1999 Draft re-done

[GrandBlue]

This is the '99 draft re-done isn't it? As far as 'm aware, Brown was a father son, so would go in exactly the same position as he did last time... that's why I didn't include him. If you wanna simply express the best 10 from that draft, I'd have him number 2.

Re Ling, I see you what you're saying, and that's fair enough. I coudn't fit him in the top 10 either. I was just picking a bone with your earlier comments, which were fairly unreasonable.

In my OP, I said F/S picks included. That would also mean Reece Shaw.

Re Ling: I acknowledge Ling is a good player. I was just returning a challenge to dyertribe.

 

[doondoon]

Assuming Brown is available.

1. Brown
2. Pavlich
3. Corey
4. Chapman
5. Hille
6. O'Keefe
7. Glass
8. Davis
9. Bateman
10. Gilbee.

finally someone worked out bateman was in that draft

 

[careyrips(I)]

Id say he, is not because im a collingwood supporter but because he is the best ruckman to come out of that year. Every team needs a good ruckman

 

[Bombers1234]

Id say he, is not because im a collingwood supporter but because he is the best ruckman to come out of that year. Every team needs a good ruckman

Hille has had a better career i would say

 

[eliminator28]

1. Jonathan Brown
2. Matthew Pavlich
3. Joel Corey
4. Ryan O'Keefe
5. Lindsay Gilbee
6. Joel Corey
7. Darren Glass
8. Robert Murphy
9. Paul Chapman
10. David Hille

 

[HolyRioli]

1. Matthew Pavlich
2. Darren Glass
3. Jonathon Brown
4. Paul Chapman
5. Joel Corey
6. Brett Kirk (was elevated from the rookie list that year, does this count?)
7. Cameron Ling
8. Ryan O'Keefe
9. David Hille
10. Chance Bateman


Honorable mentions to Gia, Gilbee, Murphy (sorry doggies supporters!), Davis and Bruce.

In regards to the poll, Josh Fraser is a muppet. Has 2-3 great games a season, and coasts the rest.

 

[Chops_a_must]

Haselby and McPharlin criminally under rated in this thread. And Hille is being massively over rated on the back of one very good year.

Obviously Hase was not the best mid to come out of that draft, but would still be in the best half dozen I would imagine. What could have been if he didn't have a serious back operation (spinal fusion I'm 99% sure) at the end of his first season.

But geez... how good was that draft for KPPs? ****. Best ever just about. And Collingwood just about got the worst.

 

[WN123]

1/ J Brown
2/ M Pavlich
3/ J Corey
4/ P Chapman
5/ D Hille
6/ L Gilbee
7/ R O'Keeffe
8/ P Haselby
9/ C Bateman
10/ R Murphy

Done on the basis of who I would pick if this draft was done again tomorrow. How well did Geelong and the Bulldogs do out of this draft.