Search results for query: *

Such good news for JR , your club but also the the AFL.. If he gets back and plays great but even if he doesn't ..just overcoming what he has make him such a good news story ... fronting the media and making the 10 minute check comment makes he such a positive example for so many people. He...

Had to come in to post on what the Hawks and the Pies did last night. This whole issue go's past any inter club rivalries. The "Circle of Reverence" that the Hawks and the Pies did to honour Phil Walsh , showed why both clubs are leaders in the AFL. True moments of worth are not scripted and...

Hawkas1988 , you have posted on our board so I hope you don't mind. I doubt all Hawk supporters or all Geelong supporter as the same , so as to being content.... Im not sure any true footballer , coach or supporter stays content for to long. Win two flags in a row are Haw content. The most...

Not sure on the working harder thing. He was played quite early compared to several kids of ours, we usually have a long leadup time for new kids for eg. last year Lang our R1 has played a 1/2 of AFL footy this year , the R2 and R3 have not played. If anything id say he need to build his body up...

I have no idea if my pov is “realistic” to your "hawks" perspective , probably isn’t , but I'll try.... Seen a few posts mention Geelong players Menzel, Thurlow. Id say Menzel would almost be untradeable , we have stuck by him so long now and I can’t see it changing. His worth would be almost...

WWSD , on foreign turf here so I will proceed with caution and comment only if you want? I see some Geelong names mentioned as possible trades , I know you have contributed on our board a bit but your turf here so up to you Hawk guys.

Interesting you say that , I was just coming over to ask what you guys think he is worth? The market seems to be getting a little over the top if Frawley is on much more than 500 in my eyes. Bloody Syd have hyped the market I reckon. 10M SC , forwards and mids should be getting just as much as...

Just dropped in to wish him all the best. I love his testy attitude , about how he is always adding to our rivalry by dropping the odd remark about Cats or Geelong. Its all good for the theatre of footy. So hope he recovers quickly and returns to the coaches seat to be the one so many love to...

Well done today , totally the best team on the day and did it when it counts. Congrats on another Flag guys

As with a lot of umpire decisions , its different live than on the replay. Every one paid was technically there , so really its just rub of the green. With any players whether its SJ , Buddy or whoever that are match smart , they will try to accentuate contact and draw a free kick. No prob with...

In the end both club are pro's and neither were going to be pushed around. As you say both would have it in the back of them minds what will happen if he doesn't get games. 24 Months ago Laidler was the same , got an offer from Carlt and it didn't take but then 12 months later when out of...

Well , we will only know that for sure if it goes down wont we. You trade someone for a late 20's pick and lets see what happens. If we are just mouthing platitudes , Id think the min. would be a pick earlier than 26. I really don't see why he would be less than Gunston and you have shown what...

Look at what you paid for Gunston and that would be a start but really Geelong will probably not trade to anyone short of an "offer we can't refuse" something like a single figure pick. I acknowledge he probably is not worth that but thats what it would take imo. so 99% sure no deal will happen...

Back at you. Who was the last we got of you , David Loats? Not interested in any suspect , injury ridden players no matter the potential. I really don't see how this deal gets done unless you can trade someone to GWS , they have all the picks.

Ahh , no. You have set what a potential player is worth. He was not contracted. Gillies is and unless the deal is right , he will not be going anywhere. 33 & 51 is just to late. You have apparently offered him 300G a year , has to be R1.

Lot of factors here. One is Gillies has been groomed to take over form Scarlett/Milburn etc. Drafted in 2008 Geelong always seem to look long term. For eg Lonergan was 2002 and only the last couple of years has he really secured his spot. Guys like Laidler have shown that just because you...

As far we know Gillies is contracted so : what do you think he is worth , what do you think you will offer to make a deal happen?

Same old, same old. One team only wants to give what the others will not accept. I cant see how any deal for Mackie could get done without involving GC , they have all the picks. Mackie may even want to move but he will not be going anywhere unless we get heavy comp.

Well played , you guys were up and we were less than sharp. Impressed by your tackling and the breaking of our tackles , and the midfield dominance was impressive. To me you will be a very tough team come 08 , with all the talent you have down stream.

Do you guys ever listen to Dermie on SEN? .The way he is talking if you get P1 & P2 , my bet is you will go Deludio and Griffen He is very hot on having a quality midfield. There has been references to Geelong. Right or wrong , if you look at Geelongs drafting post 98 they have gone no...

If you guys are going to get P1 and P2 , would you consider trading the #1 pick for a super deal say 3 player that were basically 1st round draft picks (P20 or better). A team like Fremantle, who you dont mind trading with, has 3 ex Vic players guys like Dunn, Murphy, Mundy. Now before you say...