Who is more cooked, Joel Selwood or Jack Gunston?

[Socrates2]

Ha ha! Selwood kicked Cotchin's arse in the prelim. Cotchin should have retired 3 years ago. What a loser.

Cotchin was coming back from injury and Selwood is a perennial finals loser.

 

[Danger2Jenkins]

Jack Gunston was rated #4 among key forwards in AFL Player Ratings this season.

and Tom Hawkins wins

 

[Danger2Jenkins]

Cotchin was coming back from injury and Selwood is a perennial finals loser.

Lol nice anti logic! Selwood has won more AFL Grand Finals than Richmond ever will

 

[craffles]

Thread has Confirmed selwood is so cooked he can’t get a touch and Gunston is so cooked Clarkson needs to throw him a back to find the footy.

shaping up for a dead heat here

 

[RegHickeyStand]

Cotchin was coming back from injury and Selwood is a perennial finals loser.

If you take the field, no excuses. Cotchin is a sniping faux tough guy.

 

[WillemDaDrew]

Disappointing no poll.
Where's the Tex Walker option?

 

[Socrates2]

If you take the field, no excuses. Cotchin is a sniping faux tough guy.

Sniping? He would be the fairest player in the league.I don't how we keep winning flags with Cotchin, Lynch and Rance apparantly no good.Cotchin is a duel premiership captain and brownlow medalist.

 

[Bigeasy]

Disappointing no poll.
Where's the Tex Walker option?

And the Charlie Dixon one too

 

[RegHickeyStand]

Sniping? He would be the fairest player in the league.I don't how we keep winning flags with Cotchin, Lynch and Rance apparantly no good.Cotchin is a duel premiership captain and brownlow medalist.

You must have a great team to have won the 2019 GF with that dud Cotchin. Landed a gun in Lynch. also. Big admirer of Reiwoldt. But really, its Caddy. Since he has been in your team, you have improved leaps and bounds. You need those guns to carry a Cotchin weighed down team. Dion Prestia was critical too.

Imagine if we played a bit better, Lynch goes down in the second, got the rub of the green in the second half and beat you guys by a point. How would Cotchin playing have looked then?

 

[leobarryustar]

That'd be because he's spending as much time in defense as attack these days. No I don't know why either, ask Clarko.

Probably because he spends half his time in defence. Because we didnt have a 2nd tall defender.

Cool story guys, but nah. He was 34% defensive half, 66% offensive. You would expect a key forward to spend 20% in the defensive half anyway.

Scoring accuracy of 46% is really very concerning.

 

[HairyO]

Cool story guys, but nah. He was 34% defensive half, 66% offensive. You would expect a key forward to spend 20% in the defensive half anyway.

Scoring accuracy of 46% is really very concerning.

Id be concerned about a team that saw Joe Daniher as the saving grace, who then failed to get him.

Id put money on Hawkins being less than 5% defensive, so too Kennedy.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

The answer to the OP is definitely Aaron Sandilands.

 

[A Cut Above]

Cool story guys, but nah. He was 34% defensive half, 66% offensive. You would expect a key forward to spend 20% in the defensive half anyway.

Scoring accuracy of 46% is really very concerning.

All I know's Gunston is less cooked than Buddy "Enjoy paying him $1.4m this year & $1.5m next year" Franklin.

 

[beema limapep]

Lol nice anti logic! Selwood has won more AFL Grand Finals than Richmond ever will

Not quite.

But to be fair to Selwood, how many have they captained to a flag?

Selwood - 8 years as captain, 0 flags.
Cotchin - 7 years as captain, 2 flags.

Cotchin is a team player with a positive mindset and the glue that keeps Richmond bonded.
Selwood is an individual with a negative mindset, that (by gosh what a cooincidence) cant bring his players along with him.

 

[Danger2Jenkins]

Not quite.

But to be fair to Selwood, how many have they captained to a flag?

Selwood - 8 years as captain, 0 flags.
Cotchin - 7 years as captain, 2 flags.

Cotchin is a team player with a positive mindset and the glue that keeps Richmond bonded.
Selwood is an individual with a negative mindset, that (by gosh what a cooincidence) cant bring his players along with him.

Hmmm interesting take! But 3>2

 

[WillemDaDrew]

And the Charlie Dixon one too

Ben Jacobs board friend..

 

[Bigeasy]

Ben Jacobs board friend..

Jack Watts, Ollie Wines, Tom Rocklif, Stephen Motlop board friend

 

[WillemDaDrew]

Jack Watts, Ollie Wines, Tom Rocklif, Stephen Motlop board friend

Good to see you're acknowledging our player list.
Apart from Jacobs, Polec and Pittard I can't think of any more relevant on yours.

 

[TallyHawk]

How to get hits on a Bay thread:
1. Mention Geelong
2. Mention Hawthorn

Yet you somehow managed to fu** it up and hardly get any nibbles.

Gunston will kick 40 or 50 goals next year now we have a 2nd tall defender.

Selwood is a good choice for a Geelong player. Maybe Smith was a better choice for Hawthorn.

There is more to it than that, old mate craffles still melting over Ray telling Jack not to go to the injectors.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[leobarryustar]

Id be concerned about a team that saw Joe Daniher as the saving grace, who then failed to get him.

Id put money on Hawkins being less than 5% defensive, so too Kennedy.

17% & 18%

Would you have given a gun player plus two first rounders or whatever dodo wanted when you could get him for nothing next year? But you’re right, I thought we would have learned our lesson with Tippo

All I know's Gunston is less cooked than Buddy "Enjoy paying him $1.4m this year & $1.5m next year" Franklin.

When you knob off to Buddy in red and white, do you feel a bit hollow inside? Or have you not tried it yet?

 

[HairyO]

17% & 18%

Would you have given a gun player plus two first rounders or whatever dodo wanted when you could get him for nothing next year? But you’re right, I thought we would have learned our lesson with Tippo



When you knob off to Buddy in red and white, do you feel a bit hollow inside? Or have you not tried it yet?

He left for money. We kept winning flags.

If we matched we'd be in the toilet like Sydney.

 

[craffles]

Disappointing no poll.
Where's the Tex Walker option?

poll added

 

[HairyO]

There is more to it than that, old mate craffles still melting over Ray telling Jack not to go to the injectors.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

His Dad did have inside knowledge on how terribly mismanaged the Dons were.

Smart boy Jack, listening to Dad.

Got the $$$ and the Flags.

 

[leobarryustar]

He left for money. We kept winning flags.

If we matched we'd be in the toilet like Sydney.

Yeah cos your outlook is so rosy

 

[Xtreme]

Neroli Meadows is more cooked rhan both. That's why Fox Footy turfed her out.