Remove this Banner Ad

QAFL 2026

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

smy1305 said:
nah disagree - Collings best years were in the tweenies, who knows how good Doolan or Quinn are as they haven't ventured outside this level of footy (not a criticism at all). No doubt they would be good but when this comp was super competitive with Noosa and Maroochydore in it they were seen as very good players, not extraordinary as they now are 10 years later! I think it's more a reflection on the standard of div 1 vs when Mayne was playing against Noosa, Maroochy, (a strong) Springwood.

I watched the magpies last week for a while - stayed with Maroochy for a half but don't have the cattle to sustain for a full game. They aren't a basket case
Click to expand...
agree,, must say the difference in standard is a big jump even with the last 2 or 3 clubs at the end of the ladder in the main comp ..
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Sorry, I’m late to the party with tips. I thought they went through last night - obviously not.

My Tips:
Broadbeach
Morningside
Redland
Palm Beach
Wilston Grange
 
watched Broadbeach and Labrador play another thriller ....was a good standard game and note the Cats had their best 2 players absent be it Erickson and Gilmore....some good youngsters in the Cats side and the coach is doing a very good job with this list.
 
Tipping comp;
Up it stumpy and 2010 Premier pick the card with the latter now the comp leader .....Unspoken brizz had 5 out of 5 missing his tip for the Surfers vs Noosa game .

37; 2010 Premier

36; Footyboy, Unspoken brizz, Longy zillmere

35; Up it stumpy, Westerman, Windsor Zillmere, Pugs,

34; North street, Stuyd, Toucan soup, Bud 63

33; Thunderdoc, Big E, Noosa boy

31; Goalkicker, Carl Boops,

30; Bunyip, Lagging behind

28; SMY

27; Mobbs, Magpie boy

26; No Bee

22; Tedlasso
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Still Me said:
Wouldn’t have thought Fletcher Clare in best 50 players in competition so let’s settle down a bit. Whilst it’s good Vultures have a few good kids that look solid QAFL players the key will be keeping them interested whilst trying to be competitive so they see a long term plan for remaining at the club.
Click to expand...
Just had a 40 disposal game against grange mate, so forget top 50 this kid is a top 15 player in the QAFL right now
 
DaicosKing said:
Just had a 40 disposal game against grange mate, so forget top 50 this kid is a top 15 player in the QAFL right now
Click to expand...
Performing against Grange midfield is massive achievement. Let’s do it consistently against the better sides then you might get him into top 50. I reckon I can name 15 quite easily ahead of him in varying positions. Not all just about disposal numbers?
 
Still Me said:
Performing against Grange midfield is massive achievement. Let’s do it consistently against the better sides then you might get him into top 50. I reckon I can name 15 quite easily ahead of him in varying positions. Not all just about disposal numbers?
Click to expand...
Would think #2 in comp for inside 50s, #6 for disposals, and #5 for clearances would make a top 50 player in the comp lol. Not sure what planet you're on
 
Carltonboppers said:
Would think #2 in comp for inside 50s, #6 for disposals, and #5 for clearances would make a top 50 player in the comp lol. Not sure what planet you're on
Click to expand...
Archie Robert’s is leading disposals in AFL and top few for metres gained so does that make him a top 15 player in competition?

I assure you disposals aren’t even a guage within 4 walls of most decent sides. Inside 50’s aren’t really a highlight either as depends where and how they coming in and we are talking about one of the lowest scoring teams in competition so not sure they would be deep quality entries.

Sometimes it’s not just about statistics. We all entitled to opinions and you obviously rate him which is good for the young fella. But I think there is probably 3-4 better players from each side in top 8 ahead of him at present.

That may change by season’s end and players get a year older next year and he may come up the rankings, but right now not sure he is a top 15 player in competition. But you entitled to your opinion as am I and we just differ.
 
Still Me said:
Archie Robert’s is leading disposals in AFL and top few for metres gained so does that make him a top 15 player in competition?

I assure you disposals aren’t even a guage within 4 walls of most decent sides. Inside 50’s aren’t really a highlight either as depends where and how they coming in and we are talking about one of the lowest scoring teams in competition so not sure they would be deep quality entries.

Sometimes it’s not just about statistics. We all entitled to opinions and you obviously rate him which is good for the young fella. But I think there is probably 3-4 better players from each side in top 8 ahead of him at present.

That may change by season’s end and players get a year older next year and he may come up the rankings, but right now not sure he is a top 15 player in competition. But you entitled to your opinion as am I and we just differ.
Click to expand...
Hey mate, you said he wasn't a top 50 player, not 15.
 
Fletcher Clare is a fine player. Carltonbopper and the Mt Gravatt supporters on here you’ll all have him in your selected combined team, Still Me, who knows a little about recruitment, I dare say wouldn’t. Each to their own.

Are there state selections this year?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Jones, Casboult, Simpson, Rolls, Horne, McDonagh, Dawson, Hammelman, Sexton, Gaul, Foon, Fyfe, Martin, Bastinac, Woodburn, Fletcher, Wilson

thats 17 pretty good players and I'm sure I have forgotten plenty who should be in that group!
 
Miller1971 said:
Jones, Casboult, Simpson, Rolls, Horne, McDonagh, Dawson, Hammelman, Sexton, Gaul, Foon, Fyfe, Martin, Bastinac, Woodburn, Fletcher, Wilson

thats 17 pretty good players and I'm sure I have forgotten plenty who should be in that group!
Click to expand...
I’ll add you another 14: Buzza, Swallow, Miller, Jellyman-Turner, Jayden Young, Malone, Erickson, the other Dawson (Palmy or Morningside), Cameron-Reeves, Hickey, O’Sullivan, Castle, Delbridge, Doran.
 
offsider12 said:
Anyone want to have a crack at their top 15 players in the QAFL?
Click to expand...
TOP 15 PLAYERS IN THE QAFL
NOT INCLUDING VFL LISTED PLAYERS. e.g. Liam Jones, Alex Sexton, Brock Aston, David Swallow.
Genuine QAFL players only:

1. Matthew Hammelman (Redlands)
2. Tom Simpson (Palm Beach)
3. Liam Dawson (Morningside)
4. Jack Rolls (Morningside)
5. Campbell Aston (Redlands)
6. Benjamin Woodburn (Surface)
7. Garret Mcdonough (Morningside)
8. Craig Malone (Redlands)
9. Aiden Fyfe (Labrador)
10. Levi Casboult (Palm Beach)
11. Aaron Wilson (Maroochydore)
12. Tristan Hobbley (Morningside)
13. Kai Purslow (Morningside)
14. Matt Doran (Surface)
15. AJ Dawson (Palm Beach)

Representation:
Morningside: 5
Redlands: 3
Palm Beach: 3
Surface: 2
Labrador: 1
Maroochydore: 1



HM: Cam Lovig (Morningside), Jack Manly (Wilston Grange), Fletcher Clare (Mt Gravatt), Owen Collins (Sherwood), Sam Tilley (Noosa), Wylie Buzza (Morningside)

I understand this isn't a true representation of the quality of the comp as VFL players regularly play:

VFL Players who would be in top 15-20:
David Swallow (Suns VFL)
Alex Sexton (Suns VFL)
Hugh Greenwood (Suns VFL)
Luke Coombes (Southport VFL)
Brock Aston (Southport VFL)
Justin Krok (Southport VFL)
Liam Jones (Brisbane VFL)
Charlton Offermans (Brisbane VFL)
Tahj Abberley (Brisbane VFL)

Other Noticeable Absences:
Will Fletcher (Playing in Tasmania)

Keen to hear thoughts.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom