Analysis Inexperience watch

[T Rick]

Surely 7 players with less than 25 games experience must be close to a tipping point for us.

 

[M Malice]

Surely 7 players with less than 25 games experience must be close to a tipping point for us.

Levi Ashcroft, Bruce Reville, Sam Marshall, Luke Beecken, Ty Gallop, James Tunstill, Darragh Joyce.

Joyce and Tunstill unlikely to play, Reville and Beecken are older in years, LAshcroft is elite for his age, Marshall looks to be holding his own, Gallop is the question, I'm bullish he will give a good account of himself.

 

[Jivlain]

Final squads:

	Brisbane	Hawthorn
(0 to 10 games)	2	0
0 to 24 games	5	1
25 to 49 games	2	1
50 to 99 games	4	8
100 to 199 games	7	10
200+ games	5	3
Games played	119.87	128.78
Age	26.00	26.74
Height	187.43	187.83
Finals played	8.48	4.61

Interactive version

Five in our final 0-24 category, and all five (Gallop, Marshall, Jimmy, Bruuuuuuce and Levi) are less experienced than Hawthorn's least experienced in Dear (who will be leaving that group after this game). Play the yuuf!

 

[Dalions]

Final squads:
View attachment 2403551

	Brisbane	Hawthorn
(0 to 10 games)	2	0
0 to 24 games	5	1
25 to 49 games	2	1
50 to 99 games	4	8
100 to 199 games	7	10
200+ games	5	3
Games played	119.87	128.78
Age	26.00	26.74
Height	187.43	187.83
Finals played	8.48	4.61

Interactive version

Five in our final 0-24 category, and all five (Gallop, Marshall, Jimmy, Bruuuuuuce and Levi) are less experienced than Hawthorn's least experienced in Dear (who will be leaving that group after this game). Play the yuuf!

Season kinda hinges on this game to an extent.
And seeing this doesn’t ease my nerves.
Unbelievably important game tonight and our Gabba form doesn’t fill me with confidence either.

 

[shayno]

If you take out the subs on either team then I think we are slightly more experienced than them.

 

[Jivlain]

	Geelong	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	0	2
0 to 24 games	2	3
25 to 49 games	4	2
50 to 99 games	3	4
100 to 199 games	11	8
200+ games	3	6
Games played	127.04	139.96
Age	27.05	26.61
Height	188.00	187.35
Finals played	8.39	10.17

Interactive version

 

[Viceregal]

Younger than Geelong ... all is right with the world!

 

[Jivlain]

	Brisbane	Gold Coast
(0 to 10 games)	2	0
0 to 24 games	4	1
25 to 49 games	1	3
50 to 99 games	5	5
100 to 199 games	8	10
200+ games	5	4
Games played	128.91	116.35
Age	26.21	26.37
Height	188.00	188.35
Finals played	10.70	1.91

Interactive version

 

[Nathan Barley]

Gold Coast are old

 

[Elixuh]

Crazy how young we are given the Zorko outlier at the top.

 

[Jivlain]

	Collingwood	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	1	2
0 to 24 games	1	3
25 to 49 games	1	2
50 to 99 games	3	5
100 to 199 games	11	8
200+ games	7	5
Games played	171.57	129.91
Age	29.35	26.23
Height	189.35	188.00
Finals played	10.78	11.70

Interactive version

40 games and 3 years less experience. Retro mode inexperience watch.

 

[T Rick]

View attachment 2429903

	Collingwood	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	1	2
0 to 24 games	1	3
25 to 49 games	1	2
50 to 99 games	3	5
100 to 199 games	11	8
200+ games	7	5
Games played	171.57	129.91
Age	29.35	26.23
Height	189.35	188.00
Finals played	10.78	11.70

Interactive version

40 games and 3 years less experience. Retro mode inexperience watch.

Thanks Jivlain - always look forward to your work each week...hopefully, one more week!

 

[M Malice]

Wow! You would have to think 2025 is the last throw of the dice at a Premiership for a lot of this Magpies best 23.

 

[Elixuh]

What’s the highest avg games we have seen? Cats 2022 was around 180ish? I can’t recall.

 

[KissKiss]

What’s the highest avg games we have seen? Cats 2022 was around 180ish? I can’t recall.

Was wondering the same. 170 is insanely experienced.

9 players over 30 and only 2 players with less than 50 games!

 

[Section 5]

We have 10 players under 100 games to the Pies 5

I like our 10. Below in order of games played.

Lions:
Wilmot (81), Fletcher, Will Ashcroft, Fort, Lohmann, Morris, Levi Ashcroft, Marshall, Reville & Gallop (4).
The first six have won a premiership.

Pies:
McCreery (95), N Daicos, Frampton, Long, Steel (4)

 

[M Malice]

We have 10 players under 100 games to the Pies 5

I like our 10. Below in order of games played.

Lions:
Wilmot (81), Fletcher, Will Ashcroft, Fort, Lohmann, Morris, Levi Ashcroft, Marshall & Reville (4).
The first six have won a premiership.

Pies:
McCreery (95), N Daicos, Frampton, Long, Steel (4)

+ Ty Gallop.

 

[Section 5]

+ Ty Gallop.

Yes, he is the 4 games

Getting old can't transfer my written names to the screen.
Not to mention counting to 10 to make sure i included all players

 

[Nathan Barley]

Surely the finals played counts for more than the overall games played

 

[Section 5]

Surely the finals played counts for more than the overall games played

I don't think anything counts other than what is produced on the day.

 

[Nathan Barley]

I don't think anything counts other than what is produced on the day.

Yes nothing that contributes to how they produce on the day counts for anything than what they produce on the day

 

[Section 5]

Yes nothing that contributes to how they produce on the day counts for anything than what they produce on the day

Yes, we are very good when we are on, but not so when things like pressure are 5% off
I am as confident in this game as any other this season.

 

[Jivlain]

What’s the highest avg games we have seen? Cats 2022 was around 180ish? I can’t recall.

Most experienced teams to take the field since 1990:

1. Collingwood @ Hawthorn, 2025 r22 (185.78)
2. Collingwood vs Melbourne, 2025 r24 (172.26)
3. Collingwood tomorrow
4. Collingwood @ Gold Coast, 2025 r18 (170.26)
5. Collingwood vs us, 2025 r21 (170.22)
6. Us vs North, 2004 r22 (169)
7. Us vs Saints, 2004 r21 (168)
8. Geelong vs Sydney, 2022 GF (166.26)
9. Hawthorn @ West Coast, 2015 GF (165.82)
10. Us vs Port, 2004 GF (165.41)
11. Us vs Geelong, 2004 PF (165.14)

Geelong 2022 was generally running at around 150-160 games experience.

 

[Jivlain]

Grand final squads:

	Geelong	Brisbane
(0 to 10 games)	0	2
0 to 24 games	0	3
25 to 49 games	6	2
50 to 99 games	2	5
100 to 199 games	11	7
200+ games	4	6
Games played	130.65	135.65
Age	27.21	26.45
Height	188.43	187.39
Finals played	10.43	12.91

Interactive version

 

[Viceregal]

Fairly even as you would expect from a GF ... you would hope that the 3 <25 (and 2 <10) blokes would be quality and love pressure (fortunately for us they do!!!!)