StCicatriz
Hall of Famer
- Joined
- Aug 3, 2016
- Posts
- 30,456
- Reaction score
- 68,121
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Why do you think Pyke is no good? Just curious if you think that because of the Crow’s camp? He had nothing to do with them going to that camp. Wasn’t his call in any way. And he was questioning it whilst they were there.
he's the senior coach. its ultimately his decision and if he wasn't comfortable with the camp going ahead there are ways you can mitigate damage for example facilitating the transfer of personal information from the playing group to a third party if you DO have concerns is not good.
but his time at west coast has already gone off in a similar hap-hazard manner. for example he took off mid season. he was heavily involved in some questionnable trades and contract negotiations. something he shouldn't be involved in at all. the pick split trade was a disaster IMO
the appointment of Mini wasn't strategically sound IMO they've taken an inexperienced senior coach and haven't put enough support around him, especially once you consider how bad that list was and has continued to get under the list manager he appointed. that's the one responsible for the banfield debacle.
community football wise. west coast have gone backwards massively. they contribute less which ends up just hurting their ability to draft locally. there's a disconnect between the club and community now, which previously was not there.
dont get me started on the philosophy of trading away the limited experience they did have.





been brought up
