Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. Papa G

    Which 00s key forward would you build a modern team around?

    Tredrea is so criminally under rated. AA CHF 01,02,03,04 and should have been 05 but they went with Pavlich for something different.
  2. Papa G

    Do you enjoy AFLW

    It isnt even close to top end under 15 boys. A decent College under 15s team would beat most AFLW sides by 20 goals. Developed 15 year olds can be 6 foot tall. Skill levels, speed, stamina and strength are all above that of even the best females. Erin Phillips, easily the best player of all...
  3. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Sicily deserved it more than the bloke that took his position, Tom Stewart.
  4. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Every player in the top 11 of the coaches award made the All Australian Team.
  5. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Actually think the umps are probably the least biased of anybody. Sure they favour midfielders, but in terms of team biases, they are probably the least likely as they must do a 3,2,1 for every game regardless if it is an exclusive all Victorian Friday night "Blockbuster" or Sunday twilight on...
  6. Papa G

    Which side is closer to a premiership - Adelaide or Port Adelaide?

    Butters and Rozee are better than any "young" mid the Crows have. I just don't see who you would be referring to? Soligo? McHenry? Hately? None of those guys are even in the same postcode.
  7. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    It would be really great to see Touk Miller win the Brownlow.
  8. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    In terms of who'd get laid... Rozee, then Brayshaw then..... Walsh would be at home playing with his train set.
  9. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    The Crows managed to get the 3 worst first rounders from the 2018 super draft, that takes some sort of talent.
  10. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Rozee had 2 votes in the first 5 rounds. Hence my argument his last 10 games (yes 12) technically) have been outstanding. Rozees best is better than the other 2. The other 2 have been far more consistent so far.
  11. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Agree. Rozee played forward for 3 year (the second 2 injured). Walsh was an in and under mid from day 1, Brayshaw has been that for the last 3 years. Now they are all playing proper midfield they can all be compared properly. Both Brayshaw and Walsh have a better body of work Rozees last...
  12. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Rozzee kicked 29 goals in his first year. Walsh has kicked 31 in 4 years.
  13. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    Brayshaw is a year older but I'll compare and rank the 4 seasons they've played together 2019 Walsh/Rozee Brayshaw 2020 Walsh Brayshaw Rozee 2021 Walsh/Brayshaw Rozee 2022 Brayshaw/Rozee Walsh
  14. Papa G

    Moved Thread Brayshaw vs Walsh vs Rozee

    84 Clayton Oliver MELB 75 Christian Petracca MELB 72 Andrew Brayshaw FRE 72 Touk Miller GCFC 70 Lachie Neale BL 68 Connor Rozee PORT 67 Jeremy Cameron GEEL 65 Patrick Cripps CARL 55 Callum Mills SYD 53 Hugh McCluggage BL 48 James Sicily HAW 48 Sam Walsh CARL 48 Chad...
  15. Papa G

    Sam Walsh vs Connor Rozee

    It's almost like Rozee was playing injured for 2 years......
  16. Papa G

    Year the competition truly went national

    When we stop counting VFL flags.
  17. Papa G

    Boak v Dangerfield

    Better bloke? Travis Boak.
  18. Papa G

    Moved Thread Lethal or Ablett sr

    Carey. For football ability and Bad Bloke rating.
  19. Papa G

    Which club is the biggest club in the AFL right now

    West Coast get 50,000 plus of their own supporters to their home games just about every week. No Victorian side can say that.
  20. Papa G

    Which club is the biggest club in the AFL right now

    Outside of the media which is run out of Melbourne, you could argue that West Coast is bigger in every other area.
  21. Papa G

    Which club is the biggest club in the AFL right now

    Clubs that heavily rely on Pokie on Fitness venues for their income streams, particularly in Victoria will also be the worst effected. West Coast, financially will be enormously in front of everybody this year you'd think.
  22. Papa G

    Which club is the biggest club in the AFL right now

    I've heard the theory that is the Big Melbourne Clubs that have been the most adversely effected by the Covid Crisis. These big Vic Clubs get huge revenues from the AFL Endorsed and Promoted Spankbusters at the MCG where they get significant financial up lift from the Gate. These have not...
  23. Papa G

    Who would you take? Dusty or Juddy?

    When you think about it, Richmond's 2 Premierships have been the back of overwhelming home ground advantage, a generally weak comp, a smattering of stars and the rest role players. Their list doesn't compare favorably with any premiership list in living memory, yet they've won 2 in 3 years...
  24. Papa G

    Who would you take? Dusty or Juddy?

    An indictment on just how weak the comp is at the moment.
  25. Papa G

    Who would you take? Dusty or Juddy?

    The competition feels so much weaker these days. There aren't any great teams. The fact that players like Jack Reiwoldt and Trent Cotchin are considered stars tell you all you need to know. Counts against Dusty a bit.
  26. Papa G

    Which grand final do you rate as the best of this millennium so far?

    01, 02, 04, 05, 06, 08, 09, 10(first), 11, 12, 16, 18 are all games which were of high quality or close. About a 60% strike rate of good grand finals.
  27. Papa G

    Which rivalry would you rate as the biggest in the AFL?

    Pretty sure the skivvied reporter at the start there is famous cricket reporter/author Mike Coward.
  28. Papa G

    Which rivalry would you rate as the biggest in the AFL?

    89 was Port v North Adelaide. Port destroyed North. The joke always was that North went into that game with "one goal in mind.. " because they only kicked 1 goal for the match. Dont remember it being particularly violent though. The 91 GF between North and West was pretty vicious.
  29. Papa G

    Which rivalry would you rate as the biggest in the AFL?

    Glenelg only played in a GF twice up until 1969, but from that point on, they became a league heavyweight making the grand final 12 times between 1969 and 1992. Of those 12 GFs they faced Port 5 times and lost all 5. So you can see why they hated us. Despite their lack of success the Bays...
  30. Papa G

    Which rivalry would you rate as the biggest in the AFL?

    Every Showdown is a big game. Regardless of where we sit on the ladder. That's the point you seem to be missing. As a Port supporter I have no interest in having a rivalry with Collingwood, because there really isn't one (although many Port supporters are still aggreived about the Black n...
Back
Top