Who do you believe to be the most trustworthy reporter on this mess?

[I am Jack]

Caro has owned this saga.
I didn't even like Caro before this saga, but what a woman!

 

[blackcat]

Caro has owned this saga.
I didn't even like Caro before this saga, but what a woman!

i'd like to see them done gloves and go to Festival Hall before some property developer comes in and razes that s**t

 

[pablo668]

I tend to take everything in this saga with a pinch of salt.

So many things need a good inquiry/clean out after this saga.

The Footy media, The AFL and it's position in footy, the relationship between the two previous, the boys club which has tentacles in all of it.....

It's been disappointing.

 

[blackcat]

I tend to take everything in this saga with a pinch of salt.

So many things need a good inquiry/clean out after this saga.

The Footy media, The AFL and it's position in footy, the relationship between the two previous, the boys club which has tentacles in all of it.....

It's been disappointing.

yeah nah. it should be water off a ducks back. it is not like Abbott having to make decisions that involve the DF.

it is what it is. treat it like i do, have a laff, throw a few grenades, and mock the public commentators and the football operators for the risible explanations and implausible undeniabilities(sic)

 

[gavaniacono]

Caro has owned this saga.
I didn't even like Caro before this saga, but what a woman!

I voted for Mckenzie. However I agree that Wilson has been dogged in the face of the SEN and other boys club criticisms and her response to such criticism is to go harder. She was perhaps the first to identify hirds hypocrisy and she has been swinging for a ko ever since.

 

[compact72]

I picked Caroline, even though the Hird sacking didn't seem to work out for her, she has been by far the most accurate one.

Even when James Hird didn't get sacked, it was clear she knew somebody in the board, however didn't find out the legal reasons in time.

Sam Newman managed to change my thoughts though. Which is to never listen to a word he says anymore, as it was even hard before.

 

[gavaniacono]

I picked Caroline, even though the Hird sacking didn't seem to work out for her, she has been by far the most accurate one.

Even when James Hird didn't get sacked, it was clear she knew somebody in the board, however didn't find out the legal reasons in time.

Sam Newman managed to change my thoughts though. Which is to never listen to a word he says anymore, as it was even hard before.

I assumed the inclusion of tim Watson and Sam Newman was lighthearted jesting by the survey poster. Caused me some hearty chuckles anyway.

 

[piesaregreat]

Tim Watson and Sam Newman were the comic relief in this Kent Brockman is a far more realistic journalist than either

 

[Ophiomorpha]

yeah nah. it should be water off a ducks back. it is not like Abbott having to make decisions that involve the DF.

it is what it is. trate it like i do, have a laff, throw a few grenades, and mock the public commentators and the football operators for the risible explanations and implausible undeniabilities(sic)

That, and a bit of Hardie trolling, is pretty much my whole schtick.

 

[SunshineBoy]

Thread needs more FogDog

 

[Halloween Jack]

As with any issue, the reporter who agrees with my opinion is the most trustworthy.

 

[Cunctipotent]

Francis Leach

 

[blackcat]

Francis Leach

evo 's good m8.

 

[ziad]

one good thing to come out of this saga is that it has truly exposed the footy journalists for what most are

 

[blackcat]

one good thing to come out of this saga is that it has truly exposed the footy journalists for what most are

fans, groupies who dont have to be fluffers

 

[Howard Moon]

depends which side they were getting leaks from.

Gerard Whatley for mine is the only scribe with a modicum of class amongst the lot of them, i respect him and he has got lots right. He rarley uses hyperbole, just goes with what he believes to be facts.

Robbo is the only one who i can still feel passion in his voice, like hes still a fan in the outer - but he DID name names.... so the jounro insitinct has taken over.

Whatley for me.

 

[evo]

evo 's good m8.

I prolly should give him back his lunch money.

 

[Nikita Blue]

Where is Luke Darcy??

 

[Stumpy Pete]

As much as his pomposity irks me I think Patrick Smith has been pretty good on this issue. I think he has been appropriately critical off all parties when warranted but has also been pretty clear that the fact that these athletes compete in a much loved sporting code should mean absolutely nothing when it comes to this matter.

Regards

S. Pete

 

[B0SK]

If this were a Bay13 poll I'd probably have my nose in front.

...of Jack Watts

 

[BigJoeD_]

If this were a Bay13 poll I'd probably have my nose in front.

You know this isn't Flog of the Year voting, right?

 

[QuietB]

There's a Grant Baker that has been writing on it too. Don't get confused which is which!

Baker and MacKenzie started strong but have done not much since.

I wish Baker & McKenzie would publish the stuff they have held back

 

[QuietB]

As much as his pomposity irks me I think Patrick Smith has been pretty good on this issue. I think he has been appropriately critical off all parties when warranted but has also been pretty clear that the fact that these athletes compete in a much loved sporting code should mean absolutely nothing when it comes to this matter.

Regards

S. Pete

I was going to say Smith as well - he has been pretty balanced. Maybe he cannot bring himself to burn Essendon being another (ex) supporter.

 

[pazza]

Le Grand has been the most accurate and with no agenda.

Caro has made mistake after mistake. Be very easy to list those mistakes and her agenda alongside of them.

 

[jenny61_99]

Le Grand has been the most accurate and with no agenda.

Caro has made mistake after mistake. Be very easy to list those mistakes and her agenda alongside of them.

LMAO. So funny seeing comments like this.