Search results for query: *

Talia is the better pure defender. Carlisle is the better and more flexible footballer.

And yet Tredrea is the one with double the All Australians than "the next Carey"

He probably enjoys playing against us more than any other club. 37 disposals and 3 goals

I think its hard to compare. Would Lockett and Dunstall have kicked 1000 goals in an era with heavy defense ranging from floods to tempo footy to zoning to clusters to 16 opponents inside the forward 50? I wouldnt have thought so. Its hard to compare modern day defensive minded footy to an...

It is rubbish. You think the game didnt change from 87-94 when Sticks was at his peak through to 01-06 when Tredrea was at his? Utter garbage. Im not sure its even debateable that the game hasnt changed. The invent of the flood, tempo football, zoning. In Kernahans career there were 18x...

I dunno, but being best on ground in at least 3 finals suggests he at least dominated some finals. I think Tredrea and Kernahan were pretty even. Very very similar footballers, similar strengths. I think Kernahan gets the nod for his longevity and I think Kernahan often gets overlooked...

Got to see Jurrahs mark live. Just about the best mark ive seen live before, up there with Modras against North Melbourne and a mark by David Hynes in an SANFL game. Goddards was bloody good as well. Cant split them for me.

Well, no, not really. Tredrea was at his best right throughout the peak of 'flooding'. But I will give you credit....you do work hard to completely undermine and push a negative towards anything Port Adelaide. Im sure someone appreciates the hard work you put in.

Yeah, 2005 was the year where Tredrea kicked more goals, took 50 more marks, had more disposals, more tackles, more goal assists, more marks inside 50 and a better disposal efficiency than Pavlich wasnt it? "lost on the wings".....love it! As for the OP....Darren Bradshaw wins hands down.

Gray will go through his career very much underrated...much like Roger James was. Hes that sort of player. The things he does so well (inside ability, clearance ability) are things that often get overlooked. Whereas Otten sat on the back flank picking up handball recieves every week, which is...

Given that C Bolton couldnt get in the top 10 of his clubs BnF, ill say him. Goodwin will finish in the top 3-4 of Adelaides.

A good solid footballer who will probably win AA later on in his career if he can improve another 20-30%. I understand what people are saying in the not a lot of improvement left call, but I dont think its entirely true. When Chad Cornes was a good contested marking half forward, who would...

Both very good 2nd tier AFL forwards. Fairly hard to split. Sav was a touch one dimensional (but he played in one dimensional times) and Lucas has more agility. Id say Sav but not by much...I think Savs best was just better than Lucas' best.

Luke Molan definitely

I cant believe you are comparing a one season wonder like Woewodin to a player that was AA in 4 consecutive seasons in the hardest spot on the ground. Are you Richmond supporters that insular that you think Tredrea only had one good season? And that Richo has had 14 equal seasons to Tredreas...

How often do CHFs win games off their own boot? Do you only count goals? Do you include marks and contested marks as well? Much harder for a CHF to win a game off his own boot compared to a previous era FF who rarely went further than 30m from goal. Apples with Apples indeed. From 99-04...

This year Essendon. Next year Adelaide.

And what the hell has that got to do with this thread?

Carlile has had the better year.

I think in terms of the draft era (Gaz was before that), Rodan might be considered one of the best, considering Port got him with the last pick of the 06 draft. He isnt elite, but hes turned into a top class midfielder with great clearance ability and goal sense. Considering the last...

Westhoff is easily better now. Tippett has the potential to be better than Westhoff but hes still got a long way to go before he becomes a consistent AFL player.

Yeah didnt come down to Adelaide this weekend. Was spewing I missed a Port Norwood game.

Odd thread.

Toby isnt our regular full back. The fact you completely dismiss Carlile, who statistically would be right up with the best full backs this year kills your argument. Ill give you one ruck, tredrea and cornes, but P Burgs has already been replaced both in the midfield and in defence.

Stop feeding the troll.

If you look at the whole trade and not just two players out of a big trade, Port clearly won. Bulldogs paid too much to get their man. Eagleton had some terrible years early on at the Bulldogs and he has become a very good midfielder over the last three years or so, but he definately didnt...

Arnie all the way. 20 odd years and hes still p**sing people off!!

Gotta say Pavlich for mine. Can play very well anywhere on the park. Probably the most versatile player in the league. Riewoldt is excellent, but just not as good as Pav is at this point. Riewoldt is more the classic style of tall player. Pavlich is more the dynamic style of tall player...

Dont go accusing the Eagles moderator then. Equal chance (this is if anybody has rigged the poll) that you would of played around with it just as much as GoEagles might have. As for who is better. I voted Haselby but its very close. What does Kerr have over Haselby?? Not much What does...

Wheres my name?? Sabre would have a field day!!!!