cash cows to pass the NVB train and just bank the money?

 

[ashley12]

I don't think there are many cows coming in the next few weeks so I would jump on, particularly since it would only be the second trade of your season as opposed to your fourth.

 

[Kadog]

I don't think there are many cows coming in the next few weeks so I would jump on, particularly since it would only be the second trade of your season as opposed to your fourth.

My concern lies with my net gain in that trade. Will likely make 70-85k out of it over the next month or so. Is it really worth it?

 

[PACatter]

Getting my hand forced by rumors of Bonty's late out rumor...

Do I cop the donut, or go Lids to a money-earner with the expectation of coming back to a fallen premo in a few weeks? Was content to let Lids on the bench for the extra week, but not if it means a big 0 on the field. My other FWD bench spot is Kane Lambert and no, I can't go Lambert to McGrath, I come up around 4k short.

If I do switch Lids, I'd be looking at either Pavs to make good points and a little money, or McGrath to make big money but lowered points expectation.

 

[SnappyHappy]

My concern lies with my net gain in that trade. Will likely make 70-85k out of it over the next month or so. Is it really worth it?

I'm still 50:50 on NVB. Has over acheived so far but even with 70's he will still make some quick money. I'm not sure that it's worth a traded and 100k though, I have all the best rookies apart from NVB so not sure it's neccessary.

 

[Krujan]

Gaj>Sloane is LOCKED. First trade of the year.

I've got 151k banked.
My midfield is now Pendles Fyfe Jelwood Sloane Griffen alongside Heeney CEY Vandenberg Jed Cripps Touk as my cas cows.

Do I pull a second trade of Touk Miller>NvB(m6) costing me 100k... or do I have sufficient cash cows to pass the NVB train and just bank the money?

I would keep that trade (and 151k) up your sleeve. Your team is really good and you have enough cows IMO.

 

[Krujan]

Getting my hand forced by rumors of Bonty's late out rumor...

Do I cop the donut, or go Lids to a money-earner with the expectation of coming back to a fallen premo in a few weeks? Was content to let Lids on the bench for the extra week, but not if it means a big 0 on the field. My other FWD bench spot is Kane Lambert and no, I can't go Lambert to McGrath, I come up around 4k short.

If I do switch Lids, I'd be looking at either Pavs to make good points and a little money, or McGrath to make big money but lowered points expectation.

I would trade Lids to another forward premo keeper. Buddy if you don't have him.

 

[cardje]

No. I don't like the Grundy selection. Who is your other ruckman?

Didn't see this kept grundy he got 100 and went up 40k Lolz. Did gaz to fyfe though

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Shouldn't have gone Bont. Now i will have burnt a trade and he will be out

****

 

[StoneX]

Ablett to martin or another dpp fwd and swing him forward for lambert

Thanks. You reckon Martin will be a better scorer than Pav or believe his DPP is more beneficial?

Also start cripps over miller imo

Yeah, that's the plan. Miller is just on field to give a false projected score to my opponent

 

[Feerits Elf]

Bonts a possible out leaves me exposed to a potential donut in the forward line.

Had pencilled in Ablett > Fyfe and Goodes > NVB.

Now looking at one of the following to cover a forward donut:

1. Ablett > Gray and Goodes > NVB
2. Ablett > McGrath and Goodes > Fyfe​

If I get Gray, I probably won't get Fyfe until Rd 6-10 and vice versa.

Which is the better combination - Fyfe and McGrath, or Gray and NVB?

... anyone?

 

[Captain Harley]

Get fyfe

... anyone?

 

[Krujan]

... anyone?

I would go with your original plan and cop a doughnut if Bont is a late out than compromise my plans for a McGrath 50 points which is heck all in the context of Rd score and season.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Get fyfe

And get McGrath to cover Bont, or get NVB and hope like hell Bont plays?

 

[rog1995]

Why can't you reverse trades after the round has started even if the players haven't played? Want to reverse my cripps to Bonts trade.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

I don't think there are many cows coming in the next few weeks so I would jump on, particularly since it would only be the second trade of your season as opposed to your fourth.

My concern lies with my net gain in that trade. Will likely make 70-85k out of it over the next month or so. Is it really worth it?

Krakeour, Anderson, WhiteX, Webb, Lamb, Karnezis, Ah Chee, Byrne, Kelly, Schade, McInnes.

Just a couple of rookies to choose from.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Why can't you reverse trades after the round has started even if the players haven't played? Want to reverse my cripps to Bonts trade.

I honestly don't think anyone here can help you with that issue.

 

[Feerits Elf]

I would go with your original plan and cop a doughnut if Bont is a late out than compromise my plans for a McGrath 50 points which is heck all in the context of Rd score and season.

Thanks Gingy, bear in mind it's 50-70 points if McGrath covers, if I go Gray + NVB the Bont cover would be Heeney or Lang (70-90).

Still risk the donut? Is NVB worth it?

 

[Krujan]

Thanks Gingy, bear in mind it's 50-70 points if McGrath covers, if I go Gray + NVB the Bont cover would be Heeney or Lang (70-90).

Still risk the donut? Is NVB worth it?

I wouldn't knock back a cow averaging 94 so far that will make 70k just this week, that's for sure. But mostly, I think getting Fyfe in this week should be the priority for those without him.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Spend 3 trades & get Sloane & Brodie Smith (sloane this week, smith next)

Or

Spend 2 trades & get Wines & Smith (both this week, if smith misses I get Oxley's 98)

 

[Big Fozza]

Thanks. You reckon Martin will be a better scorer than Pav or believe his DPP is more beneficial?

Both. I think martin will be top 6 fwds - not sure about Pav.

 

[TurboBreuster]

Spend 3 trades & get Sloane & Brodie Smith (sloane this week, smith next)

Or

Spend 2 trades & get Wines & Smith (both this week, if smith misses I get Oxley's 98)

If Smith isn't named, is there any way for you to get Wines and Sloane this week? Eg via Saad.

 

[Masha]

Hi all. Newbie.
1. I'm still sitting on Lids. Is there any point whatsoever holding him? Sloane my alternative. Was thinking Bonts but not now with injury concerns.
2. Also thinking of NVB. Who would you get rid of first? Touk Miller or P. Cripps?

Might just do 1. Or 1 and 2.

Haven't traded this season. Neck and neck with my opponent with current team.
Thanks for any advice.

 

[SnappyHappy]

If Smith isn't named, is there any way for you to get Wines and Sloane this week? Eg via Saad.

Nah not enough $ unfortunately,
It has to be Sloane (in 3 trades) or Wines (in 2). I don't really mind if Smith doesn't play because in that case I'll get Oxley's score

 

[TurboBreuster]

Think I made a post last year on how the Bont could be a great pic this year! Surely enough I had him in my team all summer, but took him out at the last minute. Now I have to get him!! but I'm faced with the following Dilemma:

Option 1 (Assume that Bont is a late out):
Trade in 2 of Docherty, Rance or NVB

Option 2 (Assume Bont is playing):
Trade in 1 of Docherty, Rance or NVB & 1 of Bont or J.Lewis (if Bont is a late out)

I wish there could be some confirmation before 1:45 today.